According to PRIZM, "lifestyle segmentation system," Gothamist lives in areas that can be defined as:

Urban Gold Coast
Young Literati
Bohemian Mix
Gray Power
Urban Achievers
Single City Blues
Hispanic Mix

That seems about right: Gothamist is schizophrenic. [Via The Observer, which breaks down other NY neighborhoods... Gothamist plugged in its New Jersey hometown and came up with Blue Blood Estates - eek]