A subway ad that has upset more than a few passengers has been removed, after the MTA decided it violated its advertising policies (PDF).
@NYCMayorsOffice @NYCTSubway my child should not have 2see this ad of a girl's #death to sell a "hayride" #Halloween. #wrong #dobetter pic.twitter.com/KTsM8xCwB2
— Mason Bendewald (@MasonBendewald) September 25, 2016
The ad, promoting a Haunted Hay Ride attraction on Randall's Island, is still running on trains, but not for long. WNYC reports that after it made inquiries, the transit agency said, "MTA has determined the ad violates our ad policy - specifically that it is 'so violent, frightening, or otherwise disturbing as to reasonably be deemed harmful to minors' and we have instructed our advertising contractor to have the ad pulled immediately."
The MTA doesn't approve ads on the subway—its advertising contractor, Outfront Media, does—and while political ads are currently banned, other provocative ads are allowed. For instance, the ads for Thinx, the "period" underwear offended MTA chairman Thomas Prendergast, but still ran.
Ad on NYC subway for haunted hayride portrays woman strangled with head in a bag...Yeah, hayride+killing women=fun? pic.twitter.com/LI1G8aOqFZ
— Jen Harris (@JenHarr99) October 5, 2016
I hate the ad for NY Haunted Hayride, a throttled woman in a plastic bag with rope around her neck. Stop promoting violence against women.
— maddie (@sincerelylcohen) October 4, 2016
.@MTA Who approved the ads for the NY Haunted Hayride? I don't think commuters should be forced to stare @ images of brutality against women pic.twitter.com/Wl9kUC3HrU
— Jessica (@blushindressing) October 12, 2016
fun Halloween ad - subway. Young woman with a clear plastic bag over her head, garroted by rope. #HauntedHayride.com pic.twitter.com/XJkOsnV3xX
— Terry Kinney (@RealTerryKinney) September 22, 2016
@MTA nothing says 'haunted hayride' like a homicide crime scene photo. Bonus points for the misogyny pic.twitter.com/FfBx9doBXP
— Peter Duffy (@DuffmanTweets) September 27, 2016
.@MTA #hauntedhayride this is a very inappropriate subway ad. You can sell Halloween without a dead woman's body pic.twitter.com/5vWCIOqbMJ
— lizzie logan (@lizzzzzielogan) September 27, 2016
MTA board member Charles Moerdler told WNYC, "In my view, [the haunted hayride ad] demonstrates not just a lack of taste, but a clear absence of taste. Unfortunately, under the case law as it's been coming down from the federal court of appeals, there's not much the MTA can do about it."
Last year, the MTA allowed Amazon to completely cover the S shuttle train between Times Square and Grand Central Terminal with Nazi-imagery ads for their fantasy series Man In the High Castle, which imagines the world if Axis powers won World War II. Amazon eventually decided to pull them.