Before he had ever spent any substantial time in restaurant kitchens, the chef Michael Psilakis went to college and earned an accounting degree. Oddly, it was a fluke, part-time post-graduation waitering gig at a T.G.I. Fridays that first convinced him that he should be a chef and restaurateur. His father Gus had always been a generous culinary daredevil, having built a spit in the backyard for roasting whole lamb, and he imparted a strong love of home cooked food. At the same time, Psilakis' mom taught him the basics of classic Greek cuisine, so it's not unusual that his new restaurant—just opened in the original Kefi space—combines comfort food like homemade potato chips and choices like smokey tomato soup with made-from-scratch versions of riblets and tater tots.
Gus & Gabriel, named for Psilakis' late father and young son, is a treehouse of a restaurant. Psilakis designed the interior, which notably includes a penny farthing bicycle and a suit of armor that's bound to be stared at by kids for a really long time. Food-wise, Psilakis has made an honest, small plates menu out of the entire Applebee's oeuvre, and it turns out that's not a bad thing: those potato chips are made from scratch, as are the "crab & fish sticks." With the latter, don't expect perfectly molded rectangular fried nuggets of the Gorton's persuasion. Don't expect something haute or overly-styled, either: Psilakis is interesting in making food from scratch, and food that tastes good, not museum pieces and plates painted with sauces.
While there are a few vegetarian options, the menu is meat heavy, and carefully prepared at that: chicken wings are smoked for 20 minutes and hit with sauce for good measure; fried chicken is brined for two days. The pastrami is made in house. The burger ($11.50) is a mix of 70 % dry-aged beef and 30% regular, and may well turn out to be a contender in the ever-raging city burger sweepstakes. Nothing on the Gus & Gabriel menu costs more than $14.95. 50 beers and 70 whiskeys round out the menu, and spirits can be ordered by the flask in 8 oz. quantities. Your flask, when unfinished by the meal's end, will be stowed away behind the bar for subsequent visits. Below, the opening menu, nachos and all.
Gus & Gabriel // 222 West 79th Street // (212) 362-7470
Beer Snacks
Hot Potato Chips 3.95
Sour Cream, caramelized onion, garlic & chive dip
Pretzel Nuggets 3.95
Honey mustard glaze
Spicy Pickled Fries 3.95
Mayonnaise
Onion Rings 3.95
BBQ sauce
BBQ Pork, Cheddar & Jalapeño “Tater Tots" 3.95
Spicy BBQ sauce
Appetizers
American Salad 7.95
Romaine, bacon, hard-boiled egg, carrot, red onion, crouton, cheddar, cherry tomato, red & green peppers
Choice of Dressing: garlic ranch ~ Italian ~
blue cheese ~ roasted tomato, onion & bacon
Chili 6.95
Aged cheddar, scallion, sour cream,
chipotle-scallion-jalapeño corn bread
Buttered Sweet Corn &
Jalapeño Soup 5.95
Crème fraîche, Pecorino Romano, chive
French Onion Soup 6.50
Sourdough crouton, gruyère
Black Bean Soup 5.95
Sour cream, cilantro, avocado
Glazed Pork “Riblets” 7.95
Sherry, honey, molasses
Nachos (for two) 9.95
Chili, refried beans, guacamole, sour cream, salsa
Crab & Fish Sticks 7.95
Tartar sauce
Mexi Mac & Cheese 7.50
Monterey Jack & cheddar, jalapeño béchamel, sour cream, salsa
Potato Skins 7.95
Chili, aged cheddar, Monterey jack, bacon, sour cream
Spicy BBQ Chicken Wings 8.95
Blue cheese, celery, carrot
Entrees
Burger 11.50
French fries
Bacon & Cheddar Burger 12.95
French fries
Smoked Tomato, Garlic Confit & Mozzarella Burger 12.95
French fries
Roasted Mushroom, Caramelized Onion & Gruyère Burger 12.95
French fries
Fried Egg, Bacon, Onion Rings & Gruyère Burger 13.95
French fries
Beef Brisket French Dip 11.95
Gruyère, caramelized onions, beef jus, French fries
Two House~made Hot Dogs 10.95
French fries
Two Chili & Cheese Hot Dogs 12.95
French fries
Meatball “Parmigiano” Hero 13.95
Sautéed onion & bell pepper, provolone, mozzarella, tomato, spaghetti
Grilled Beef Ribs 14.95
Beef jus, mashed potatoes
Meatloaf 11.95
Roasted mushroom & onion, mashed potatoes
Pulled Pork Cuban 12.95
Monterey jack, pepperoncini, pickles, sauerkraut, mustard, French fries
Crispy Fried Chicken 13.95
Biscuits, giblet gravy, mashed potatoes
BBQ Roasted Pork Butt 13.95
Onion rings, coleslaw, mashed potatoes
Hot Turkey Sandwich 12.95
Gruyère, bacon, gravy, mashed potatoes
BLT Grilled Cheese 10.95
Bacon, cheddar, smoked tomato, romaine, mayo
Baked Ziti 11.95
Mozzarella, ricotta, tomato
Fish & Chips 12.95
French fries