We love comedian Billy Eichner, but we know his unique brand of mocha caffeinated man-on-the-street comedy can be overwhelming for some. Which is why a sweet dose of Amy Poehler makes it go down all the better. Eichner and Poehler took to lower Manhattan in the video below for a very frantic attempt at caroling with complete strangers—many of whom don't recognize them, most of whom don't know the words.

The best parts: the person who thinks "Happy Birthday" is a Christmas carol, when Poehler tells a stranger who doesn't recognize her that "you know me," and when the two meet a baby named Arrow and Eichner responds in justified disgust, "No, no, not dealing with that bullshit."