Quantcast

Did A Food Network Star Steal Recipes Or Is It A Slow News Day?

021612desserts.jpg The front page of the New York Post today is all about a pastry chef whose show, "Dessert First," was canceled because her recipes were allegedly not so fresh. STOP THE PRESSES! Headline: "Food Network's 'Dessert First' star axed in recipe-copy flap: sources." The sources, as usual, are unidentified, and the "exclusive" is actually based on a single source, not plural sources, but why get bogged down in trivial details when you can lead with: "This puff-pastry princess is a purported plagiarist"? We don't want to egg on the Post, but this whipped-up scandal seems a little half-baked!

Pastry chef Anne Thorton's show ran for two seasons on the Food Network, and a spokesman for the channel tells the tabloid, "Anne’s show, ‘Dessert First,’ was not renewed after its second season purely due to ratings/performance." But the Post's source says Thorton got canceled because "many of her recipes were close — with only a few minor edits — to other chefs’ recipes."

But is any of this true, and do you care? (After all, there isn't a famous comedian mixed up in this one.) When a Post reporter got her on the phone, Thorton said, "This is all news to me. I get inspiration from all my heroes. You take what you learn from them and then you riff on that. As for lemon squares, there’s only so many ways you can make them, so of course there will be similarities. The same thing with baking or frosting — there are only so many ways you can do it." It's like coming up with a front page story for a tabloid day after day—there are only so many ways you can cook a cow pie and call it manna. Read the whole smear for yourself, then go stick your head an oven.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • People still read the Post?

  • Sluggo1407

    This is the Post's front page story?  How pathetic!!!

  • DonPancho

    This is news?

    Food Network plagiarizes every big-busted gal who can't cook. It's their own creepy version of natural selection. 

  • whiteiris

    "but why get bogged down in trivial details"  You mean like you, Robbins and Gothamist when it comes to the NY Post or any Republican candidate?

    As for Food Networks decision, it's absurd. You can't copyright a recipe. Rachael Ray is the queen of taking 2 recipes and putting them together and calling it her own ie Stoup.

    "But is any of this true, and do you care?"  You obviously do.

  • every chef knows that once they put a recipe in a book or on tv someone is going to steal it... but to do it on tv.. thats some set she got. 

  • whitecastlerock

    Every day is a slow news day at Gothamist–that is until the latest edition of the NY Post is available...

  • David

    She had a weird eye mole anyway. Bad for tv.

  • TheRealCannibal

    oh god, just cut her head off

  • How do you even plagiarize a recipe? Is the person who invented apple pie going to sue you?

  • BottomlessChips

    You can't copyright recipes. This is a non-story.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com