Quantcast

Man Disagrees With Birth Certificate That Says He's A Woman

201202_ladymarine.jpg
File photo of a totally unrealistic lady marine, NOT the ex-marine in question (Maksim Shmeljov / shutterstock)

Does it matter what gender is on your birth certificate? Apparently only sometimes. A 29-year-old ex-Marine is suing the city because since 2003 it has refused to acknowledge that he is not a she, no matter what his birth certificate says.

The problem, the Post reports, started at Lenox Hill Hospital (where Blue Ivy Carter popped out) when David Hassan was born. Though nobody noticed it at the time, the hospital marked his sex as female. It really didn't matter until 2003, when Hassan came home on leave and lost his ID. When he applied for a new one, a clerk wouldn't give it to him because, well, Hassan was a man.

The only way to get an ID for Hassan would be to have Lenox Hill acknowledge their mistake. But it won't do that "for liability reasons" (though it acknowledges the gender on the certificate should be changed). And without Lenox Hill saying it done wrong, Hassan can't get a new birth certificate. "I am caught between two self-serving bureaucracies and need the intervention of this court to tell one, the other or both to do the right thing," Hassan's court filing says.

It wouldn't really be a problem except that Hassan now needs to get a driver's license in New Jersey for a grad program at Rutgers...and can't get one without a birth certificate. The man just wants to drive a car!

Sadly, these things happen (and have been happening) for ages. We knew a woman whose alma mater still, almost fifty years after she graduated, believes she is a he—though she lived in a women's dorm when she attended and was most certainly not a he (let's just say she was our mother).

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • jwcbklyn

    When I first got my driver's license the DMV incorrectly put me down as female. I had to make a pretty emasculating trip back to the DMV to beg for official recognition of my teenage manhood (is that form GV-678F or form G78-PFF7?), but they recognized the mistake and fixed it without any trouble. Didn't even have to drop trou.

  • Peanut_Butter

    You could've said to the clerk I'll show you mine if you'll show me yours.

  • smalll

    Can we turn this into a fight over transex/transgender somehow?  Those are always fun.

  • cr17

    What's with his parents that they never did anything about it when he was a kid?

  • His mother always wanted a daughter....

  • Peanut_Butter

    Face looks like a dude but the pose is kinda hot.

  • The_Bork_Man

    I guess he has no choice but to sue someone now, even though it seems he tried to avoid being a dick about this whole thing...

  • da_phonz

     I guess they expected him to be a 'pussy'. bu dum dum!

  • What liabilities are there to if Lenox Hill were to admit the error? 

  • nunyadamn

    Probably none due to statue of limitations and no real issues regarding the mistake until now.

  • Is anyone capable of admitting a mistake anymore?  Or do we always have to worry about potentially being sued?

  • petey2

     thats pretty much the problem. many people are unwilling or unable to take responsibility for anything. Its a bad codependency.

  • sauerkrautcity

    not as long as we got shmucks like Binder & Binder in their stupid fucking hats

  • My birth certificate says my mom was 7, not 27. It hasnt hindered me but maybe one day...

  •  Pete = secret Kenyan.

  • Damn! Your mom developed early!

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com