Top 10 Lies Told By Ray Kelly's NYPD: A Retrospective
("And here's where the suspect allegedly chopped down a cherry tree.")
Today's non-startling revelation that NYPD spokesman Paul Brownelied about Commissioner Ray Kelly's involvement in an anti-Islam propaganda documentary got us thinking about some of the other times the NYPD was less than forthright. Come, friend, take a stroll down Prevarication Lane, where the untruths grow like toxic mushrooms along the banks of the Browne's babbling Bullshit Brook:
Browne Lies About Officer Getting Punched Before Councilmember's Arrest: City Councilmember Jumaane Williams said today that Browne's statements on the anti-Islam documentary are "far from the first time that he has displayed his penchant for questionable judgment, continual misrepresentation of events or blatant lying. I have seen this firsthand." Williams, who wants Browne fired, was referring to the mysterious man who allegedly punched an NYPD officer in the face at last year's West Indian Day parade, which Browne cited as justification for the arrests of Williams and another city official. This non-existent man who supposedly punched a cop was never arrested. Williams was.
NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly Says The NYPD Doesn't Have Quotas, Just "Productivity Goals": Yeah, that's the ticket. Goals, not quotas. And cops can shoot down planes, too! We suppose you could call this semantic spin, not lying, but last year a jury decided the NYPD had a policy "regarding the number of arrests officers were to make." Denying this whatever you call it is not very truthy, is it?
Video Evidence Contradicts Browne's Sworn Deposition: In the transcript of a deposition [pdf] conducted in 2008 for a lawsuit filed by the 5 Borough Bike Club, Browne said he'd only attended one Critical Mass ride; a small one he visited near Columbus Circle. This video shows Browne working another Critical Mass ride, which took place on the eve of the Republican Convention in 2004 and resulted in the arrest of hundreds of cyclists. Same Browne, different day!
NYPD Lies To Naomi Wolf, Then Arrests Her:Author and activist Naomi Wolf says that cops were telling Occupy Wall Street protesters they weren't allowed to be on the sidewalk outside an event space—where Governor Cuomo was receiving an award from the Huffington Post—but protesters actually were allowed to be there, because she checked the permit. When Wolf made a stink about the Constitution or whatever, they arrested her.
Browne Lies About Officer Being Elbowed Before Decking OWS Protester: The NYPD's spokesman claims that this Occupy Wall Street protester elbowed a cop before the cop punched him in the face, but we broke this story and can confirm there was no physical provocation preceding the punch, just a "dirty look." And none of the various videos show any elbowing. "On the off chance they were intending to arrest him for injuring the captain's fist with his jaw, I strongly suggest that you decide not to add insult to injury and avoid such a retaliatory move," attorney Ron Kuby wrote in a letter to the NYPD and the Manhattan DA's office.
Cops Plant Drugs to Make Arrest Quotas: A former NYPD Detective testified last year that he regularly saw police plant drugs on innocent people as a way to meet arrest quotas, er "productivity goals." Apparently, planting drugs is so common that when the drug is cocaine, they call it "flaking." Is this technically lying, or just sinister deception? Or maybe the NYPD planted pot in our lunch and now we're paranoid???
Police Commissioner Kelly shows reporters the kind of bomb that a self-circumcising stoner may have wanted to build. SCARY! (AP)
Kelly and Bloomberg Sensationalize Stoner's "Terror Threat": At the height of the bad press surrounding the NYPD's heavy-handed handling of Occupy Wall Street, Kelly and Bloomberg held a big press conference to announce the arrest of terror suspect Jose Pimentel, a local stoner who allegedly had vague plans to build a bomb. But the FBI's refusal to take the case based on "holes" and entrapment issues—as well as the revelation that Pimentel was mentally unstable and had attempted to circumcise himself— have many wondering if Pimentel was ever a serious threat. File this one in the shadowy border land where fearmongering meets fibbing.
The NYPD Doesn't Spy On Muslims: No, really! "We don't racially profile, we follow leads wherever those leads take us," Kelly told the City Council during a hearing about the NYPD's broad surveillance of Muslim communities, which was revealed in a series of damning Associated Press articles. In 2002, the AP reports, veteran CIA division head David Cohen came out of retirement to run a secretive NYPD intelligence team, and the NYPD has acknowledged that it sends undercover officers into ethnic and Muslim neighborhoods to act like "a human camera" and "map the human terrain" in mosques, hookah bars, and Internet cafes. But Kelly insists, "We don't do it ethnically, we do it geographically." And if you believe that, there's a bridge the NYPD would like to sell you.
NYPD Lied About Existence of "HipHop Task Force": And finally, an old school goodie from way back in 2004, when NYPD brass repeatedly denied the existence of an intelligence squad that kept tabs on rap stars and their entourages. Then the NYPD admitted it, after the Miami Herald reported that at least one NYPD officer had traveled to Miami to liaison with cops preparing for the Source Awards. Nice work if you can get it!
Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.
Journalism - writing characterized by a direct presentation of facts or description of events without an attempt at interpretation. The Gothamist seems to be interpreting the news for us, not letting fair minded people interpret for themselves. Is this story biased?
CityFace
Is this blog entry pretending to be dryly reporting facts and not to have an opinion on the subject matter? I say thee nay. It is not biased in the way you mean, because it is not claiming a status of, say, "we report, you decide." Besides, you saw through it, didn't you? You seem to be interpreting it just fine.
i'm still waiting for the explanation of why photos of the family and their lawyer were in the file of the bicyclist that was killed in a hit and run
edgie186
Bloomberg can go and take Kelly with him.
napalm2
No matter how bad the NYPD misbehaves, whether its civil rights violations, manipulating crime stats, racial profiling, murdering unarmed minorities and even the individual cases with rape-cops etc, Bloomberg will always reach for his disposable $green slips$ that have been working magic by getting rid of problems that the average citizen would face harsh disciplinary actions for.
You can bet that THIS particular problem will disappear before you know it. Nothing to see hear!
Here's the metadata on Ray Kelly in relationship to his financial, duly noted and obliquely referenced on google scholar in gory detail. http://scholar.google.com/scho...
The NYPD needs to come under the the oversight of the Dept of Justice due to all of its civil rights violations. There is currently NO oversight and the City Council could at least be doing some of it but it has chosen to abdicate its responsibility in order to play a submissive role servicing the mayor's egomania. You fail to mention the stop and frisk policy in minority neighborhoods to make pot arrests - WNYC did a whole series on this - I believe this is part of the revenue quotas, er productivity goals on revenue targets the NYPD has to bring in.. Though whites and upper middle class whites consume more drugs in terms of street value, the NYPD is doing this to minorities because of race, stereotypes that exist against minority youth and because they can extract monies and meet their revenue and arrest quotas and most people are not going to file suit against the City.. you can't do this repeatedly against coke head son of business executive or lawyer from the UES and get away with it..
Nor do you mention the lies from Kelly leading up to the 2004 Republican convention and the infiltration of anti-war organizations and the mass pre-emptive arrests. Kelly and Brown have to go and strong man Bloomberg needs to be held to account.
BoogieDown
To be fair, Gothamist does a lot of coverage of the NYPD's bullshit stop and frisk policies in low-income neighborhoods. You're absolutely right about the whom the police choose to target though. They're not going to go after the cocaine-addled exec's son because these types of people are believed to have a better understanding of their rights under the law. Poor blacks and Hispanics, not so much.
Emmily_Litella
How can this be? He raised his son to be a respected journalist. Why his son risked his life in I-rack as a reporter for state media.
BoogieDown
Yes, and now he can add accused rapist to his resumé. What a guy, that Greg Kelly.
Bernie_Geotz_Squirrel_Luv
You can fool some of the people some of the time.....
picaflor
Browne is a conniving and sinister sack of shit
jibbly
That's insulting to sacks of shit everywhere.
69Reality69
Don't forget the completely pervasive corruption - with a department full of drug dealers, armed robbers, pimps, and even hit men being "policed" by an IAD designed to cover the real crimes up. Kelly and the rest of the brass claim the constant stream of busted cops are "bad apples" when everyone inside knows that the corruption is everywhere and the entire cop culture depends on the "blue wall of silence" (lying) to cover it up.
If there has ever been a time when this city needed Federal takeover of the NYPD it's now.
randomtransplant
You know the theory that Batman is bad for Gotham because Gotham becomes too dependent on him & his bat-shit crazy psychosis's?
That wasn't just filler.
New York is like Egypt or Pakistan - no matter what happens in the election, the army still calls the shots.
Spirit of 76
He's okay. Just needs a new job title. I vote for NYPD information minister. Baghdad Brownie!
Fronko
We need term limits for police commissioners more than we need them for mayors.
Spirit of 76
Commissioners aren't elected. They're appointed by the mayor and can be fired at any time.
Fronko
I understand. But we could still place limits on how long commissioners can serve following their appointment. Ray Kelly's NYPD is a government unto itself, answerable to no one.
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.
Want Gothamist's suggestions on what shows to check out, where to eat, what to buy, where to go for a quick trip? We'll be bringing you some exclusive tips and ideas via email every day! And don't worry—you'll still get a list of our top stories.
Sign up for Gothamist Daily, which will deliver useful tips—plus Gothamist's most popular stories—to your inbox at 11 a.m. This way, you'll be able to plan your week or month as well as catch up on Gothamist if you've stepped away.