Quantcast

Fatal Stamford Fire: Smoldering Embers Were Left In Bag By The House

Stamford, Connecticut officials shared details about the fatal Christmas Day house fire that claimed the lives of three young girls and their grandparents: It seems that still-smoldering embers from a Yule log were placed in a bag and left by the house, and those embers caused the blaze that consumed much of the three-story home. Officials ruled out foul play and Fire Marshal Barry Callahan said, "The origin was determined to be on the first floor rear corner of the house in the immediate area of a mudroom and trash bin enclosure."

The home, a $1.725 million Victorian with views of Long Island Sound, was bought by NYC fashion branding executive Madonna Badger last year and she had initiated extensive renovations for the home, which she shared with her three young daughters, Lily, 9 and twins Grace and Sarah, 7. On Christmas Eve, Badger, her daughters, her parents and family friend (also referred to as her boyfriend), the home's contractor, Michael Borcina, were celebrating the holiday; authorities say that after 3 a.m., Borcina emptied embers from the fireplace and placed them in the bag. According to the NY Times:

Less than two hours later, firefighters were called to the scene. The first ladder crew found Ms. Badger on a second-floor scaffold, which had been placed there as part of continuing renovations. As the crew helped her down, Ms. Badger directed firefighters to the third floor, where she said her children were sleeping, according to the Stamford fire chief, Antonio J. Conte.

Mr. Borcina told fire officials he had tried to flee with two of the girls. But, perhaps in the chaos of the smoke and flames, the girls seem to have panicked and turned around, Chief Conte said. One of the girls ran back upstairs, and the other was found with her grandmother on the stairs between the second and third floors.

Badger's father, Lomer Johnson, a retired safety director who had been the Saks Fifth Avenue Santa Claus this Christmas, apparently tried to get one of his granddaughters out, but died in the process. The Stamford Advocate has the heartwrenching details:

Conte said Johnson made a "valiant effort" to bring the girl out of a window in the rear of home, but Johnson, 71, a former safety chief at a Kentucky liquor company, was overwhelmed by the intense blaze and died along with his granddaughters and 69-year-old wife Pauline.

Johnson was able to stack some books by the window for his granddaughter to step on, but when he fell onto the roof face first where he was found later by firefighters, he perished. "When he stepped through that window his life ended," Conte said. One of the girls was found on the stack of books.

Johnson, his wife Pauline, and the three girls died from smoke inhalation. Badger and Borcina survived—Badger was rescued from second-floor scaffolding, where she had been trying to reach her daughters, and Borcina reportedly had to be restrained by firefighters from re-entering the home, which was entirely on fire. The Post has a graphic showing the home and what apparently happened during the fire.

City officials also revealed that the family technically should not have been residing in the house, because the renovated parts of the home (including much of the second floor) had not been approved for final occupancy. But they stressed that the work done by Borcina—the most recent inspections were in June—appeared to be proper. Stamford Mayor Michael Pavia added that Badger had recently "changed the building permit to include plans for the installation of a new security alarm and fire and smoke detection system," but it did not appear that the hard-wired system was activated and it was unclear whether the home had any battery-operated smoke detectors.

Borcina spoke to the Post from his hospital room and said, "We’re all going to be OK." The Post adds, "Borcino, his voice weak and his conversation interrupted by coughs, said he and Badger 'need and have the love and support of our friends... They are surrounding us and taking care of us. I’m going to be OK.'.. She’s going to be OK. We’re all going to be OK. We’re taking care of ourselves physically and spiritually."

Badger was separated from her husband, Manhattan resident Matthew Badger, and had initiated divorce proceedings. No funeral arrangements have been announced for their daughters; Lomer and Pauline Johnson will be buried in Canada. The home was torn down, because it was structurally unsafe.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • zenobiaznb
    Bad things happen accidently all the time in life people! No criminal intent here. Why are folks so judgmental as if they are perfect!!
  • Still lit embers in a bag? No smoke alarms? Negligence, Not registered to perform home improvements in the state? The grandfather had a blunt trauma head injury?The mother is saying all I have to hold onto is "that love is everything" ?   Have to say that this did not seem accidental to me from the first I heard of it. Placing still lit embers in a bag on what appears to be a wooden porch is not something many children would do much less a grown adult. Also dangerous or not I think the house was torn down way too quickly for a complete and thorough investigation. We're all going to be okay? They're dead,they're not going to be okay.
  • EarsWideOpen
    Also your blog sucks. http://www.dearoneshealingmini...
  • Thanks for the 'platform', EarsWideOpen. The Lord has given me a daunting mission which I have chosen to fulfill and that is to be a clergy-person-OPENLY-in the world today.  I'm out and proud!  Since I've ended up here, you might as well check out my latest article:  http://dearoneshealingministry...  You should also be sure to check out 'Rev. Cari Jackson/FCC Stamford & all the other gay UCC stuff you are likely to be interested in on GOOGLE or via the search engine of your choice.  Check out my Google 'profile'. I've been there & sacrificed much for the 'O & A' struggle, not to mention 'Civil Rights'-and will continue to do so!  I understand your distaste for clergy and those who question the LGBT movement.  But I forgive you for this and will keep an open mind, for I have many LGBT persons in my life whom I love dearly.  And love always prevails, doesn't it?  Hatred and petty comments and negative intentions do not!  I forgive & understand what you are saying, 'EarsWideOpen' (and 'PrettyAmiable', too) for the 'God-hating' you so openly manifest.  For 37 years I was an atheist/agnostic myself, although I didn't quite have the hatred that you do.  Perhaps you have reasons that I am unaware of.  I've learned to not take things 'personally' and  will love you anyway, as God does. Thanks & gratitude to 'Gothamist' for this unusual and unexpected opportunity to speak about these things.  I had no idea what this forum was all about before I commented on the Christmas Day Stamford fire. Happy New Year & Many Blessings To You All-Love, Rev, Barb
  • Scavenger333
    You're a crappy witness for your faith: your words and tone have turned me away. If this is the "blessed change" that has been wrought by your finding faith, then I reject your faith. I don't want to become like you. You're a false prophet and use faith as a smoke screen for bias. You can best serve your faith by not engaging others but rather by turning that "need to plead" inward; it definitely is creating an opposite effect from the one you are seeking. Clean up your own soul before you go sweeping others' steps.

    Your presumption, pride and boastfulness is, well ...revolting.

    Oh, p.s.: take this personally. It was intended as such.
  • I forgive you, Scavenger333. God Bless You-Rev. Barb Edited here: However, now that I have learned you are on record as having a problem with 'white women' (to quote you " Multiple women all pulling a "Heidi." -Scavenger333 link: http://gothamist.com/2011/10/0... ) in defense of the alleged Riverside Park Rapist..and having back-ground checked you, I would like to publicly request that you keep your distance from me and my loved ones in all respects, Scavenger333 Thanks!-Rev. Barb
  • Scavenger333
    Jesus Christ you're thick. Re: the Riverside Rapist article: Grok sarcasm much? Yeah, no, thought not. Seriously, THAT'S what passes for a thorough "background check" with you? To correct your comment to EarsWideOpen, you are, in fact, pretty stupid. You cannot even parse the written word.

    But hey, if your complete and utter lack of reading comprehension serves to keep your bigoted, phony, holier-than-thou, clueless self far from me, then vaya con dios asshat.

    P.S. wanna guess my gender and ethnicity for bonus points?
  • EarsWideOpen
    I dont know why I feel the compulsion to keep responding to you, Reverend, but clearly you have a problem understanding either nuance or perhaps simply the english language. SMH...
  • EarsWideOpen: You respond to me because you know I am not stupid.  I respond TO YOU because I know that you do, indeed, have a heart.  In fact, I'd be willing to bang on BOTH of our chests...just to prove that NEITHER ONE OF US is perfect, or anywhere near it . Thanks for having me have to  'google'  'SMH', btw.  Blessings to you-Rev. Barb
  • bkk8
    What a horrible, yet avoidable tragedy.  The family should not have been occupying the floors of the house if there were no smoke detectors or better yet, a sprinkler system given the age and style of that house.  That Borcina guy is a creep and who the hell puts fireplace embers in a bag outside in the trash - something very fishy about that.  You take the screen and put it flat against the fireplace at night so nothing could accidentally pop out of the fireplace onto a rug, etc.  I don't believe for a second that he led two of the girls out and then they ran away!  I wouldn't have let them out of my grip but then again, I don't believe he went back into the house at all. He is just saying that now to deflect the issue of his leaving the ashes in a bag - what a guy!  I just finished renovation on a house built the same year as the Badger house and we have smoke detectors, - nobody was allowed to sleep there before they were put in.  Isn't this guy supposed to be a "contractor." Sleaze.  Now this beautiful family is gone.  Absolutely heartbreaking.
  • OK !  I guess most people feel the same way i feel. Ironic  The contractor and his girlfriend r the only ones who survived this tragedy. Yes in a situation like a fire, how can u tell us u had the children and they broke away from u. Does this man have any children of his own, Is that mother Madonna a woman who got men issues, Did this guy want Madonna for his self so he set the house on fire, Hey keep in mind, he knows  her personal business, He knows that he will get paid,He wanted that woman for his self, he did not want to deal with the visitation right, and u know girls love their daddy's, He doesn't seem like a family man. Investigate that dude something ain't right, Shit he will be alright, sorry him and Madonna, they got plenty friends, wait a minute  does he still have smoke in his head, that woman lost her mother, father and all her children, It is not alright, She will need a whole lot of therapy. See how he's ready to move on, To the kids dad where ever he is I'm so sorry about your lost, Three beautiful angels went up to heaven. They got a hell of a welcome party in heaven, It rain like hell, Blessing to a family of 5 gone to soon.
  • dogbertt
    You could be right.
  • All I know is that I would die before leaving my children in a burning house. I don't care how loud she was yelling.
  • musili
    She was trapped on the scaffolding of the house, trying to get access to her daughter's room one floor above her own room, when firemen arrived and pulled her off, after which she had to be restrained.  It's not exactly like she was standing safely on the ground, half-heartedly yelling for her daughter to jump. Maybe she couldn't get to her daughter's room from inside the house because of the rapidly spreading fire.
  • I read a lot of articles before commenting but this is the first time I've heard this account. I know it's easy to judge from a distance but as a mother my impulse would be to get to my children or die trying.
  • musili
    I mis-read the floor (she was still on the second floor... check the graphic from the washington post linked in this article to see what her path was), but here's a quote from the article you commented on: "Badger was rescued from second-floor scaffolding, where she had been
    trying to reach her daughters."  

    This one quotes the press conference in which Badger is described as needing to be restrained.   http://www.courant.com/news/co...     The fire was already engulfing the house by the time the firemen arrived.      I get your impulse, but from the way things are laid out, I really think she had the same one.  Hope that's helpful
  • splicernyc
    And that's the difference between a real human being and someone who only cares about himself.
  • Billy Don
    I wonder if the DA is looking into these 5 deaths and the possiblity of criminal charges?
  • Jessica Jones
    At the very least, criminal negligence:

    http://www.jud.ct.gov/ji/crimi...
  • Something stinks here, and it ain't the burnt wood. Who moves hot embers?? who put them in a BAG?? Leaning against a house?? Who decides to have a cozy FIRE when you know the smoke detectors aren't connected?? Why is no one asking these questions? The two most able-bodied escape and leave 5 elderly and young behind to die - and no one thinks that's strange? Why did no one from the house call 911? The neighbors called, when they heard screaming - surely that lost precious minutes when someone could have been saved. This is so beyond a 'tragic accident', and NO one is talking about it or even asking questions!
  • splicernyc
    The police and fire investigators are asking these questions. Guaranteed.
  • Too often in this country we are more concerned with appearances and the sensitivities of others and their precious feelings instead of bringing out the truth however awful and painful it may be.  I am in favor of knowing the truth.
  • EastCoastMom
    That's a good question - why did no one from the house call 911?  Most people keep their cell phones close by, yet no one from the house called?  And Stamford officials certainly reached their conclusions quickly - so quickly that the house was torn down the very next day - ??  They seem rather anxious to wrap this up, yet there seem to be a lot of unanswered questions.
  • sk83r
    If she was black, shed be in jail on 5 counts of murder by now. Tell it to a judge.
  • Officials tearing down a crime scene quickly and avoiding a thorough and proper examination of evidence?  Not a good sign
  • I think one issue is that the structure was very unsafe and they were worried about curious people trying to access the house at night. Someone who lives down the street in Stamford told me there was a line of people waiting to look at the remains of the house.
  • That is not a valid reason to destroy evidence.  There are potentially dangerous sites all over.

    You put up police tape/barricades, even a chain link fence with barbed wire if necessary.  But you don't immediately order the destruction of evidence w/o another agenda.
  • How sad that people need to gawk at this.  If they were afraid of someone trying to sneak in then they should have taken steps to keep people out while preserving the scene to conduct a proper and thorough investigation.  Pathetic.
  • pete_mac
    Sorry, But If this was a Law and Order episode, no one would believe these two.
  • Mr. Borcina is a complete moron and caused the deaths of five people with his utter stupidity. As a contractor he should have made sure there were active smoke detectors in that house, let alone know that the safest place for hot embers is in a fireplace, not a paper or plastic bag. I don't buy his story of how he tried to lead those girls out. He panicked, plain and simple. From his interivew he sounds like a narcissist. He spoke about himself first.
  • M P
    You're right.  Sorry if this sounds harsh, but from the quotes he sounds like a real dick. Did you catch his first line: "I'm going to be OK".  Are you f'ing kidding me?  First, no one cares - in fact most of us wish we had the power to switch you with the kids / grandparents.  Second, no one believes that you ran back into the house.  He was leading the two girls out, and then they ran away?  Bull... if that had happened you go back in, at least to get one of them - assuming he was even in the house (which I don't believe) -  he just continues to safety without at least one kid?  What a piece of shit... too bad he doesn't have a conscience.
  • EastCoastMom
    I agree.  I would think that any child in such a situation would cling to an adult, not run away.  From photos I've seen, he looks like a pretty big guy...surely he could have held onto at least one of those girls.  It just doesn't add up...
  • whiteiris
    "I’m going to be OK.'.. She’s going to be OK."

    Um, no. You didn't lose your 3 kids nor your parents. She will never be ok.
  • GalBklyn
    After what he did -- how can he even think to speak on her behalf? Not to mention not one word of an apology to the family and all of the firefighters who risked their lives on Christmas morning. 

     Keep talking M.Bocino - so the whole world will know what a class A jerk you really are. That poor family never stood a chance.  How he is not criminally liable is beyond me.
  • Joey__Blow
    wow... I am pretty sure you are supposed to leave burning coals in the fire place.

    sad.
  • cr17
    I still don't understand why the yule log was removed from the fireplace in the first place.
  • sk83r
    The homeowners and life insurance money will pay for the rest of the renovation.
  • SonnyBobiche
    This is a case of remembering some safety tips but, ironically, following them so badly that you end up making it worse; much, much worse.

    It is recommended that a fireplace not be left unattended and before leaving the house or going to bed the still glowing embers should be scooped, placed in a METAL bucket and left OUTSIDE.  Putting them in a bag inside or near the house is so far removed from the intent of the advice that It is beyond belief.  

    If no metal bucket was available they should just have let the fire die out behind the metal screen. My siblings and I have three fireplaces in our homes and that's what we do.  For goodness sake, fireplaces are designed to contain fire, mudrooms are not! If the fireplace had no metal screen, no fire should have been lit in the first place.
  • SpideySense
    A truly heartbreaking story.
  • Elderta2
    This story gets more heartbreaking. Bag of embers? Really?

    Is there any update about the lady who was was killed on Eastern Parkway with the list of dreams note?
  • akrnyc
    Ditto your query about Donna Fountain, who was killed by a hit and run driver.  Has the NYPD made any progress yet??
    With this CT fire, the hit and run death, the Texas family massacre, the 7-year old girl brutally murdered by her babysitter in Indiana and the Bronx toddler killed by her father - this has been one truly depressing holiday week :(
  • Elderta2
    Jezebel has a story today about it today, but nothing much new. They suggest sending funds to an LGBT fund, as nothing has been set up for Elijah Fountain yet. http://jezebel.com/5871582/you...
  • Elderta2--This is not the time or place to promote politico-sexual politics.  Out of respect for those lost, for the grieving and for the firefighters suffering anguish at this time...you should consider removing your post above.  Have compassion and solicit money for your causes elsewhere.  God help you-Rev. Barbara Sexton, Stamford, CT
  • Elderta2
    Hahaha. Oh wow, I just saw this comment. What is it with all the trolls regarding this Connecticut housefire? In this thread and others, the troll is strong with this incident. Interesting.
  • Elderta2: "All these trolls?' Let me help you before you bring too much trouble to 'Gothamist'  -Rev. Barb
  • Christopher Palmer
    Excuse me, Rev, but the poster was merely echoing what was said in the article in the link. From where I am sitting you are the one putting their agenda on display, so knock it off.
  • This is not the place to solicit funding for LGBT, gay rights or any other 'agenda'.  Have some respect for the grieving and for those lost here. Rev. Barb, Stamford, CT
  • PrettyAmiable
    "God help you"? Thanks, but if your god is so hateful that he doesn't see the utility in paying respects to another recent victim, I'd rather not have his help. He's kind of an asshole.
  • I was a proud 'atheist/agnostic' for the first 37 yrs of my life, so I understand you at least a little bit..I think..Rev. Barb
  • Scavenger333
    How is sending money to a victim who was gay and whose note of dreams in her pocket included not only helping her son go to college but also meeting and marrying a wonderful woman "off subject?". Sending to a local LGBT fund IS appropriate, and does not "promote" ANY politics. The victim in question WAS gay. Whether you like it or not. And no, being an atheist/ agnostic for 37 years does not get you a bigot pass or endow you with some superior insight into others. If that was so, then I guess it would also be correct (in your twisted logic) for Rev. Fred Phelps to say that he "gets" you because he's just like like you in re: being a believer.

    Thing is, it's yourself that is showing prejudice. Thanks for showing me the fruit of your faith. I'll be avoiding such beliefs as a result. Such a good witness you are!
  • I wasn't consciously witnessing to YOU here (curious you would think so)...but obviously you ARE being 'winnowed'--a thing which is completely out of my hands.  You and your fellow God-haters ought to check out 'unpardonable sin'.  This here is an article about a tragic fire, persons lost and those who grieve--and you choose to defile it.  So be it. Instead of showing compassion and sympathy for all involved, you choose only to promote your Christianophobia and heterophobia, both of which are so popular nowadays. That's your choice, of course. Welcome to 'Gothamist' indeed! lol Rev. Barb
  • EarsWideOpen
    That's retarded. I'd also posit that this is not the time nor place to promote respect or compassion. Welcome to Gothamist :)
  • I'm sure Matthew has some choice words for Borcino at this moment....
  • SonnyBobiche
    What do you do or say to someone whose incompetence killed all of your children?

    I can just imagine Borcino saying "I heard that you shouldn't leave burning embers in the fireplace."  True, but that means putting them outside, away from the house in a fireproof container, imbecile!
  • They are not all going to be ok
  • Guest
    I was thinking the same thing.  They're going to need therapy.
blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com