Quantcast

9-Yr-Old Bronx Boy Dies After Choking On School Meatballs

201112_bronxps47.jpg
P.S. 47 in the Bronx (Google Maps).

Angela Jewth is living a parent's nightmare. Her only son, 9-year-old Jonathan, died Wednesday—nine days after a choking incident at his Bronx school left him clinging to life in the hospital. Now she is getting ready to sue the city to find out why it appears nobody at P.S. 47 knew how to properly clear the healthy boy's airways of a rogue meatball. "If something had been done differently, my son would've been alive today," Jewth told the Daily News.

Details about the December 5th incident are sketchy, and don't all match up. One moment Jonathan was laughing with his friends and then things seem to have gone wrong:

Witnesses have told investigators for the family that Jonathan was eating a meatball sandwich and leaving the cafeteria when he started choking.

One witness said three school employees, including a school nurse, were attempting to revive him using a defibrillator, flipping him from side to side, and performing CPR, according to the family attorney.

The witness "was shaken by what she observed and felt it necessary to yell instruction to the staff because they clearly did not know what they were doing,” the attorney's statement said.

Another witness says, "They sent for a teacher and then a teacher came, and a parent stepped forward to do the Heimlich, but by then the child was on the ground and it was too late."

According to a DOE report given to the boy's mother, the choking began at 12:15 p.m. and the NYPD was called at 12:16 p.m. But according to 911 records obtained by WNBC, "the 911 call reached EMS dispatchers at 12:29 p.m. and EMS and fire crews were on scene four minutes later." The boy reached the Jacobi Medical Center in critical condition at 12:48 p.m. He died nine days later.

Jonathan's mother, a housekeeper, says she has been troubled by the conflicting reports. "They're saying that they did everything, but others are saying that there was no one around at the time," she says. And so she is preparing a lawsuit in hopes of finding out exactly what happened.

Meanwhile, the DOE is staying mostly quiet about details of the incident beyond a statement from Schools Chancellor Dennis Walcott: "Tragically, a student passed away and my heart goes out to the family and the school community."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • tsol

    Don't they teach the Heimlich anymore?

  • CrumbHunter

    I know this is mostly a rule for toddlers, but considering how children have to wolf down their food at lunchtime, shouldn't meatballs be made to be too big/small to accidentally inhale? Giving spherical food to unsupervised kids - in the presence of clearly unqualified chaperones - is irresponsible.

  • I'm not surprised. The meat products when I went to school were made of rubber. The fucking hot dogs used to bounce. 

  • Alyssa Deklich

    I feel school aids and teachers in the city are not prepared for incidences like this. As someone who went to public school in nyc I remember them being pretty incompetent.

  • Using a defibrillator improperly can kill someone. They may have been the one to kill him. Wow...this is unbelievable and wholly preventable. Inexcusable.

  • Unkle_Bob

    The likelyhood of killing someone with an AED is laughably small.

  • You can misuse anything, even a toothpick. You have to know how to at least operate the damn thing to get it to work properly. The current state of NYC schools is what is is a joke and I seriously doubt they have a brand new, properly working, properly maintained, high quality AED. Just like they have new textbooks right? The idea that any piece of medical equipment is idiot proof is laughable. They couldn't save a boy who WAS CHOKING!!! They could have bludgeoned him to death with it for all you know. I don't think using any type of defibrillator would help him if his passageways were still blocked.

  • whoknewit

    They make them very much idiot proof these days and you can only shock someone that has a 'shockable' rhythm.

  • the4thcoming

    Sad. R.I.P Johnathan.

  • Rocknrope

    What if his dad was a cop?  Would you be saying "Good, the NYPD scumbag deserved to lose his kid."

  • stewart_nyc

    Tragic. My sincere condolences to his mother.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com