Quantcast

Video: "Explosion" Stranded Hundreds Of 4 Train Passengers Last Night

2011_10_4train.jpg
Photograph by James Thilman

Last night, NYCT Subway Scoop Tweeted, "#ServAdv: Downtown #4 turning at Bowling Green due to a smoke condition. Expect delays" For the over 400 riders on that 4 train, it turned into an unnerving experience. Our own James Thilman was on the train at 9:30 p.m. and says it "suddenly stopped between Bowling Green and Borough Hall. Quickly filled with smoke, people got a little jumpy (only a few screamers). We sat for well over an hour and were then transferred to another train and sent back to Bowling Green," which is where many people decided to give up on the MTA for the evening.

The Village Voice's Steven Thrasher was also on the train and has a long description. Here's what happened at the begining:

About a minute after pulling out of Bowling Green station at full speed, I felt a bump. Hearing a "pfizz," the train came to a halt.

Had we hit something? Had someone pulled the emergency cord?

I realized that we were underwater. I'm not normally a claustrophobic type, but I suddenly felt very nervous, and we were under a few hundred (thousand?) feet of water.

Then, the car started to fill with smoke.

It was the most frightening thing I'd ever experienced.

The man next to me pulled out a gas mask and winked at me. I had the terrifying feeling that every time I'd made fun of terrorism being overblown was going to come back and haunt me.

"It's OK," he said. "I work in construction."

I found this not particularly likely or reassuring.

The passengers, which included very young children, were taken off the stopped train and transferred to a rescue train. Thrasher writes, "For whatever reason, I ended being the next to the last person on the entire train getting off. There was a putrid, acrid, smokey smell passing between each car, like a hundred soldering torches were lit. When we finally got to go to the rescue train, the gap between the two was about a foot. MTA workers were telling us to watch the gap. Three firefighters were there, getting ready to investigate the 'explosion' and needing to put out the fire, whose location wasn't certain." He also took some video:

The MTA tells us the smoke condition is still "under investigation."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • CKing13
    It was the purple people eaters!
  • My building is a block from Bowling Green and I knew i heard a loud bang last night! Thought it was a truck on West Street or something. Never imagined an explosion.
  • galaxytime
    what is wrong with everyone! why are you discounting someone's fear? at the time, he had no idea how much water there is. for some it's traumatizing being in enclosed spaces, especially in questionable circumstances. be nice :(
  • jamieob256
    Anything over 5 feet of water, I would have panicked.
  • BrassMonkeyBallz
    yea - especially seeing how packed that train was. with strollers and babies. not a good time.
  • TCF16
    Seriously. He put it in parentheses and added a question mark to make clear that in a moment of panic, you probably start thinking the worst.

    I'm sure the heroes commenting above you would have been totally calm, cool and collected and barely remembered it happened once they were home. Dicks.
  • GalBklyn
    wow. I think I was on the no. 4 just before that one.

    glad everyone is ok.
  • DC
    Perhaps he meant a few thousand squared feet of water.. Which is entirely true.
  • Theose
    Few thousand cubic feet will be an extreme under statement.
  • NYC1978
    The East River at that point is what? 100-150 feet deep? A THOUSAND ?!?!?! Yeah, ok
  • luke_1
    Same reaction. I had the impression it was usually around 50 ft. I guess it would be deeper down there.
  • Detex
    haha, yeah I saw that! As soon as i read that i started to question the persons account of the situation.
  • BrassMonkeyBallz
    some people just over-exaggerate....
  • Pashri Diaz
    At that point, does the actual depth really matter?
  • JR_in_NYC
    Yeah, I laughed at that as well. Thousand feet, ha, come on!! The deepest station 191st Street on the 1 line is 180 ft.
blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com