New York Students: You Can Now Say No To Dissection
There's a new New York State education law that's now in effect, and it calls back the frog-freeing scene from E.T. (watch below!). Patrick Kwan at the Humane Society of the U.S. tells us that schools must now notify students of their right to refuse to dissect animals without being penalized. The HSUS and the Humane Society of New York are making sure that schools now abide by the new provision in the state’s humane education law.
The legislation, A.3467-B, was proposed by the Humane Society of New York and was introduced by Assemblymember Linda Rosenthal, D/WF-Manhattan, and Sen. Suzi Oppenheimer, D/WF-Mamaroneck. It charges the board of education or trustees of a school district to develop a policy to give reasonable notice to students and parents about their right to opt out of animal dissection as students with moral or religious objections may do under the existing law.
The HSNY's Elinor Molbegott discussed the law's importance, noting that “over the years, we have been contacted by many students who expressed moral objections to dissection but who were not informed by their teachers of their right to do an alternate project."
Currently 15 states have dissection choice laws or policies in place which typically require the school to notify students and/or their parents at the beginning of the course. They are: Florida, California, Pennsylvania, New York, Rhode Island, Illinois, Virginia, Oregon, New Jersey and Vermont. Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts and New Mexico have Board of Education policies, and Louisiana passed a state resolution in 1992. Student-choice legislation is currently pending in Connecticut (incidentally, we refused to dissect a frog in high school in that state and had no problems!).
Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.
Those that opt out of dissection would make lousy doctors so we don't need them.
69GeorgeWBush69
At first reaction, I was against this. But then I remembered all the dissections I've performed over the course of my education and realized I probably learned as much or more from pictures than having to cut something open and looking at it myself. However, this should be require if you're pre-med.
robingee
I thought you could always opt out. No one can force you to cut open an animal. Well, no one forced ME in 10th grade to cut a baby pig. Screw that noise.
felixthecat
Awesome
kenorasis
Yes, but what about the frogs? Can they opt out? Until they can our work is not done!
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.
Want Gothamist's suggestions on what shows to check out, where to eat, what to buy, where to go for a quick trip? We'll be bringing you some exclusive tips and ideas via email every day! And don't worry—you'll still get a list of our top stories.
Sign up for Gothamist Daily, which will deliver useful tips—plus Gothamist's most popular stories—to your inbox at 11 a.m. This way, you'll be able to plan your week or month as well as catch up on Gothamist if you've stepped away.