Quantcast

230 Fifth Owner Fighting Club's $500M Racial Discrimination Lawsuit

july28fifth.jpg
Photo via 230 Fifth's website

Flatiron bar and lounge 230 Fifth (you may recall its rooftop bar as the host of Kobayashi's controversial solo hotdog eating contest on July 4) is at the center of a $500 million racial discrimination lawsuit filed by a black man from Texas.

Rainbell Owens is claiming that he and his 15 friends, all of whom were also black, were kicked out of the bar during a 2009 birthday party after owner Steven Greenberg started screaming that the cake they brought in would "f- - k up my $10,000 sofa." Owens is suing the bar for $500 million in damages. It's not the first time the bar has been at the center of a lawsuit—in 2009, a chef was arrested for sexually assaulting a guest during a Halloween party.

We got in touch with Greenberg for a comment, and here's what he had to say: "These people came in without a reservation and brought their own cake. We sat them, we served them, and as the evening wore on they became boisterous and obstructive—they weren't just sitting on the couch, they were blocking the main thoroughfare. We asked if they could move to another couch where they could move around not block the passageway, they refused, and told us they'd leave if we gave them their money back. So we did. And they left. They were there for two or three hours. I would like to know how these people were damaged. They came in, they had their party, they had their drinks, they got their money back. Where's the discrimination? All we did was ask them to move."

Greenberg added that the bar has an "open door policy" and estimated that, based on the video cameras installed at the entrance and exits of the space, "we have probably 1000 or more African American people and people of other minorities enter and leave 230 Fifth on a busy night." He said that his lawyers are making a motion to dismiss the entire lawsuit, "and we believe we have an excellent chance of making that happen."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • pecolalid

    I'm black and have been to this bar on many occasions and have had nothing but a great time with top notch service. Once there was a disturbance by a black man who could not accept that a white woman he was trying to hit on wanted no part of him. He became abusive to her and called her white bitch. The bar tender called security and had him removed. He said that black men are their biggest problem when rejected by white woman who are not interested in them and just want them to leave them alone. One black man went so far as to tell one she knew she wanted him because white women like black men because they have big penises and grabbed his. He created a profane laced commotion as he was escorted out of the bar by security and told never to come back. Of course his last words were that he was going to sue the bar.

  • 2brnot2b1

    An afro-american Texan, sues in New York! I'm sure, coming from Tx., the plainiff"s well educated in discrimination. Maybe the group, just could'nt handle the reality of being free. Over step bounderies, and now want to sue. Using the courts for discrimation should not implie that a party was disrupted. A sign of the ridiculous times. We've gone from Civil Rights to, you say what? WASTE OF TIME, AN REAL CIVIL RIGHTS STRUGGLERS BLOOD! 

  • Agent2man

    to the two people arguing worthlessness.  Let's break down our history for a moment.  If you believe in science then their is no such thing as a pure bred White, black or any other race.  The human population has bottlenecked twice in our history on this planet (that means we were almost extinct at one time for those that are not sure what I'm talking about)  that means that the genes for all races are within each person.  What I do find kind of offensive is how you say that white people have cowtowed and allowed us to come to the U.S. and live a great life.  Thats such bullcrap.  The U.S. was stolen from the native americans and the people that stole it were the lowlifes and criminals of their former countries.  This country was built on money and thats the real racism in the world !  Class is the real racism.  Being black or white don't mean crap if you got money.  The Lawsuit is frivelous and I seriesly don't think its gonna go anywhere.

  • Thank You!! During that entire arguement all I could think was "how can you so graciously allow people of other races to come into a country that did not even belong to you in the first place?"

  • Agent2man

    This is why stupidity and racism still exist there is always someone out there that is willing to be a follower of any ideal instead of finding the truth for themselves.

    In a message dated 8/1/2011 4:56:37 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, writes:

    (http://disqus.com/)

    BrittanieW wrote, in response to Agent2man:
    Thank You!! During that entire arguement all I could think was "how can you so graciously allow people of other races to come into a country that did not even belong to you in the first place?"

    _Link to comment_ (http://disq.us/2uk5qt)

  • If a white person were treated the same in a predominantly minority bar/club it wouldn't be considered racist... so why is this? They were causing problems they got kicked out with a full refund, most of the time people get kicked out here your thrown out the door and lucky to not get your ass beaten. I don't know why Americans jump to the race card for absolutely every little thing.

  • canofpeas

    Why don't they go to a black club and try to pull the same shit?  I doubt they'd get out alive to file a lawsuit.

  • celmira9

    THIS IS EXACTLY THE REASON WHY THIS WORLD SHOULD COME TO AN END AND EVERYONE GO TO HELL OR HEAVEN.  THIS IS EXACTLY THE REASON WHY ON A DAILY BASIS WE HAVE PEOPLE JUMPING OFF BRIDGES.  THEY ARE SICK AND TIRED OF THE DAY TO DAY SUFFERING AND BIGOTRY.  AND I DON'T BLAME THEM.

    WE HAVE RACES WHO HAVE SUFFERED AT THE HANDS OF OTHERS AS WELL AS THEIR OWN PEOPLE.  HAVE THEY LEARNED ANYTHING? OF COURSE NOT.  THEY GO AROUND CRYING DISCRIMINATION AND PRETENDING THEIR RACE IS FLAWLESS AND COMMIT NO CRIME (HIDING THE TRUTH, THAT IS). WHILE THEY CONTINUE TO OPRESS THEIR FELLOW HUMAN BEING.

    THE WORLD IS TOO MUCH WITH US!

  • charles000

    So . . . let's see if I get this.  This 2 bit clown, Rainbell Owens and a gaggle of his crew of the moment crash a bar event, uninvited, act like a bunch of ignorant thugs, and then get thrown out . . . which now has become a $500 million racial discrimination lawsuit???

    This has nothing to do with race, this has to do with an out of control a**hole and his so-called friends acting like a bunch of wild animals, and then being surprised when they're thrown out.  If you act up like an ignorant thug, guess what . . . you'll be treated like one!

    Tell me what I'm missing here . . .

  • JeRsEy JiM

    Clearly they should have only sued for $460 mil ...

  • I'll never understand why minorities always want to force themselves into places that don't want them...I'm sure there are lovely clubs in Harlem and Bed-Stuy that would love his business..whatever happened to the buy black movement?.Are the only nice upscale clubs white owned and white run?I thought white people are corny and boring why would this guy want to be in that club?.You don't hear white people complaining that they couldn't get into some club in Harlem.

  • Thanks for that trip down memory lane, which had all the sensibility of Plessy v. Ferguson (1896).  I don't remember hearing whites complain that they couldn't use the blacks-only water fountains.

  • Peanut_Butter

    You responded to Le Nwwaert, but if I may, you missed our shared point. My argument is that we can distinguish the Plessy days from today.  During the Plessy era, "separate but equal" was not, in fact, equal because minorities depended on government funds NOT equally dispensed.  Minorities today are in a position to create their own venues which are not only equal to, but can exceed, those of whites, thus leading to the possibility I mentioned above.  Why do you think this not possible?

  • I see your point and I am very aware it's possible (and it has been accomplished), but it's hardly a positive thing.  Segregation was better than slavery, but that doesn't mean segregation was a good thing either, whether legally mandated or self-imposed.  In reality there are places mostly white people go and places mostly black people go, and that's just a fact.  That doesn't mean a nightclub should be scaring away paying customers and telling them to go start their own nightclub where one race is unwelcome.  

    Le Nwwaert sounded more like he was putting a modern spin on "send 'em back to Africa"-- namely, send them back to Harlem (as if black and Harlem were totally synonymous, and all black Americans are a homogenous group, etc).  I'll give the benefit of the doubt that that isn't what either of you really intended.  

    In any case New York is what it is because of the cross-pollination of different cultures.  Seeing 200 different nationalities and ethnicities represented, watching the fireworks together on July 4th, made me proud to be a New Yorker. We would certainly not be better off if every race went to fend for themselves in self-inflicted ghettoes.  We'd wind up as deluded, closed-minded, and ignorant, as a run-of-the-mill Republican in Utah*.  

    (* Intolerant rhetorical irony recognized and accepted.)

  • Telemachus_1

    As recent statistics indicate, people seem to self-segregate in general and this city is more segregated than ever before.  Given the tribal origins of humans, this isn't surprising.  That NYT map last year was really shocking.

    The sad reality is that in general, the country has become MORE segregated over the past 40 years, not less.  People have very clearly chosen to live in self-inflicted ghettos, except where childless white people are willing to venture into certain neighborhoods like those in North Brooklyn.  

    All that said, I'm really offended by your racist comments against white people in Utah, and by extension white people in general.   The United States is the only nation in history that has willingly allowed tens of millions of people of another race into their borders.  The vast majority of white people will do almost anything to prove how much they conform with politically correct ideals. They only draw the line when and if they have children as they will do anything to not send their kids to schools that are majority black.  But then again, everyone does this - even upper class blacks including the President himself.  

    If anything however, your attitude would call into question the wisdom of the immigration policy of the US.  If a half century and a 100 million newcomers is not enough to prove conformity with your morality, what is?  By the end of the century, white people will essentially be extinct. Is that what you desire?  If genocide is your goal, why not just state it?

  • nomadnewyork

    What statistics show that this city is more racially segregated than before? I've lived here for 40 years and ... um ...  New York is NOT MORE segregated than it was. There are pockets of segregation. There are neighborhoods that were formerly minority and have been displaced by a wealthier, lighter shade. Poor people have been magically erased from some neighborhoods...

    Yeah, and I really like your insulting belief that mixing races is genocide. It's as though you think that you're a different species than I am. You're not. 

    Another bi-racial homo sapien here. 

  • Telemachus_1

    Search the New York Times.  There is an extensive article on the subject. I'm not going to bother doing the work for you.  

    As to your last comment, all people have a right to exist without others demanding they cease to exist. And please - organized rape is well recognized by even the UN as a form of genocide. It has been practiced for centuries and is still practiced in Africa. Now, you're not advocating militarized rape. Instead, you're advocating a moral crusade to force people to make such "choices". But the end result is the same, and regardless - historically that which you desire has been implemented in a fashion consistent with genocide.

    In the end however, it is this hatred of white people that is irrational and wrong.

  • I never said white people in Utah, I said Republicans in Utah, and that was just a snarky aside made to lighten the mood, and I pointed that out.  I'm sure there are many very enlightened people in Utah.  

    Anyway, I am a bi-racial homo sapiens, and I'm descended from numerous now-extinct species that nobody is crying about.  Personally, I don't really give a damn if "white people" become "extinct", but what I think is besides the point.  White is a skin color, not a species, not a homogenous group, and not a way of life.  And I'm sure you are capable of seeing the difference between races interbreeding and racial genocide.  

    The sooner we're all cappuccino-colored, the better, since it will end put an end to debates like this one.  

  • Telemachus_1

    I'm sorry, but Republicans in Utah have a productive, safe, and civilized state that is a rarity in a world that is become more anarchic by the day. NO ONE there is ignorant. If you said Africans are ignorant, you would be right But you wouldn't say that because you're not interested in the truth, you're interested in hating white people. 

    And your post contradicts your proclamations. Firstly, even federal law regarding endangered species does in fact refer to specific species in the way you describe. Polar bears for instance are perfectly capable of interbreeding with brown bears. One is endangered, and one is not. How is this any different?  And what do you desire? total interbreeding such that the distinction between two breeds of humans disappears.  If you advocated this for bears, and implemented it, you'd be breaking the law.

    Finally, the point of demographics remains quite clear: White people are a tiny percentage of the world's population.  They have graciously given over a hundred million non-white people the opportunity to live in the productive, safe, and beautiful nation you enjoy today.  Billions of non-white people would give anything to come here.  Your hatred and racism isn't just insane, it shows how little gratitude you have for the people who have given you everything that defines your life.   

  • Excuse me, but in your white supremacist zeal you have completely missed the point of everything I'm saying. You seem to be saying white people are superior because we are kind enough to let other races live in our proud white nation-- that's the closest I can get to any meaning at all.     

    I don't want to waste time feeding your trollery, and at this point I really doubt you're doing anything else since it's some of the most idiotic and irrelevant nonsense I've ever heard in my life.  But just in case you are serious: white people are not an endangered species.  White people are not, in fact, a distinct species at all, and the only people claiming otherwise are the ones running around wearing white bedsheets and pillow cases on their heads and burning crosses.  Go down to DC and ask the EPA to protect white people, you'll be laughed all the way back to 1863. You might also re-read my comments about how proud I am that America accepts so many foreigners.  How you came to read what I wrote and think I'm racist is truly beyond me, given that everything I've said is demonstrably in opposition to that claim, but I suppose standards of literacy vary from one place to another.  But if my desire to live in a world without moronic white supremacist commentary makes me a racist, then by all means, label me a racist and sleep soundly. As I stated before, the sooner we can stop thinking about race altogether, the better.  Although the knuckle-dragging boneheads you side with will probably come up with a whole new way of segregating after that, i.e. who has blue eyes, and say we need to round up the brown-eyed people and put them in camps.  

    I'm sure you'll respond with more bait, so I'll just say in advance that whatever claim you are going to make about race is regressive, whatever you think about me is totally mistaken, and given your track record so far, I wouldn't believe anything you say about bears either.   

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com