Brighton Beach Is Excited, Angry Over "Russian Dolls"
Now that we've seen a glimpse of Lifetime's reality show about the Russian community in Brighton Beach, Russian Dolls, featuring "guys wearing Adidas pants, leather jackets and gold chains" and "a lot of hot, decked-out Russian girls" (plus some of their in-laws!), what do actual Russians in Brighton Beach think? Um, how about a community liaison's slam saying "they don’t speak this dirty language and they hate vodka."
Ari Kagan, who is Comptroller John Liu's liaison to the Russian community, told Sheepshead Bites:
There is no question in my mind that the Russian Dolls series will depict the Russian-speaking community in a distorted way, as a caricature, as a joke. Lifetime does not care about the thousands of great, beautiful, funny, smart and hard-working young Russian speaking women who attend colleges and universities, make money as paralegals, librarians, nurses, journalists and computer specialists. They are great daughters, sisters, wives and mothers. They don’t spend most of their time in nightclubs, bars or lounges. They don’t speak this dirty language and they hate vodka.
Of course, we do have our own bad apples, low lives and criminals, but they constitute a minority in the Russian speaking community. Lifetime wants to create a lot of fun and entertainment by throwing the reputation of Russian-speaking New Yorkers under the bus.
One woman told WPIX, "We are not about sex, we are not about drunk people, not about vodka, not about violence," but another said, "I grew up around here, I'm not Russian but ... I think it's a little accurate. It's ridiculous that people say it's too sexy, because Brighton Beach is a hot pot and sex sells."
Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.
As a true Brighton Beach Babe (born and raised) I must say that the show Russian Dolls is pretty spot on. Most Russians are materialistic RACIST and disrespectful (to their elders and everyone else for that matter). Every Russian friend I had did the same thing: they would date a black or “Spanish” guy and then give them the boot when it was time to bring them home to the family. Only to marry a Boris or Igor, (usually an ugly guy that will eventually beat them) (lol j/k) It’s amazing that any channel would glorify their behavior. The true Brighton beach residents are the Hasidic’s, Irish, Italian Pakistani, Spanish, Turkish, and my Coco colored friends ;) you ask a Russian anything about Brighton’s history and they don’t know. Now don’t get me wrong there are some Russians that LOVE America and everything about it. I know some beautiful Russian people (inside and out) those are the one’s that come off the boat and within 3 months speak English. They embrace this county and everything about it and are proud to say they are Russian-Americas. However most have been here for years, don’t speak any English or have no any intention on learning. They say that Americans don’t like them but it’s them that don’t like us. I mean, it could be the years of repression and a communist life that inbreeds money hungry schemers; which is why they come here with no shame and take advantage of our system.. I can’t tell you how many Russians I’ve witnessed in a check cashing place getting welfare checks and food stamps in their chinchilla furs and fendi bags. Or how many times I’ve seen a mom of three with a screaming baby and a cart of a few grocery’s get cut off in line by the Russian lady with a cart full and while that mom argues with the lady, another babushka is cutting in front of them both...LOL it’s crazy!! They have no manors..:) Now don’t come back saying I’m a racist or don’t know what I’m taking about because I’m NOT! I love all cultures and see the beauty and ugly of them all. (It’s just part of growing up in a place like Brooklyn) However, this is in regards to Brighton Beach Russians and the culture that is.. my neighborhood!! Unless you’r from there, you just don’t know. J
So
Do svidanya, Adios, Shalom, Ciao and Goodbye!
1Brighton4
Dear Enia! The whole point of my comment was to praise great Russian-American women and to defend their reputation! I did not "imply" anything else. It's true that I did
not include many noble professions in my very short list. But read my comments carefully: I was talking mostly about young students and recent college graduates. And I don't think that journalists or computer specialists fit your "traditionally female, subservient job title" definition.
Ari Kagan.
nicejewishgirl
I am shocked by the way they talk to their parents. Can this be accurate? I thought there was a strong family culture. One called her mother a bitch and the mother looked terrified of her. The daughter-in-law of Eva was so cruel--how is is possible that the son did not stand up for his mother? Some of it is mildly entertaining but the disrespectful language made me ill.
Roman, I watched your video. It is very unfortunate that I wasted my time watching this sad nonsense. You are young, healthy and ambitious. Yet you choose to spend your energy on these empty "scoops". Again, very sad!
I just want a show about people who actually have jobs in Brighton Beach. Park Slope even. How about Williamsburg? Jobs anyone?
RussiansAnonymous
yea... sadly there is a reason why stereotypes exist: they are usually pretty accurate. I have an entire blog about Russian stereotypes... and judging from the responses... people agree with the fact they are true (and funny)
I think a show called Paralegals of Brighton Beach could succeed if the girls are sexy enough.
EricKosten
I don't think anyone has ever claimed that these shows speak for the entirety of ANY community - detractors of the show seem to assert, on the contrary, that if we acknowledge that these groups CAN be absurd (like any group), then anyone who watches on bemusedly is a racist/biased/etc. But feel free to get your panties all in a bunch about it. However, I think that a show about JAPs would be the funniest thing I have ever seen. That story needs to be told.
crusher153
what we need to see is jersey shore with a drunken irish guy from breezy tearing their egos down. i could see it now, some big pasty white irish guy (with a beer belly that is as red as a lobster) sitting on the couch with a beer in hand just making fun of everyone on that cast. that would be perfect! so how about it mtv? did i just add some more depth to that boring show?
when will we see a show about the JAPS of looooong island...I'm guessing ..never...Marlon Brando was right...Hollywood is run by Jews. It is owned by Jews, and they should have a greater sensitivity. They should have greater sensitivity about the issue of people who are suffering because they've [been] exploited. We have seen the nigger, we've seen the greaseball, we have seen the chink, the slit-eyed dangerous Jap. We have seen the wily Filipino. We've seen everything, but we never saw the kike, because they know perfectly well that is where you draw the wagons around.
Liz k
Do you even realize that most of Russians in Brighton Beach are actually Jewish?
crusher153
oy! cry me a riva! who wants to see that anyway?
ktinnyc
I thought the entire first season of My Super Sweet Sixteen was a show about JAPS?
HymietownHero
So, Jewish people understand the value of entertainment, and are great at providing it. Actually, Scientologists just want you to believe that Jews run Hollywood.
hotguy
Huh really? WTf don't all te Jews caricature their own crazy people then? It's about time that the Jews that run jollywood do a show about their ridiculous Jews of Boroogh park crooklyn
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.
Want Gothamist's suggestions on what shows to check out, where to eat, what to buy, where to go for a quick trip? We'll be bringing you some exclusive tips and ideas via email every day! And don't worry—you'll still get a list of our top stories.
Sign up for Gothamist Daily, which will deliver useful tips—plus Gothamist's most popular stories—to your inbox at 11 a.m. This way, you'll be able to plan your week or month as well as catch up on Gothamist if you've stepped away.