Quantcast

Alan Dershowitz Wants Video Of His Sister-In-Law's Cycling Death, Please

070311accident.jpg
The scene of the accident, via DNAinfo

Famed defense attorney Alan Dershowitz is getting fed up with the Manhattan DA's office. He understands that charges will likely not be placed against the U.S. Postal Service driver who hit and killed his sister-in-law, lawyer and a retired court-appointed referee Marilyn Dershowitz, and that is okay. But he also knows there is a video in existence that may help his family discover who was driving the other vehicle involved in the accident—and he says the DA's office is stopping him at every pass.

Marilyn Dershowitz had been biking on West 29th Street with her husband Nathan Dershowitz last Saturday when she was struck by the truck The driver continued on, not realizing he had hit someone. "We have been trying so hard to be cooperative with the DA's office in the investigation of my sister-in-law's death," Dershowitz said. "We are getting stonewalled at every turn by William Beach in the DA's office."

And that fact is especially infuriating to Dershowitz as Marilyn Dershowitz's son Adam is in a unique position to help. He works as aeronautics engineer in California and specializes in recreating the moments that lead up to an accident. "All he wants to do is see the surveillance video of the accident to determine if there is anything else to be done to identify the driver of the truck because they still have not identified him," Alan complained to the Post.

The increasingly embattled DA's office has no comment on the matter, but it is worth noting that Dershowitz specifically did not call out the DA himself, Cy Vance, with his beef. "The only person to cooperate was Cy Vance, he called to give his condolences and was very nice," Dershowitz said. The problem apparently is lawyer William Beach. "Every day we call and we get every excuse in the book...He's saying he's too busy. He was too busy Tuesday, Wednesday, yesterday. It's a five minute video!"

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • bggb
    When is the last time a car driver killed a bicyclist and got charged with any kind of murder/manslaughter?

    Ever?
  • Jimbo853okg
    What matters is that Beach is stonewalling, Vance's office has been MIA on bike and pedestrian deaths, and Marilyn Derschowitz's family has every right to know what happened. Someone's feelings about Alan Dershowitz are irrelevant. If he wants to use a megaphone to scream loudly, all the better.
  • blindmalice
    If only it was in his DNA to just STFU and mourn the tragic loss of his sister quietly.  No....he HAS to make a huge public spectacle out of it, making it of course about HIM, and not her.
  • Guest_of_a_Guest
    What a douche this guy is.  The DA is not your private investigative firm and I hope your "we're not filing a lawsuit" comment is brought out when you do, in fact, file a lawsuit.
  • randomtransplant
    I honestly might be missing something, but if its the DA's office's job to pursue justice in the public interest what would be wrong with allowing qualified outside resources to offer free help they can't provide themselves?

    Somebody handed them that tape them investigate an accident. Its evidence, not a finite resource like the manpower to do the job themselves.
  • Good point randomtransplant. Moreover, while it might not be the DA's role, between the DA, NYPD and USPS, one of them should be responsive to this request.  Government info belongs to the people, and this is government info.  The office involved can charge a reasonable service fee for making the info available (in this case, if it's outside normal work procedures, perhaps as much as a few hours of time), but on a fundamental level, what belongs to the government belongs to the people.
  • Gwinny
    This makes me wonder how much harder it would be for some non-famous person to get hold of such footage...
  • Bicycles kill people. You should need a license to purchase a bicycle. maybe like a gun permit, showing you have mastered the body of knowledge necessary to safely and responsibly own and operate a bicycle.
  • I really hope you are being facetious because what kills 33000 people a year in the US is not bicycles. I'll give you a hint: Fossil fueled...
  • Bernie_Geotz_Squirrel_Luv
    Do those trailers always jut out of the loading bay like that?
    Not a lot of room for a bicyclist. As usual a car swerved causing the whole chain reaction.
  • being a diva? wow. i hate people who post on gothamist more and more every day.
  • zombiebob
    I'm sorry that woman died, but absolutely delighted that Alan is suffering because of it. See, there's a silver lining in ANY dark cloud.
  • Sinchy
    Wow, I don't like Dersh's views on some issues but this is so separate from that.  There is nothing good about this.
  • LazyNanny
    Uh oh, beware the wrath of Dershowitz.
  • Peanut_Butter
    For what it's worth, I enjoyed his writings when I was younger.  No idea if he's being a diva.
blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com