Quantcast

Cell Records Will Set You Free

20117phone.jpg
(Via Flickr user Ultraclay)
Lanell "Country" Downing probably values his cell phone more than any high-powered executive in Midtown. He might even like his phone more than people who insist on using them as a DJ booth while on the bus. Downing loves his phone because his cell records were the deciding factor for police dropping robbery charges against the 26-year-old Brooklyn resident.

In April of 2010, Downing was sentenced to jail for a string of robberies in East Flatbush. The crimes were brutal too - in two cases the assailant hit women with a gun, and in another the attacker held-up a 75-year-old woman at gun point. Police arrested Downing in connection to these crimes after someone tipped police off after seeing a sketch that looked almost identical to Downing.

Downing then spent seven months in jail before his defense lawyer, Jay Schwitzman, reviewed Downing's cell phone records, which placed him at another location when the crimes were committed. Schwitzman added that there wasn't any physical evidence and Downing had even passed a lie detector test. "It really shows how [witness] identification in general is a very dangerous process because people often misidentify," said Schwitzman.

For a guy who just spent seven months in jail for crimes he didn't commit because someone thought he looked like a police doodle, Downing sounded remarkably upbeat after being released. He even thanked prosecutors, before adding, "I'm glad it's over."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Trustafarian

    so is giving your phone to a buddy to make calls before/during committing a crime a valid alibi nowadays? 

  • groganz

    "Schwitzman added that there wasn't any physical evidence and Downing had even passed a lie detector test."
    Please note that "lie-detectors" are pseudoscience.

  • Please note that looking like a police sketch is not evidence of committing a crime.

    Seriously, how the hell did they hold this guy for 7 MONTHS based on this alone?

  • Spirit of 76

    "It really shows how [witness] identification in general is a very dangerous process because people often misidentify,"

    That can be true, but on the other hand, cell phone records are hardly ironclad alibis. A smart criminal could hand off his phone to a friend to use far away during the crime if that were the case.

  • Elderta2

    Please for the love of god, copyedit this article.

  • ONE_LESS_FIXED_GEAR

    wow...what a lucky mf'er...that's just nuts.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com