Quantcast

Even The MTA Thinks Its Elevators And Escalators Are A Mess

201106_noelevator.jpg
No elevator for you! (bitchcakesNY's flickr).

Elevators and escalators on the subway are notoriously bad—just ask some of the people who have been stuck in them—and yet, according to a draft report the Daily News got its paws on, the MTA still doesn't have a firm grasp on how to keep them running. Which makes us feel great about their "plans" to get garbage off subway platforms faster!

The News says they've gotten a peek at the MTA inspector general's report on a $2.7 million project started in 2007 that was meant to improve the maintenance and reliability of elevators and escalators. And it is a doozy. "Despite public concern, media attention and demands for improvement by the MTA Board, elevators and escalators remain a problem," the report says.

So what are some of the things the report focuses on? Well, to start, it turns out that some "straphangers stuck in elevators may have been trapped longer than necessary because a new monitoring system was plagued by false alarms," which meant that staffers at the MTA's Elevator and Escalator department stopped even paying attention.

Making things worse, the automated system has a knack for failing to send warnings during real breakdowns (there were 208 entrapments in the first six months of 2010). So instead workers simply wait "for notification from trapped riders or other transit workers before sending mechanics to the scene." And it turns out that monitoring equipment was disconnected at some elevators, "including some with the highest number of entrapments!"

Also, some "inspection and maintenance work reported as having been done may not have been performed." Which sort of explains why the report found that "Managers didn't know false alarms were a problem and wrongly thought staff was immediately dispatched."

"These are critical issues that must be dealt with," Inspector General Barry Kluger told the Daily News. And to that end the MTA says it is finally going to get its act together. To start it is going to create a chief of elevators and escalators to improve maintenance and reliability of the equipment. In the meantime, if you believe them, the MTA tries to keep track of currently down elevators and escalators on its website.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • BarrioPuente

    Well escalators can never break, they can only become stairs so happy walking. Probably the only exercise most New Yorkers get now. 

  • missypants

    Can anyone tell me why if one escalator is out it is always the down escalator? In my experience escalators could run in both directions - the preferable direction being up. I thought that walking down is a bit easier for those with disabilities. I know when I was pregnant and fat and totally out of shape that I could never find up escalators that were running in midtown.

  • diablofreak

    i dunno why perfectly normal, non-handicapped people use these damn elevators. if your'e unlucky to be stuck in it basically it just feels like you're stuck in a porta-potty for hours.

    even a 20 second ride is 20 second too much in that stench.

  • maritov

    Remember that you can't tell by looking whether the rider of the elevator has a disability.

  • Guest

    At some subway stops, the elevator is the only way you can get to or from the platform.  I HATE those stops.  

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com