Quantcast

Bethesda Fountain Is Now For Quiet Drinking, Not Music

201106_bethesda.jpg
(chrstiNYCa's flickr).

Musicians in Central Park are making noise over the decision to turn the Bethesda Fountain arcade into a "Quiet Zone," a decision which has led to a blitz of tickets that the musicians say is for the sole benefit of a food concession coming to the area soon. But chef John Fraser, who will be running the concession (and who has his own legal issues to worry about these days), says you shouldn't blame him.

"It's all in the Parks' hands," Fraser, who will soon be operating a 75-table concession by the beautifully restored arcade, told the Post.

The Parks Department meanwhile says the decision to send musicians packing—sometimes in cuffs—is by popular demand. "Crowds of 700 regularly overwhelmed the terrace, completely blocked the stairs, and those trying to pass climbed on and damaged sandstone carvings on the side," a rep wrote in an e-mail. "The musicians have approximately 850 acres to use. All eight quiet zones amount to less than 33 acres. The public wants quiet zones and have repeatedly requested quiet places for passive enjoyment of the park."

Whether or not people want quiet in the park—which is their right to want—making one of the most visible and famous attractions in the park off-limits to musicians, especially an area with such lovely acoustics, seems misguided. As Geoffrey Croft of New York City Park Advocates argues, "It's absurd that the city is trying to take away what is enjoyment by so many for a watering hole for the wealthy."


Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • HypocraticOath

    These urban dance crews are really the worst. Lots of loud music, yelling, taking up too much space...what a pain in the ass. It is a park, not a stage.

  • It is impossible to enjoy the park around the fountain on a summer evening due to the competing drum-circles, dance troupes, and bands out there. The place is a park not a circus. It's gotten ridiculous.

  • tsol

    Drum circles should be verboten!!!

  • bittinho

    Let them play during the week when it is less crowded and maybe allow approved performers (i.e. non-amplified and area appropriate musicians play). I don't see how music interferes with people's eating if it is not someone banging a metal pot.

  • Emmily_Litella

    In the 70s the fountain was where to go drink for the under 18 crowd.  Old guys with shopping carts full of ripple would sell to anyone.  Lots of graffitti on display too.

  • ronshapley

    ban the tourists too

  • TheOtherBob

    A guy in a corner playing a cello in front of five people?  Not a problem -- you can barely hear it, and it's not in the way.  I wish there were a way to let that guy do his thing -- because he doesn't bother me at all.

    But as someone else pointed out, a lot of it isn't that -- a lot of it is dance crews that take over the entire area and prevent anyone else from getting through.  They could perhaps forbid amplification for them (I thought that required a permit anyways) -- but they're still preventing everyone else from experiencing the place the way it was meant to be experienced.  

    There are a thousand places to have dance crews in the city -- and exactly one place to sit and see that vista.  (And the only reason the dance crews are there is that the vista attracts so many tourists, after all.)  I think it's fair to say that we want to reserve that space for its intended purpose, and not let it be monopolized by some money-making scheme.

  • 69GeorgeWBush69

    the mall is right next to the fountain. they can just perform there where there is a ton of space

  • marilync

    comments are funnier than the story. BTW -- the poll is sooooooo friggin' rigged.

  • WetButt

    Yea here's the problem though, the "musicians" at Bethesda fountain are dance crews with amplified speakers, not instrumentalists so I say fuck em

  • It should be limited to acoustic instruments. Most of the musicians there play acoustic instruments. Do you go there?

  • johnnieutah

    What if they specified no amplified music? I think that's a policy I could support for the subway, as well.

  • WetButt

    The amplification is a minor issue, the fact is the dance crews there  use a large portion of the terrace space and their crowds get very large. If they want to perform get a permit at the bandshell or at a stage.

  • MermaidFornicator

    there are already two "dance crews" at the bandshell. the park should be for quiet. there are plenty of bars & performance venues for musicians to play in.

  • ImperialStout

    Not enough.  And none of them pay as much as a musician can make in a few hours in the park.  In fact, most venues don't pay anything.

  • I don't think limiting this to amplified music solves the problem. You can hear those annoying drum from a great distance. And on the subway? There's no escape.

  • blindmalice

     Concessions generate revenue.  Summons and tickets generate revenue.  Musicians dont.  In the Bloomberg era, guess who wins and who loses.  

  • JeRsEy JiM

    But, I REALLY do not like to go outside.

  • schmeep

    Can we have a poll canvassing whether it's a bit passe to have an extra throwaway 'humorous' poll option, please?

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com