Quantcast

Park Slope Big Shots Sue DOT Over PPW Bike Lane

030711lane6.jpg
Zoe Schlanger/Gothamist

Two groups of Park Slope residents opposed to the controversial Prospect Park West bike lane have filed a lawsuit against the DOT to get it removed. The well-connected group Neighbors for Better Bike Lanes—whose members include former NYC DOT commissioner (and wife of Chuck Schumer) Iris Weinshall and former Sanitation Commissioner Norman Steisel—filed the lawsuit this afternoon along with the group Seniors for Safety. Not only does the lawsuit (which you can read in its entirety below) accuse the DOT of conducting a misleading analysis of the bike lane's impact, but it also accuses the DOT of working with cycling advocates to smear the lane's opponents. And the plaintiffs obtained juicy e-mails to prove it.

E-mails obtained via the state's Freedom of Information Law allege that DOT official Ryan Russo encouraged bike lane advocates to "neutralize" and "counter-attack" the bike lane opponents. We're not sure whether that's illegal, but the anti-lane lawyers (working pro-bono, by the way) are trying to portray the DOT as a bunch of zealots willing to use any means necessary to shove the bike lane down Park Slope's throat—even if it means encouraging other people to make comments on the Internet. In these e-mails, Russo tells one bike lane "lobbyist" he found his comments deriding the anti-bike lane crowd as "quite enjoyable." In those comments, opponents are referred to as:

  • "shameless, selfish pigs"

  • "complete f'ing troglodytes"

  • "the worst of what the Baby Boom generation has to offer"

  • "monsters" who should "move to Florida" where "they probably won't live long enough to experience what climate change has in store for the Sunshine State."

Well, the debate certainly has been, uh, spirited! The lawsuit—which also argues that because of Park Slope's historic nature, the DOT needs to conduct an environmental review—comes days after the plaintiffs' lawyer threatened to sue Streetsblog over a blog comment. (Streetsblog initially refused to remove the comment, but later took it down at the commenter's request.) All this should make Thursday night's Community Board meeting (6:30 p.m. at 237 Seventh Avenue, between 4th and 5th Street) to discuss the bike lane a real hoot. Just please don't say anything mean in the comments, you guys, thanks!

NBBL vs. NYCDOT

In a statement, DOT spokesman Seth Solomonow says, "This project has clearly delivered the benefits the community asked for. Speeding is down dramatically, crashes are down, injuries are down and bike ridership has doubled on weekends and tripled on weekdays." And City Councilman City Councilman Brad Lander, who conducted a survey about the bike lane, tells Transportation Nation, "Most neighborhood residents feel that Prospect Park West is now a calmer, safer street... The DOT is proposing additional modifications - many suggested by community members - that will make PPW even safer. I hope that the lawsuit does not put these additional safety improvements at risk. Of course everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I believe this lawsuit disregards the opinions and jeopardizes the safety of the community."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Was driving down PPW the other day... much fewer reckless drivers, traffic moves at a more reasonable pace. Keep in mind this is a residential neighborhood and traffic should only be moving about 25-35 miles an hour. PPW is no longer the speedway that it used to be. For opponents to say that the bike lane has made PPW less safe, well, they have no idea what they're talking about.

  • I suggest everyone trying to get this dim lawsuit derailed go to Chuck Schumer's web site and ask him, in the interests of civility, health and quality transportation, to intervene and cool things down. I also took a moment to leave a thank-you comment on Brad lander's website -- I don't live in his district but I support and use the bike lane --- and I support his calm, fact-based approach.

  • I drive and bike in the city, and am floored at the anti-bike/bike lane sentiment. I'm also from Minneapolis, which is a very pro-bike city. I live right near Prospect Park West and as others have stated, I actually find driving down that street quite pleasant.

  • StriketheSet

    I can see why young people hate old people we were never
    in debt ,had plenty of places to live in to choose from in NYC and cheap rents
    at that! ,did not need to be electronicly entertained 24/7, we liked that we were not
    connected where anyone could find us and a world where CCTV everywhere did not
    need to be .
    No AIDS. to worry about when screwing, or pollution fears excepting DDT, We had the military draft anxiety that we also helped eliminate so that you could enjoy your bike riding skateboard, Frizzbes ,smartphones texting & twitter etc and now a resume/CV rat race.
    Wow! the dollar was the best currency and I will avoid the cliche how much was fairly
    priced in the marketplace for just about everything.

    We also have survived some years in an older USA which many young people fear that they may not.

    Yes a lot was wrong with humans hitting humans for racial reasons and for political gain yet
    this will continue as humans really have to learn respect ,it is not a native instinct.
    We also produced everything we needed in our country ,not Asia or India ,...Imagine that?

    Sadly we had children that became your parents and dropped you into an
    insane world,that we never (Grand Pa's and Grand Ma's) never expected to be.

    It is still a mystery to us that as more babies are born living ,we have created a world
    of extreme competition for just about everything.... to live better than a street rat..
    It is also amazing to me that we are keeping people alive longer from infant to
    death is predicted for a baby born today to expect a lifespan of 100 years.

    Our joy is that we will all be gone ,when it gets worse, that's priceless as the old Advert's
    used to say ,priceless!

  • Please, this lawsuit isn't about safety, government transparency, or aesthetics. It's about a few very wealthy residents who live on PPW and how they are mad that they lost their "right" to double park.

  • imadick

    how are community boards elected? these people obviously don't represent the neighborhood, just a screechy minority.

  • kevd

    They aren't the community board. They have nothing to do with the community board. The actual, elected community board requested a bike lane on PPW.

  • thinprep

    As someone who drives all over brooklyn, I love any traffic calming measures since people drive like assholes. The PPW bike lane has made driving more pleasant. The bike lane on 9th street around smith/court/Lowes area has calmed speeding assholes. Also the pedestrian island at fort hamiliton near Maionides hospital have calmed down insane Hasidics in their mini-vans of death. I am a driver that fully supports bike lanes.

    However, as a former biker, I would never use a bike lane... I would rather take my chances on the street rather than the false security of a bike lane.

  • imadick

    it definitely slowed down traffic, which is why i can't see the irrational argument about how bike lanes are unsafe...

    but i don't think driving down ppw is any more pleasant now -- there's always some moving truck on the right side, and some asshole driving 10 mph on the left looking for parking.

  • PhotoR

    Isn't that true of around 80% of Brooklyn streets? Having a 3-lane thoroughfare lets some traffic go thru the middle lane, but it's far more dangerous to pedestrians than a 2 lane road with parking-protected bike lane next to it.

  • starrygordon

    It can't be much worse than it was before they started working on it. I both drove and biked there and I learned to avoid it.

  • Woodendesigner

    They should all be careful what they wish for. Fast cars vs. old people crossing the street usually equals someone getting hit by a car.

  • pvbklyn

    I'm an old timer, retired, and I think the bike lanes are great. More bike lanes and more pedestrian friendly walkways is what is needed. I also drive a car sometimes but I'm willing to put up with going slow. We all have to share. It's a dense city and it is helpful that we all go greener in every way as well as learn to co-exist. My only complaint about the PPW bike lane is the small section by Grand Army Plaza. Because of the medical center on the corner it's quite difficult to get through there in the middle of the day. Perhaps they could have taken up part of the sidewalk on PPW at that point to continue the bike lane. . .? I don't know I'm not an engineer. In any case more bike lanes . . . Those cranky, old, afraid of new ideas people should get a life.

  • cmdrogogov

    Thank you for injecting some sanity.

    For the record, most of the vitriol I feel is directed precisely towards those who persist in believing the fantasy that automobiles are the answer to every problem. They have their place, but that place is far less relevant to densely populated urban areas than the current configuration of infrastructure would suggest.

  • kevd

    AnY jackass can file a lawsuit for any reason.

  • random transplant

    The lawsuit can't go anywhere. Its a conspiracy theory, not a list of legally defensible grievances. You can find cookie cutter forms like this online. No wonder it was drawn up pro bono.

    The very idea that a non-profit advocacy group is colluding with the city with regards to falsified data is absurd. I wouldn't believe it if Markowitz wasn't their neighbor.

    I feel sad for these olds. They don't understand the internet. They don't understand the media. Money can only buy you civic grace as long as your graceful about it.

    And to think a former DOT commissioner has their name associated with it...last dying & incompetent gasp of a failed legacy, if you ask me.

  • art525

    Yep it's all about old isn't it? You caught them in that character flaw. How dare they be old?

  • cmdrogogov

    old.. stuck in an antiquated way of thinking... believing the 20th century american fantasy that's proven to be utterly unsustainable in both economic and ecological senses..

  • art525

    Yes I know and you are leading us to a bright green tomorrow. What a hero.

  • petercow

    @And to think a former DOT commissioner has their name associated with it...last dying & incompetent gasp of a failed legacy, if you ask me.

    That is one of the most depressing aspects of this. The reality that Weinshall was DOT commissioner. It's like she was at a seance, and Robert Moses jumped into her body. Did she have any qualification in the field apart from being fucked by Chuck Schumer?

    I have no doubt the plaintiffs want this expedited, as the weather warms up, and more and more cyclists use the lane.

    Peter
    http://inklake.typepad.com

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com