Quantcast

Self-Defense Claim In Parking Space Coma Incident

3511comaspace.jpg
On East 14th Street, near the spot where the fight occurred

Yesterday, we heard the grisly story of parking space rage gone too far: petite Bronx woman Lana Rosas ended up in a coma after a vicious confrontation with electrician Oscar Fuller over a parking spot. Rosas was holding the space on East 14th Street for her boyfriend, and refused to let Fuller park his van; the argument escalated, and Fuller punched Rosas "in the face with so much force that the woman flew off her feet," according to court papers. But in court yesterday, Fuller's lawyer argued that he was just acting in self-defense: "There is nothing to suggest my client intended to inflict serious injury. At most, the charge should be misdemeanor assault."

Thomas Kenniff, Fuller's attorney, didn't dispute that Fuller punched Rosas in the face, sending her into a coma, but he argued that the 4-foot-11 Rosas of attacking his client first, hitting him multiple times in the face. Then Fuller saw her boyfriend running toward them: “Now, as he perceives it, he believes he’s being attacked by two people. He throws one punch to the woman’s face, to defend himself, gets in his car and removes himself from the situation.” Fuller, a father of two with prior busts for weapons possession and felony assault, has been charged with felony assault.

According to Kenniff, Fuller "was in tears" when the lawyer visited him in jail: "not because of the situation that he's in, but first and foremost the situation that the young woman is in." Rosas remains hospitalized in a coma at Bellevue Hospital with her family and boyfriend; doctors told cops that she suffered permanent brain damage from hitting her head in the pavement, and may die. Kenniff added that Fuller acted on instinct, and didn't intend to hurt Rosas: “The bottom line is the events, while tragic, are not criminal,” Kenniff said.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • handsomedevil

    “The bottom line is the events, while tragic, are not criminal,” Kenniff said.

    Well, no, THAT's ridiculous. No one's gonna buy that.

  • robingee

    Oh, that poor man.

  • mistermarkdavis

    "Fuller, a father of two with prior busts for weapons possession and felony assault, has been charged with felony assault"

    Gothamist, you're great.

  • 69GeorgeWBush69

    "Then Fuller saw her boyfriend running toward them: Now, as he perceives it, he believes he’s being attacked by two people. He throws one punch to the woman’s face, to defend himself, gets in his car and removes himself from the situation."

    Yeah, he couldn't have just gotten back into his van and left the scene. At the very least he could have just pushed her away. Instead, this sack probably tried to sock her as hard as he could out of anger. Unfortunately, there are lot of these animals in NYC, which is why you don't do stupid things like stand in parking places, asking for trouble. Not saying that the chick deserved it but this is a probable outcome of the game you play when you act like garbage.

  • Chazz1918

    The guy MUST be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. But it is insane to stand in a parking spot and claim it in NY. He would have a better case if he killed her, temporary insanity via parking spot rage. I think a better tactic would have been to slowly back into the spot - she would have moved.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com