Quantcast

Momentum Builds To End "Last-In First-Out" Teacher Policy

22511bloomb.jpg
Mayor Bloomberg, outspoken critic of LIFO (AP)

After months of criticism from the likes of Mayor Bloomberg and Gov. Andrew Cuomo, president of the American Federation of Teachers Randi Weingarten announced a plan to overhaul the "last-in, first-out" (LIFO) teacher firing system. Weingarten proposed that tenured teachers who are rated unsatisfactory by their principals will be given a maximum of one school year to improve, and if not, can be fired within 100 days. But there may be even harsher legislation coming that could spell doom for thousands more teachers much sooner.

Sen. John Flanagan introduced a bill that would fire 2,671 teachers who have an unsatisfactory rating in any of the last five years, 291 teachers who have been slapped with a fine, 1,149 teachers who have been assigned to the Absent Teacher Reserve pool for more than six months, and 529 teachers who have been convicted of a crime. United Federation of Teachers President Michael Mulgrew criticized the reach of the bill: "The proposed bill would send us back to the days before civil service protections, when people could be fired for being the wrong race or gender, too young or too old."

According to the Post, the "notoriously slow and convoluted disciplinary process" of firing teachers has gotten even more expensive in recent years—and it's now put the state Education Department in the red for $7.5 million. Last week, Mayor Bloomberg warned that nearly 5,000 teachers could be out of jobs due to budget cuts, but as the Post points out, the employees and executives of the United Federation of Teachers union who represents those teachers have been quietly making bank despite the stormy weather—the amount of workers who make more than $100,000 in annual salary increased 38 percent over the past six years.

Of course, NY isn't the only state dealing with a budget crisis that is affecting its teachers: the school board in Providence, Rhode Island voted yesterday to send out termination letters to all 1,926 of its city's public school teachers, because of their $40 million budget deficit.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • LazyNanny

    $heldon $ilver will never allow this to become law. Move along.

  • angry_pickle

    Randi Weingarten sees the tree but not the forest. I would imagine her retort would be something like "it's not my duty to see to the forest". She is the mother parasite.

  • GalBklyn

    Teaching is a profession in which, ideally, skills improve with time and experience. Bloomberg's goal I believe is to have the teaching staff be mostly young and cheap. Basically babysitters with few if any good experienced mentors to get them on their way. Another shot to the bow of our public education system.

    Time for some Wisconsin action. I'm really really done with this.

  • spiv

    Still waiting for this to be applied to Mayors.

  • handsomedevil

    I'm generally sympathetic to this push, BUT there is one point that seems to get lost. Older teachers cost more and new teachers are cheap. Thus, school systems that were entirely released from any kind of consideration of seniority would have a HUGE financial incentive to fire people over, say, 45, which could very well be bad educational policy and blatantly unfair.

    Thus, there needs to be some kind of balance - like a requirement that the average age of the staff remain relatively stable.

  • cool

    I see your point, but it is somewhat recursive. Older teachers cost more because, by union rules, pay is dictated by seniority and not quality. If pay were based on quality, there are political consequences for firing the best teachers.

  • Petey

    This is my biggest fear with this situation, that the older (higher salary) teachers will be the ones to receive the unsatisfactory reviews in order to fire them. It already goes on with harassment by principals towards some of the older teachers, and this will only make it worse.

  • healthstudent

    After hearing Randi Weingarten on the Intelligence Squared debate, I have absolutely zero sympathy for teachers unions. (http://intelligencesquaredus.o...

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com