Quantcast

Stupid Survey Says New Yorkers Are Very Rude?

012111angry.jpg
Katie Sokoler/Gothamist
An idiotic survey by Travel & Leisure claims that New York City is the #2 rudest city in America, second only to Los Angeles. That LA is considered numero uno in incivility makes sense—there are countless self-serving jackasses over there—but anybody who's ever visited NYC know the old stereotype of the boorish, inconsiderate New Yorker is just a canard perpetuated by those Hollywood scumbags. Stop and ask a New Yorker for directions and others will immediately gather, competing to guide you. Fall onto the subway tracks and New Yorkers will risk their lives to save you. Hell, even our bank robbers are polite! So how did this stupid survey rank us so high on the rude list? Oh, wait it didn't—it's just the schmuck who wrote the dumbass Travel & Leisure article misrepresenting the survey.

What the survey actually asked people to do was rank how "friendly" a city is. Which is a horse of a very different color—though the result is still utter manure. You see, when Katrina Brown Hunt wrote her vapid article accompanying the survey, she decided that not being friendly is the same thing as being rude. As New Yorkers, we would like to politely ask Hunt to go play in traffic: just because we don't always make friends with the tourists doesn't mean we're rude. It means we're busy! And maybe we have enough damn friends.

We can only assume the tourists who considered us so incredibly cold and unfriendly are a bunch of hayseeds who can't get over how we don't smile or say hi to each and every person we pass on the street, like y'all do in Charleston, South Carolina—supposedly the #1 friendliest city. But if we behaved like that here, the important business of this city of 8 million people would grind to a laryngitic halt. Also, we're probably on our phones and can't be bothered. So stop taking it so personally, tourists! And stay in your lane (please)!

And another thing about this bullshit survey: It ranks Charleston, again, as #1 in the category of most attractive people. NYC comes in 13th, behind those famously winsome inhabitants of Denver, San Diego, and, um, Salt Lake City. Yes, SALT LAKE CITY. The survey even says Phoenix/Scottsdale has hotter citizens!? It's all enough to make a person question his faith in the media's wholly unscientific puff polls. Nevertheless, we still wear the Reader's Digest crown for the most polite city in America. Suck it, Charleston.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Ragingsemi
    Charleston, S.C. has more attractive people? Yeah if your definition of attractive is 50lbs overweight, rocking a Col Sanders mustache, a bolo tie, with fucking penny loafers. All the while walking around and having to listen to "Hay Yall", "Praise Jesus" all goddamn day. Then Yeah they're fucking super models.
  • fleur_de_lis
    To me, it seems most people either love or hate new york (though I've met a few people who are mixed). I LOVE it but my whole family think its a bunch of rude stuck up jerks. Every time I've visited, I haven't encountered one rude person. (though I know they exist there, just like everywhere else) The people are just real. Where I grew up, some people were nice, some were rude, and most were just superficial. In nyc, people are genuine and of course they don't wave and say hi to everyone!! It would be impossible. I love the fast pace of the city and I don't think nyers are rude at all. this article is stupid, whatever.
  • dropstep
    New Yorkers are both rude and classless!!
    Yes, I am a New Yorker.
  • diablofreak
    i'd take a rude, selfish city with life over a quiet, soulless city that's dead by 4pm any day.
  • random transplant
    HA HA

    JDS fell for troll bait and it was funny.

  • hi_mom
    This can only mean a shrinking influx of people who choose their travel destinations based on articles in Travel and Leisure magazine which they took at face value. I support this article.
  • :/ Can the city sue Travel and Leisure for defamation, and then buy more plows?
  • Just Me
    Upstate NY.
    Now those are some rude folks.
  • Guest
    We aren't rude we are just direct.
  • Stevennnn
    These lists are stupid and a waste of time. It's all relative to the person and experiences had within a city.
  • Rod
    don't forget the influx of republicans to nyc after rudy and mike rebuilt the city for them and them alone
  • ManhattanTransfer
    The journalist with T&L might want to brush up on her vocabulary. Curt does not mean rude. Direct does not mean rude. Hurried does not mean rude. I cannot think of another metropolis of 8.3 million inhabitants where people manage to negotiate personal space as well as New Yorkers.
  • And, in spite of what a lot of Midwesterners believe, passive-aggressive does not equal polite.
  • HymietownHero
    WORD. I just got back from Shanghai. I haven't bumped-and-grinded so much since prom!
  • TheRealCannibal
    The rudest people in NYC are the tourists and the transplants.
  • FU Boy
    I'd buy that Scottsdale has hotter people. It's a major porn town, and I'm not kidding. If you ever see some strumpet with huge tits getting banged on a patio table with a desert-ish landscape in the background, you're looking at Scottsdale.

    Favorite moment when there - was at the bar at a sushi restaurant waiting for a friend. A few chairs down there were two women with silicone enhancements being propositioned by a producer. He actually used the line, "Have you ever wanted to be in a movie?"
  • Trustafarian
    I love giving tourists directions!
  • robingee
    There just isn't enough time to say hi to every single person on the street or in every building. I do it when I am in a smaller town, but not in NYC.
  • Rammy
    I'm convinced a lot of the actual rudeness in NYC is the direct result of tourists proactively being rude - because that's how they think we act.

    So a lot of shoving and no eye contact and cutting you off is done by the out of towners.

    New Yorkers know that if you were to act like an asshole 24/7 in a city w/ 8 million people - that you'd get your ass beat/stabbed about 2x a month - so we're actually pretty chill - in a hurry and we have places to be, but chill.
  • timmmyk
    I have to add that in my experience, the truly rudest people I have ever come across in NYC are those from the burbs who seem to be in town either against their will, bearing a chip on their shoulders or are 'entitled shits' who are inflicting their own misperceptions/issues on others.
  • ITA. Tourists are rude and nasty to each other while hanging out with groups of tourists in Times Square, and then they complain about NYers being rude.
  • Professor Von Nostren
    Agreed. I actually think NYers are a lot more patient than most people. We'll put up with a lot more crap before going postal.
  • Rod
    Yeah, i've gotta say new yorkers are the friendliest assholes and crooks you'll ever meet.
  • The original article I read about this quoted someone who said, "I like New Yorkers. They stab you in the front." Which pretty much sums it up.
  • hotstepper
    travel + leisure can eat a steaming bowl of dicks with no spoon.
  • S.D.
    JDS: One of your finer posts, I was laughing from beginning to end...
  • Professor Von Nostren
    I concur. Well done, sir. And, have a nice day!
  • maatthias
    I completely agree! Well done JDS.
  • bkgirl
    fuck them right in their fucking face.
  • new york humor is my favorite kind of humor =)
  • Rude? guess they only saw cyclists and hipsters.
  • smorrebrod
    Nah, I've asked people in Williamsburg and outside the Ace Hotel for a cigarette, they usually give one.
blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com