Quantcast

Arizona Shooter Charged As Political Debate Rages

1911giff.jpg
AP

The US Attorney in Arizona has filed charges against Jared Lee Loughner, the accused gunman in yesterday's tragic shooting in Arizona in which six people were killed and 14 wounded. He has been hit with three charges of attempted murder (of Rep. Gabrielle Giffords and two members of her staff) and two charges of murdering federal employees (Judge John Roll and Gabriel Zimmerman, a Giffords staff member). And inspectors now believe Loughner was a lone gunman, and have found evidence of a premeditated attempt to assassinate Rep. Giffords.

Police had been searching for a second suspect who was captured on surveillance camera, but the officials announced this afternoon that the second man had been found and cleared of any involvement in the shootings. Police say that the second man was a taxi driver who drove Loughner to the meet-and-greet event where Rep. Giffords was appearing; when Loughner said he had to go into the Safeway store for change, the taxi driver followed him, which is why people saw them together. Even with Loughner in FBI custody, there are a lot of vicious accusations being slung between conservatives and liberals over the political rhetoric which may have fueled the emotions behind the shooting.

Pima County Sheriff Clarence Dupnik spoke passionately during a news conference yesterday about the unstable, polarizing state of politics in Arizona: “When you look at unbalanced people, how they respond to the vitriol that comes out of certain mouths about tearing down the government—the anger, the hatred, the bigotry that goes on in this country is getting to be outrageous. And unfortunately, Arizona, I think, has become the capital. We have become the mecca for prejudice and bigotry.” Much of the anger in this incident has been directed toward Sarah Palin, whose "Take Back the 20" initiative, an attempt to replace 20 Democrats who voted for the health care bill, targeted Giffords; in particular, Palin used a "gun target" image as part of the campaign. Giffords discussed Palin's initiative with MSNBC last March, and said, “Sarah Palin has the crosshairs of a gun sight over our district and when people do that, they’ve gotta realize there are consequences to that action.”

The News thinks that Palin's violent rhetoric (including labeling Giffords a "target") deserves some responsibility for the incident: "anyone with any sense at all knows that violent language can incite actual violence, that metaphor can incite murder. At the very least, Palin added to a climate of violence." Matt Bai thinks that it's a larger problem than a Blue/Red divide, speaking to a carelessness in our culture: "It’s more that [politicians] are so caught up in a culture of hyperbole, so amused with their own verbal flourishes and the ensuing applause, that — like the bloggers and TV hosts to which they cater — they seem to lose their hold on the power of words."

Conservative blogger Erick Erickson took some umbrage with Republicans getting blamed for the shooting, and argued that the media (and Democrats) have placed conservatives in danger with their implications: "By perpetuating the lie - by even treating it as a legitimate topic of consideration to revisit the accusations of violence and hate the media tried to run with prior to the November election - that the right and the tea party incited this evil act, the left and media may very well incite violence against the right." But one senior Republican senator, who spoke to Politico anonymously, thinks the terrible incident should be taken as a “cautionary tale” by Republicans. “There is a need for some reflection here - what is too far now? What was too far when Oklahoma City happened is accepted now. There’s been a desensitizing. These town halls and cable TV and talk radio, everybody’s trying to outdo each other.”

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • soxinthecity

    Luckily, the voices in my head just tell me to listen to more music.

  • splicernyc

    I continue to wonder why people who hear voices in their heads aren't compelled to do constructive things like bathe regularly or clean their rooms. The voices always tell you to kill. I don't get it.

  • Rod

    i hear voices in my head.

    it's called a "conscience".

    they tell me "why won't anyone shoot SCALIA???!!"

  • S.D.

    Um, Yeah, that's just wrong...

  • splicernyc

    No.

  • robingee

    Maybe there are people with Nice Voices but we don't know about it because they are being nice. Maybe... TOO NICE...

  • S.D.

    CNN employee Erick Erickson, like most of the Radical Right Wing full of S__t and a boob.

    How many Democrat politicians use violent rhetoric like:
    ‘Don’t Retreat, Instead – RELOAD!’
    '2nd Amendment Remedy'
    'WE CAME UNARMED [THIS TIME]'

    and
    'Pray for Obama—Psalm 109:8'
    'The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants.'

    Or encourage people to bring guns to a political event?

    O The Poor Right wing! Being held accountable for their own statements must really suck.

    Hey, that's some coincidence that takebackthe20.com went down yesterday, isn't it?

  • random transplant

    You forgot one very important question:

    How many democrats would have enabled such an unhinged, known wacko to waltz around with that level of firepower?

  • Rod

    good point. if the democrats had been listened to, Loughner couldn't have purchased the gun!

    republicans have always been a threat to this nation's security.

    round em up to GITMO. we can't take any chances, THEY say!

  • Spirit of 76

    "By perpetuating the lie - by even treating it as a legitimate topic of consideration to revisit the accusations of violence and hate the media tried to run with prior to the November election - that the right and the tea party incited this evil act, the left and media may very well incite violence against the right."

    Violence from whom??? When was the last time you saw a story about some gun-hating liberal shooting up a place? What a crock of bull.

  • Rod

    yeah, we have Palin and her fans ADMIT they love to kill for FUN (i mean "sport")!

    we need to round up all these terrorists of the American Taliban. They can hang out on Gitmo and tell us how we give too many perks to detainees!

  • handsomedevil

    And talk about hypocrisy.

    1) You insist on pointing to occasions where we implicitly encouraged violence. That's not fair! None of those statements could possibly make somebody shoot somebody.

    2) And furthermore, because you are doing this, it might encourage violence!

    Yeah, good job there buddy.

  • clafleche

    Blaming Palin for this type of violence is like blaming video games for Columbine. It's stupid and disgusting. It's using the tragedy to push an agenda.

    Crazy people are going to do crazy things. I doubt that Palin's rhetoric is what really pushed this guy over the edge. Come on.

  • mcsoxerhoff

    I tend to agree, I don't think the rhetoric (from Palin AND others) helped anything, but I also don't think it was the central cause.

  • Rod

    you are not smart. (i'm trying to be more sensitive in my language.)

    I mean, you are intellectually challenged.

    PALIN repeatedly used clearly-violent language like "reload" and the friggin GUN SIGHTS for Giffords, idiot.

    I mean, "you not-smart" person.

    under the law, you could arrest Palin on numerous charges but they won't.

    it's a variation of "inciting to riot".

  • handsomedevil

    Even if Palin's little bullseye map didn't cause the guy to do it, it still sucked. Palin's an irresponsible asshole, and that's the point.

    "It's using the tragedy to push an agenda"

    It's an agenda that needs to be pushed. Obviously, real people can really get shot. People were saying that all along, and somebody who can't show enough sense to think twice about what she says and act responsibly has no place in politics.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com