Quantcast

32 Hours Stranded on the Subway: One Survivor's Story

122810stranded2.jpg
Courtesy Madalyn McKay
Think those people trapped on the A train for seven hours at Aqueduct had it bad? Actress Madalyn McKay has them beat with her subway blizzard horror story. She just got back to her Borough Park home this morning...34 hours after leaving a party on the Upper West Side Sunday night. 32 of those hours were spent languishing on a stranded subway train at the ground-level Bay Parkway N station.

McKay tells us her eventful journey home began around 8:30 p.m. Sunday night, and was going just fine until her D train switched over to the N line at 36th Street in Brooklyn, because of a signal problem. Around 9:15, the train ground to a halt before the Bay Parkway Station, and passengers heard the old familiar ruse, "We will be moving shortly."

A half hour passed, and they were informed that a stalled train at Bay Parkway was being removed, and once that happened, they would proceed. But "proceed" is a vague term, and the plan changed again: There was yet another train between McKay's train and the stalled train; this train would move up enough so that the first car reached platform, and then McKay's train would pull up behind it, enabling passengers to walk into the second train and exit to the platform. They could then "proceed" on foot... into the blizzard.

The MTA motorman and conductor urged passengers to stay on the train because of the inclement weather, but those who were near their destinations departed on foot, leaving about 30-40 souls behind. (A homeless woman remained on McKay's original train because she couldn't get her cart through the doors between cars.) Fortunately, there was heat on the train and a bathroom in the station for the stranded commuters. And, in an attempt to keep spirits bright, there was singing and comedy! McKay tells us:

I have to say MTA motorman and conductor were fantastic through this whole ordeal. I couldn't leave because I was so far off course and the snow was so heavy; I couldn't go anywhere. I had never been in that neighborhood before, so I had no idea where to go. But the conductor and the motorman were both singers—and so am I—so we sang some songs together. We all sang Chestnuts Roasting on Open Fire, and the motorman sang Ave Maria, and a bunch of songs I didn't know. A friend had asked people to send me jokes over Twitter, so before my phone died I was telling jokes.

There was a deli close by where we could get coffee and junk food. And so around 2 a.m. we all hunkered down for the night. There was heat on the train but the heat doesn't stay stay trapped very well, because, according to the conductor, that model of train doesn't have good insulation. The next day (Monday) came. The conductor and motorman still urged us not to leave unless we knew where we were going. But the MTA never gave us any information and we had no idea if or when anyone would come to fix the train. The MTA wasn't even telling the MTA employees on the train. We didn't know if buses were running or anything.

Around one or two in the afternoon a sweet young woman named Victoria, dressed like a snowboarder, came to the train to take photos of the snowed-in train and was shocked to find people inside. She knew the neighborhood very well and gave everyone directions if their destination was within a mile or two. But some of us, like me, lived in the opposite direction. A lot of the people left at this point, and then there were about 6 or 8 of us.

So then we all just entertained ourselves. One couple had their cat with them, so I got to know them. The motorman and the conductor told us stories about working for the MTA, and we got into singing again. They had been there for a good 24 hours on duty, and so finally a relief crew came for them. This was another great group of guys! I had tried to leave a couple of times—not because I didn't like the company—but because I have a cat and a job. So I kept making trips to the bodega and they tried to find a car service, but car services weren't even functioning yesterday. There were no buses, no cars, no taxis, nothing! And so I kept going back to the train. I was really cold last night—I was still dressed from the party. So I tried again at 5 a.m. this morning and finally found a car service who, for $40, could take me about two or three blocks from my home, until he got stuck in the snow.

When I left this morning there are still people on the train—the couple with the cat, a lady with diabetes who didn't have her insulin, and a couple of other people who kept to themselves, and the homeless woman whom we never saw because she would never leave that rear train because she couldn't get her cart through the doors. I don't know what became of them.

For all we know, they're still there! Repeated calls and e-mail inquires to the MTA press office have not been returned, but we'll update if we get any news about the remaining survivors on the D train from hell. Meanwhile, the MTA is promising to investigate why those passengers were stuck on the A train for six hours.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • soxinthecity

    This is why it is important to live near an underground subway if you want to go out partying in a blizzard.

  • "as laughable as a college freshman wielding a copy of Atlas Shrugged and telling a beggar to get a job" BINGO.

  • ...I don't get it. Why didn't you just get off at New Utrecht on the N line? It's the same stop as 62nd street on the D which is followed by the 50th and 55th stops for Borough Park, which I assume one of which was yours. I don't feel sorry for you not knowing how to use the train.

  • How did she end up past Borough Park waiting for a train to go even farther south? If I missed my stop I wouldn't sit around for 32 hours to continue going in the wrong direction...

  • Our Thoughts & Prayers are with those of you affected by this East Coast Blizzard. Let us all say a prayer as the NY Times reports many are still without power.

  • Yahtzee

    Seriously, even to the northern most part of borough park that station is at most 2-3 miles. Give me a fuckin break. Even if she wasn't dressed warm it's her own fault for A) Going out to a party when a blizzard is forecast, B) Underdressing when a blizzard is forecast, C) Staying at said party until 8:30 when it had been snowing for at least 8 fucking hours already.

  • GothamExtremist

    That station and boro-park is at most a 1/2 hr walk during normal weather, and proly 2 hrs during the blizzaard, get off you fat ass and walk!

  • robingee

    See, THAT'S why s/he's the EXTREMIST!

    Mountain DEW!

  • I was on that same D train. After being stuck for over two hours and walked forward to the train whose first car was at Bay Parkway, I just started walking. It was only about 2 miles for me to get home, and to say the walk was easy wouldn't be quite right: http://photos.igorbass.com/Dai... is what Bay Parkway looked like while I was walking.
    Hard to imagine people spending that long on a train near a station, I probably would've walked to Manhattan by then, just because I can't sit still for quite that long without trying something.

  • cr17

    The lighting in your photos really captures the experience of trudging through all that. Beautiful stuff.

  • Thanks!

  • BillyBob26

    So I'm the idiot for calling this person out who decided to stay on a train for 32 hours in a blizzard? She had the option to get off the train. When she was on her original train and knew it would change tracks, she should have gotten off there and figured out how to get home on the correct path. Why would she continue on a wrong train line in a blizzard? Also, she got off the train and went to a convenience store, she could have asked how to get home from there or even look at a map. Instead of looking at other ways to get home or to call a friend for help, she asks for jokes to be sent to her so she could sing show tunes with a flippin bum???? This story is the most ridiculous thing ever.

    Also, TheOtherBob, you're defending this woman for not dressing properly, wearing light clothes and high heels?? THIS IS A FUCKING BLIZZARD, NOT A WARM SUMMER NIGHT!!! She deserves to get stranded out in the middle of nowhere. We all knew this storm was coming well before Sunday.

    How could you physically be stuck at a station for 32 hours? She left the party at 830PM, the height of the storm, 12 hours later at 830AM, i was able to walk to get to work in Manhattan from Brooklyn. This lady stayed on the train for another 20 HOURS!!! TWENTY ADDITIONAL HOURS. She stayed on the train during a day filled with sun, a dead phone, no food or water with the ability to leave. There were tons of cabs all day Monday, buses were running and people were walking the streets.

    Think about this.

  • jacqueline66

    I agree with you. 36 hrs is a long time to stick around and "suffer" when you could find your way home in 3 max!

    She might be hella' fun to be around, but I'd rather be stranded on a train with someone who is motivated to get us off the train than someone who there and just wants to party for 36 hrs more.

    Somethings not right about this story if they can go up to the bodega or catch a taxi. I'm sure a group of them could split the ride and get to another train AT LEAST. Taxi drivers have been known to help others with free rides, you can at least try to do something for yourselves instead of spending 36 hrs there.

  • robingee

    Boy, you seem like a swell fella! Wanna hang out sometime and yell at homeless people?

  • angry_pickle

    I don't understand. Everyone knew a large blizzard was coming starting Sunday afternoon which will last until Monday afternoon. So she decides to party on Sunday night. Whatever.

  • verbal

    Thankfully they had heat, and the crew sounds like they helped make an awful situation tolerable, even if they were making golden time at that point.

    As unfathomable as it is to NY'ers that they could be stranded for so long within the city limits, it's a reminder that your attitude has everything to do with it.

  • robingee

    No joke. On Christmas DAY I ran into so many a-holes, driving like nuts, screaming, honking horns. You can't take ONE day off from being a total handjob? Come on, peoples.

  • cr17

    This lady has a great attitude, so good for her - it's nice to hear a story on here where someone's not bitching/moaning about how it's everyone else's fault. However, what I don't understand is what sort of idiot would go to a party, and what sort of idiot would hold a party, when they know full well that we're going to be blasted by snow? It's irresponsible to ask people to risk their skin to come out and partake in your fruity drinks, light conversation, and yum-yums. It's Man vs. Mother Nature and believe me she's a huge c*nt with no sense of forgiveness. She will f*ck you up every time. You can say that the MTA is not prepared, but at some point there is nothing they can do and you need to be prepared for the worst by staying put. Stay home, fire up some DVD's, yakitty-yak it up with your friends on the phone about how crazy it is outside, and relax.

  • JenEsss

    Hindsight. Do you always trust weather reports? I didn't believe we were getting a full-blown blizzard til I woke up Monday.

  • NlGGAZ

    I just hope everyone learns that when they say BLIZZARD it means you are fucked if you venture outside. My brother drove last year and got stuck in a little amount of snow and this year the einstein drove during the blizzard. guess what? dude is stuck in lower brooklyn. no sympathy at all

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com