Quantcast

Trapped In Crowded Subway Elevator: One Woman's Story

120710elevator1.jpg Yesterday morning, a group of 15 adults and two children squeezed into the elevator in the F train station on Roosevelt Island. And there they remained for a full hour until the FDNY came to their rescue. One commuter, an administrative assistant at a financial firm named Alexis, passed the time by tweeting about the situation (sample: "This day keeps getting worse. I'd jump in front of a train but the MTA would find some way to cock that up too!") Today she sent us a thorough account of her experience, with video of that triumphant moment when the FDNY popped open the ceiling hatch. Here is her story:

Let me just say that I’m not surprised it had problems. The last time this thing was inspected was probably St. Swithen’s Day. Even on a good run it’s very slow to respond and pretty grungy, but I digress. I got on the elevator at 8:05am on Monday, December 6th. Like everyone else on the planet I was checking my twitter feed and noted the time. We all piled in, about 15 people, 3 kids aged from about 6 to 12 and one father with his baby in a stroller.

Seconds into its descent the inside door opened and caused the elevator to stop about 20 to 30 feet below ground level. The man nearest the door tried shutting it a few times; it popped back open twice before closing. The elevator didn’t move after that so we called for “help.” Time in elevator: 10 min (8:15am) The MTA person on the other end came through garbled at best, but offered no real help anyway. The person said they would call the engineer. Ok fine. There was grumbling, one person louder than others, but overall no one was particularly panicked. Ten more minutes go by and it’s getting hot in there. There’s one small vent near the front which is clogged with dirt and who knows what.

We jam the bell button, bang on the door and yell into the call button. One woman was particularly vocal, and who could blame her. It was tightly packed in there, getting stuffier by the moment and there was NO communication from the MTA. When the MTA rep gets back on the speaker, they say, “The engineer is on his way. 10 minutes.” We’ve been stuck about 30 minutes at this point and patience is wearing thin. I think the baby was the most unperturbed of the lot of us. Aerosmith’s “Love in an Elevator” looped in my head, but I thought singing it would be in bad taste.

Half an hour in a metal box is bad enough, but the air was getting hot and thin and a couple of people we starting to feel woozy. We decided to save ourselves and managed to call 911 on an iPhone with 1 ½ bars of service. I was near the back of the box (which must have been lead lined) and got no reception on my phone. So I took video. Where was I going? 911 dispatch hooked us up with the FDNY within seconds and we heard that they would be on the scene in 10 minutes - fine. At least it seemed like someone on the outside, with sense, was on the way.

I asked if anyone could fake going into labor. Another woman passed around cold tangerines to the kids. A little girl said her daddy could help but he was in California and it was too far. The baby was just relaxing. Her dad looked a little hot and frustrated, poor guy. We also agreed that the MTA can ‘sod off’ if they expect to raise the fair again. It was about 5-10 minutes after 911, now 40 - 45 minutes total, when we heard the FDNY banging on the ground level doors and calling out to us. Finally, someone who gave a crap! For the next 15 - 20 minutes they popped the top hatch of the elevator for us to breath, talked us through what was going on and did what they had to in order to get everyone one out safe. Total time in elevator: 60 minutes (9:15am -finally free!)

When I was 5 I found some weird looking pieces of metal in my dad’s tool box. He said it was an elevator key and I could open the doors with it if I ever got stuck; so much for that. The escalators there are perpetually broken as well. My mom was on one when it suddenly stopped. If she wasn’t holding onto the rail she would have been thrown back. I saw another person get his jacket snagged on a section without paneling. He had to keep climbing while he freed himself. When it rains, the place is soaked with water. No one mops. I was being super careful because of that but I slipped and cracked my shins anyway. Did I mention the doors have been broken for months? Yeah, the Roosevelt Island station is a mess and the MTA staff that work there are rude and useless. I’ll take my chances with the tram. At least if that gets stuck I watch YouTube.

So there you have it! The Roosevelt Island Public Safety Director tells Roosevelt Islander that no injuries were reported, and we're waiting for the MTA to get back to us with a comment. In the meantime, here's video of the FDNY arriving to open the box. The moment seems strangely anticlimactic—no cheering, no high-fives—but it looks like our narrator was trapped with a surprisingly calm group of people, and nobody turned out to be the devil (besides the MTA).

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • whitecastlerock

    Elevators? Is that what those are? Judging from the shit, piss, and rubbish strewn over the floors, I thought they were employee bathrooms.

  • Guest

    This station isn't nearly as bad as some of the ones around the boroughs that force you to use an elevator to get to the platform or street. Those are SCARY because you have no other choice.

  • Roosevelt Islander

    The Roosevelt Island F Train Subway station is very deep underground. From station platform to street level is approximately 157 steps. It would take a bit more that 5 minutes for most people to walk up the steps when escalators are out of service.
    http://tinyurl.com/2ak97ha

  • silver

    Break the hatch yourself you lazy bums. Theres gonna be atleast one meathead who can lift himself out through the ceiling and standing on the hand rails.

  • eflash

    Gothamist_Cynic and PTG need to get some facts straight. This station is 10 stories underground. I think plenty of able-bodied men and women would choose the elevator over 10 flights of stairs.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R...

  • PTG in nyc

    okay, then move somewhere else. Just because RI has a 212 area code and is part of the Manhattan borough doesn't mean the subway isn't further underground. There's one stop for RI and it's in the middle of the East River, of course it's a deep station.

    Nonetheless, people used to take the subway before AC, escalators, and elevators, so I'm still hesitant to care about the able bodied who don't want to take the stairs. People with disabilities and strollers, I'm sorry to hear your station is even worse than the average MTA debacle.

  • Guest

    I've to that station. There are not 10 flights of stairs.

  • fuboy

    I want to get Alexis' full name so we can dedicate a holiday to her and the survivors of this horror. The poise and quiet resolve she showed in this crisis is truly a testament to the American Spirit overcoming egregious obstacles.

    I'm just relieved they were rescued before resorting to cannibalism in order to survive.

  • PTG in nyc

    lol, totally! MTA is crap, so are their elevators, I get that. But there seem to be lots of able bodied, non child toting individuals in that elevator that should have taken the escalator or stairs.

    I was trapped in an elevator for an hour last year, the engineer took an hour to show up, and somehow I managed not to feel sorry for myself and complain to the blogosphere. I did have to pee though, that was a challenge.

    This is nonsense, boohoo

  • mns

    Let's spend our tax money on more roads. For cars.

  • Guest

    MTA elevators are disgusting. If you're too lazy to walk up a flight of stairs, you deserve to get stuck in there. Also handicapped people deserve better treatment than those elevators.

  • reggies

    Roosevelt Island has over 3 progressive sets of escalators which are constantly in repair... yes 3, it's that deep in middle earth. It's not laziness to use that elevator it's practicality, especially for all of the parents with strollers, the elderly, and those on the island who need assistance. There are many people here who are in treatment at the hospitals.

  • Lost in Space

    I am sorry but it is pure laziness. There are escalators going down the three flights. Moving steps. But hey, it takes 5 extra minutes to get to the platform.

  • reggies

    As a RI resident I can honestly say that those escalators are shut down almost every other day for repair. It's a real pain in the rear to run down 3 flights of stairs every day to catch a train. If you manage to catch the elevator with a stroller once in a while it feels like a dream.

  • RobNYC

    I see your point about elderly people. Having said that, anyone who gets off the orange line at 34th and 6th deals with three flights of stairs too.

  • Detex

    what is this orange line you speak of?

    Go back to Boston!

  • thirteen

    orange line? this is nyc, not boston

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com