Quantcast

Video: Yankees Bleacher Creatures' "Gay Man" Song

2010_09_bleahercreatu.jpg In the midst of several highly publicized suicides and attacks of gay men recently, as well as a "die-in" at Grand Central on Friday, a tipster sent in this account of the Yankees/Twins playoff game from last night:

I have proudly lived in New York City for over two years, and, unlike the often-heard stereotypes, have found this city's inhabitants to be kind, respectful, and even polite. This changed the night of Oct. 9, when I attended the New York Yankees game against the Minnesota Twins. As a Midwest native showing up to the game in my Twins regalia, I expected to be picked on. I expected to be heckled. What I did not expect was to hear homophobic and anti-gay cheers sung by the crowd.

During the traditional singing of YMCA, when the grounds crew takes to the field, suddenly the crowd erupted into lyrics singing, "Why are you gay, I saw you sucking some d-i-c-k." Other lyrics called people who are gay sinners and disease-ridden. I couldn't believe my ears. Whatever people may say about Minnesota or the Midwest, such hurtful and disgusting things would never be shouted at a Twins game. What an embarrassment for Yankees fans and New York City.

The tipster also suggests that the Yankees should hold an LGBT respect night. According to this site (which only goes up through 2008), more than half the teams in the league, including the Mets, have had such nights, and they've been relatively successful. The Cubs, who have an openly gay owner, have held the event since 2001.

The "Gay Man"/"Why Are You Gay" song seems to be a tradition of Section 39/Section 203, aka the Bleacher Creatures, and is directed at fans of the opposing team sitting in or near the section. (You can see a 2007 video of it below, as well as several other examples here.) However, just last month, an umpire ejected a rowdy drunk fan who was yeling homophobic slurs at a player.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Streetsmartz

    Ha they've been singing that forever. I got season tickets in the bleachers one year. I attended two games, got in a

    Fight with the loser bleacher creatures and needless to say sold my tickets for the rest of the year and sat somewhere else. Sad part is it was alcohol free seating.

  • HBHB

    Sorry, but you blew it with "I have proudly lived in New York City for over two years". I shut off after that.

  • Gbutters

    This is why I watch soccer... and because it's awesome! - Go Redbulls!

  • theplanetofchuck

    Wow, you haven't been a soccer fan for long have you.

  • Dogsbody

    It depends whether he means "this is why I watch soccer [to avoid the homophobic abuse]" or "this is why I watch soccer [because I enjoy the homophobic abuse]".

  • rahchis

    napalm,

    In all your talk of what's natural versus not and sex being a mean's of recreation... you do realize that humans aren't like most other animals in that we have sex merely for pleasure, as well as procreation? In fact, most animals only have sex when in heat and the female is ovulating which sometimes is as little as twice a year; depending on the species. Also, we tend to also not walk around nude and have sex in private. Thus, to say we only have sex for reproduction is asinine. Also, as others have pointed out... homosexuality is totally natural as it's a heritable trait and observed throughout nature, meaning there is evolutionary reason and use for it. For all we know, it may be a means of population control or extra care-giving or who know what else? If it is intended by "nature" as population control, it is a shame both your parents weren't gay and possibly disinterested in reproducing as they've clearly passed down genes for stupidity that will further contaminate the genome of H. sapiens sapiens. But as I said, most gene expression that still is around has a purpose. Perhaps yours is to make us all laugh.

  • Reflect

    Dont worry napalm will get his u know how many people are gay nurses? Hes the type u see in the nursing home slapping his ass with bed sores the size of a baseball, incapacitated by a stroke sue to his own life stupidity.... Trust me these people get theres alls fun and games when u can walk and talk shit. But another story when your laying in it from your own attitude..

    K a r m a is s o real.

  • hellogreg

    I witnessed a similar thing years ago at the old stadium. A fan was wearing the visiting team's hat and was taunted so mercilessly, it verged on physical violence.

    Personally I'd rather my tax dollars went toward educating these buffoons, than building them a shiny new stadium.

  • boogpowell

    Wearing opposing team gear is just asking for confrontation. If you want to enjoy the game as an opposing teams fan just wear plain clothes. Im sure alcohol had somethign to do with this case if it involved physcial violence. But if you wear a Red Sox shirt to Yankees stadium you really should be expecting to get heckled and yelled at. Same thing happens when I wear my Yankees stuff to Fenway park or any other stadium for that matter. Its the nature of sports fans. Im not condoning any type of physical violence but heckling is permissable.

  • henrycat

    Two years ago I went to a Yankees-Red Sox game at the stadium wearing my Manny Ramirez t-shirt and was sexually assaulted by some drunk fans. This doesn't surprise me and the poor Twins fan should feel lucky that somethnig more serious didn't happen. I will never go back there.

  • boogpowell

    That sounds pretty harsh and shouldnt have happened. You could have told a security guard or police officer at the stadium. They assuredly would have removed you or the person harassing you from the situation. There is never a reason a person should touch you. There is no excuse for anyone doing what you explained but, you should never wear a Manny Ramirez jersey to yankees stadium. Wearing anything Red Sox is just like putting a kick me sign on your back. Like I said, there is never any reason for anyone to touch you.

  • henrycat

    I expected a little harassment for wearing a Red Sox shirt. I would give dirty looks to people in Yankees gear when I lived in Boston. But, supporting the opposing team is never justification for assault, sexism and homophobia.

    I got my revenge. I told him about the friends I had in the Bronx DAs office and what he could be charged with and he started to cry and continued crying for the last three innings of the game. Just threatening to prosecute him was enough. His bros were so ashamed and so afraid of getting in trouble they sat in their seats and barely watched the rest of the game.

  • boogpowell

    When did everyone get so touchy feely about a little ribbing. Get over it. Theres a lot worse things that can be done to a person than singing a silly song, jokingly calling someone gay. Or does everyone just want every person, place and thing to be 100% politically correct? Doing stupid stuff like singing this version of YMCA are just a fun part of sitting in the crazy bleachers. Relax and dont let every little thing get under your skin.

  • whatsd

    If that song had been called "Black Man" instead of "Gay Man", there would have been rioting.

  • ShadowCat

    You're right. That's SO cute. Can we revert to making fun of blacks, Jews and Hispanics out in the open with NO consequence? Pretty please? It's just ribbing.

  • boogpowell

    Watch any rap video and you will see they make fun of blacks every other word. Watch Jerry Seinfeld's standup and you will hear him make fun of Jews. Watch Carlos Mencia and you will hear him make fun of hispanics. All of these things are done out in the open with no consequence. Are you offended by all of these things too and think they should all come to an end?

  • ShadowCat

    I should have clarified. Can people from OPPOSING races make fun of others without consequence. For example, can I dress up in black face and run around with a watermelon? It's just ribbing. When a person mocks their own race, it's just self-depricating, not racist.

  • boogpowell

    I disagree. Not everything is ment to be hateful. People joke about other peoples races, religions, etc. It should never get to a point of physical violence or serious threats. But a funny song or some jokes is completely harmless. There are plenty of comedians and joke songs that joke about things that arent the race of the person saying them. TV shows frequently use gay humor along with movies and music. If you are that insecure with yourself that a few jokes makes you cry harassment then its really you that has the problem. Why is everyone these days so easily offended? When did NYC just become a bunch of crybabys?

  • robingee

    Carlos Mencia isn't hispanic.

  • OSN!

    1) Why would anyone be 'surprised' by this behavior at Yankee Stadium?

    2) I guarantee you a few of those guys are themselves homosexual or bisexual.

    3) Making fun of homosexuals is one of the great last bastions of hate our PC world hasn't eradicated.. Can't get away with publicly doing [in semi-polite society] to various racial, ethnic, and religious groups, but you sure can still mock and laugh at homosexuals.

    And no,I'm not homosexual or bi, I'm heterosexual, and pretty conservative.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com