The Mark The Mark Restaurant, another venture from chef/brand Jean-Georges Vongerichten, is a "welcome addition to the Upper East Side," writes Times critic Sam Sifton in his two star review. Located in The Mark hotel, the dining room "lies behind a small bar filled with low-slung pony-skin chairs. Older men unsure of how they’re going to get out of them sit there, pondering the issue over vodka as cubs and cougars banter and text. Dinner seems unlikely. Past them, though, down a dark corridor that doubles as a modernist wine cellar, a very good restaurant blooms."
Vongerichten's other new local restaurant, ABC Kitchen (located inside ABC Carpet & Home on 18th Street), gets even more love from other critics today. Time Out's Jay Cheshes awards it five out of five stars, deeming it "a stunner... Though the restaurant’s sustainable ethos is outlined on the back of the menu like an Al Gore polemic, the cooking, based on the most gorgeous ingredients from up and down the East Coast, delivers one message above all: Food that’s good for the planet needn’t be any less opulent, flavorful or stunning to look at. It’s haute green cuisine." The Post's Steve Cuozzo (or as he's known among the Lakota, "He Who Yells at Clouds") is less enraptured (he hates the "flimsy" chairs, the "leathery, juiceless, joyless" pork chops) but declares that ABC Kitchen could make a tyrannosaurus — or even a carnivorous critic — give up meat and fish. Its best dishes contain neither."
The Village Voice's Sarah DiGregorio says The Fatty 'Cue, Zak Pelaccio's smoky new joint in Williamsburg, is "simple but ingenious—quality meat smoked low and slow, plus Southeast Asian ingredients like lemongrass, chilies, palm syrup, fish sauce, galangal, and so on." But such small portions! "Yes, these ingredients are thoughtfully sourced, and the meat comes from responsible, eco-friendly purveyors, but from a customer's point of view, it feels like a rip-off, especially when the vibe of the place is so pointedly casual." Meanwhile, her colleague Robert Sietsema says Murray Hill restaurant Talent Thai Kitchen is "one of the city's best Thais."
The New Yorker's Shauna Lyon favorably reviews Soho bistro La Sirène, where "the décor supports the siren theme loosely, at best—slightly dingy walls, painted canary yellow, crimson, and cobalt, randomly hung with nautical ephemera and mosaics de la mer. The high prices (compensating, in part, for the B.Y.O.B. policy) are mitigated by how seriously the food is taken, and by the generous portions. Escargots à la Bourguignonne (“1/2 dozen in the Shell!” the menu exclaims) arrive on an etched silver plate, with gorgeous matching tongs, elevating the experience of imbibing copious pools of garlic butter."
And New York's Adam Platt bestows two stars out of five on both The Mark and Recette. At the former, the lobster "was oily and without taste, the Parmesan-crusted chicken was overcooked, and the lamb chops (muffled in unfortunate black-olive bread crumbs) caused my neighbor to put down his fork in sorrow and mutter, 'That’s a sad end to a good lamb.'" The latter, located in the West Village, "isn’t much to look at (spare dark-wood tabletops squeezed between drab olive walls, with a scattering of antique knickknacks), but the modestly priced (only three dishes cost over $20) small-plate, 'urban American' menu is full of all sorts of elegant and unexpected surprises."