Quantcast

Your Annoying Roommate Situation Is Also Illegal

032910couple.jpg Today the Times notices a little known and seldom enforced law that prohibits more than three unrelated people from living in an apartment or a house in NYC. Chances are that includes you and pretty much everyone you know, except maybe those ex-roommates who've broken loose and moved in with their significant others. (They'll be back!) So why would a city with such obscenely high rents try to deprive residents of an all-too-common necessity: non-familial cohabitation?

Eric Bederman, a spokesman for the housing department, says the code was devised for residents’ safety, to prevent people with multiple roommates from erecting barriers that would foil escape attempts during emergencies. But Jerilyn Perine, a former city housing commissioner, tells the Times that the roommates limit was implemented in the '50s, as an attempt to convert boarding house brownstones and their "sketchy inhabitants" back to family homes. Now we're all sketchy! And illegal. And leaving our dishes in the sink. (Sorry!)

Thankfully, the law is rarely enforced, in most cases only when a neighbor complains or inspectors spot a violation while visiting for other reasons. (Only three citations have been issued since July.) In 2008, almost 15,000 dwellings were occupied by three or more unrelated roommates, according to the most recent Census data. But anecdotal evidence—plus the fact that pretty much everyone we know is reduced to living with roommates into senescence—suggests that number is a little low. Instead of limiting the number of roommates in an apartment, maybe the city should start implementing roommate age limits.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • taracorinne

    this is something that annoys me as I have many friends in DC where group houses are super common. laws like this prevent such cohabitation situations from occurring and that sucks.

  • J.d.

    So why would a city with such obscenely high rents try to deprive residents of an all-too-common necessity: non-familial cohabitation?

    The main reason, as people say, is preventing informal flophouses/SROs/dormitories. The other is, at least according to legend, is to give the city an easy way to shut down brothels. Can't prove prostitution? No need, if you can just prove there are more than X number of unrelated people living there!

  • buttface

    from someone living in a building full of migrant workers, i can attest: this law needs to be enforced.

  • neonwattagelimit

    I was surprised by this, but then I realized that most people I know have one or two roommates, so I'd guess we're OK.

  • r1b2

    except maybe those ex-roommates who've broken loose moved in with their significant others.

    BS. They're moving in with their parents.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com