Quantcast

Church Vs. Bike Lane War Rages On

032410henryst.jpg
Peter Kaufman/Ink Lake
One quaint block of Henry Street in Brooklyn Heights has become the latest bitterly contested front in the city's bike lane wars. For years now, parishioners at First Presbyterian Church have been given illegal parking placards by the church, which they place inside their cars when parking in the bike lane during services. Local police have always looked the other way, but back in December, Heights resident Peter Kaufman finally snapped, and posted an epic video of the weekly bike lane block on his blog, Ink Lake. We've always believed that an indignant blog post is all it takes to effect change, but in this case it seems nothing happened!

The Brooklyn Paper followed up with church leader Rev. Stephen Phelps, who argues that without the bike lane parking he'd be left with empty pews. "Churches would fail if they could not allow the driving public to come near," Phelps tells BP. "The police recognize that churches make extraordinary contributions to the community. [DiPaolo] basically confirmed that this is a long standing practice. While we are really interested in the question of reducing the use of cars and supporting bikers — we see this as an acceptable cost, and they agree."

Mark DiPaolo is the 84th Precinct captain, and he won't talk about the bike lane brouhaha with the Brooklyn Paper, or with us for that matter. The Henry Street bike lane is one of the oldest in the city, dating back to the '70s, but the church has it beat by about 150 years, having first formed in 1822. It's a relatively low-traffic Street, but it's narrow, and when the bike lane's blocked, that "means that a parked car puts you right into moving traffic," says Wiley Norvell, a spokesperson for Transportation Alternatives.

A rabbi at the Brooklyn Heights Synagogue on nearby Remsen Street defends the church's use of the bike lane, but cyclists say it's unpardonable. "Why should they get special treatment putting cyclists at risk?" cyclist Rob Hall wants to know. "Every time a cyclist has to go off a bicycle path in order to avoid a double parked or illegally parked car, it puts both cyclists and motorists at risk. A person in a car is not going to expect to see a bicycle out of the lane."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • usernamee

    and don't forget, churches are tax exempt.

    so, not only are they illegally taking street space for parking, they are taking street space that you and i paid for, and they did not.

  • Billy Simmons

    Here's a thought. Park legally or take mass transit to church. Why should churchgoers be given special privileges? Other people want to drive or safely ride their bikes, and these law breaking churchgoers are infringing on our rights.

  • Gwinny

    As an avid cyclist/commuter, I can't stand it when cars park in the bike lane. It drives me nuts.

    HOWEVER.... there have to be exceptions to the rules every once in a while. Henry Street is a quiet side street -- it's not Avenue of the Americas. Plus church services are a once-a-week thing... in Harlem, people double-park routinely for church services whether or not there is a bike lane (there usually isn't).

    I say let's focus on the greater issues, like people parking in bike lanes in high-traffic areas (for example, that approach to the Brooklyn Bridge everyone's upset about, or any number of bike-laned streets in Manhattan). This one simply isn't worth the fight. Sorry, but it's true.

  • usernamee

    i've said it before, and i'll say it again:

    put stickers on the windows of cars blocking bike lanes reminding car owners that they are breaking the law and endangering lives.

    preferably the ones that are really hard to remove.

  • potsmoker

    pretty simple solution, show up early sunday morning and park your bike there.

    protest by taking action

    you two wheeled pusses.

    if the police take some sort of unfair action against the bikers by claiming they are blocking a bike lane with bikes! then just ride slowly start to finish, get off walk bike back on sidewalk without breaking any laws, get back in bike lane amd bike real slow and prevent cars from PARKING in the bike lane, this can go on all day and the police would be unable to legally stop it. any action or claim that the police are arresting or ticketing bikers lawfully riding in the lane and lawfully walking their bikes on the sidewalk would prove that the church and the police are gigving special treatment to the chruch and allowing illegal parking and permitting fake & illegal placards to trump a bike lane.

    anyone want to do it, im game!

  • Dear PS,

    I'm the author of inklake. If you go to my blog, you'll find my e-mail address under the 'About' section.

  • csk

    The double parked cars are also an issue in Bed Stuy near Lewis Ave.

    Ticket and tow them all!

  • Boogie Down

    Many streets in Harlem are barely impassable due to double parking during church services. Oh, how I long to one day live again in a place where virtually nobody goes to church anymore.

  • BDS=(Boycott.Divest.Sanction)

    whats bothers me most is the flagrant disregard for enforcing the law against "certain" people which the pct seems to practice.

    Not only should the church goers look or pay for parking like everyone else, but the cops who colluded with them should lose their jobs for not upholding their oath.

  • Spirit of 76

    Give the cops a break. They're just afraid they'd be struck down by lightning bolts.

  • Professor_X

    Maybe they could install some bike parking inside the church to offset the inconvenience to cyclists.

    Just a few steel rings set into the pews for a u-lock to pass through would be all they'd need. I'm sure the church is empty aside from Sunday monrings and AA meetings.

  • soxinthecity

    The best solution is to close Henry Street to non church car traffic on Sunday mornings, which would let the holy rollers double park while bike riders can ride safely.

  • Brainwash

    He should put a barricade at the end of the street that says BIKES ONLY WHILE CHURCH IS IN SERVICE

  • soxinthecity

    There are no bike lanes on the road to heaven.

  • JenChungsBaby

    I'm shocked -- SHOCKED -- that the captain of the 84th precinct won't talk to Gothamist.

    Good thing you've got the TA spokescoyote on speed dial.

  • peanuthead

    haha! spokescoyote! beep! beep! maybe this time he can get his verbs, conjugations, nouns, subjects and what-not straight. oh, and bonus points for not sounding as if he speaks for the entire nyc cycling community.

  • handsomedevil

    Churches would fail if they could not allow the driving public to come near

    Jeez, if your parishoners can't schlep to your church from the subway station they must not be very dedicated. Perhaps you deserve to fail.

  • peanuthead

    "The Henry Street bike lane is one of the oldest in the city, dating back to the '70s . . . "

    john, are you sure about that? i cycle all over the city and recall that bike lane sprouting up only a few years ago. it actually caught many people's attention because it is one of the first ones to be completely filled in with green paint. perhaps that is the "first" you are referring to?

  • gothamguy

    Go by that same church anytime after it snows. You will see that the sidewalk is never shoveled. It is like they simply ignore all laws.

  • drewo

    The police recognize that churches make extraordinary contributions to the community.

    The community would just be happy if your business paid taxes.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com