Quantcast

Is Lox Kosher? Or Crawling with Tiny Worms?

03082010bagel.jpg

Chevra Mehadrin, a small group of ultra-Orthodox rabbis, recently announced a ban on lox, claiming a parasite that attaches itself to salmon makes it non-kosher. The Orthodox Union says the bagel topping is safe, despite sometimes carrying a worm called anisakis. "The issue has been resolved in Jewish law for hundreds of years already," Rabbi Moshe Elefant told the Post, dismissing the upstate rabbis’ suggestion. But kosher or not, are New Yorkers really spreading worms on their bagels?

Anisakis is most common in wild salmon, according to the Beyond Salmon blog, though herring and sardines also fall prey to the parasite. Wikipedia says that if the worms find their way inside you, you may experience “violent abdominal pain, nausea, and vomiting,” forget Jewish guilt. However, despite increasing concern in Orthodox communities, scientists say the worms aren’t a danger. “Anisakis has been around since before man. It’s one of nature’s greatest achievements as a parasite,” said Dr. Ted Myers, Alaska’s chief fish pathologist.

As for whether the worm turns lox into treif, the rabbinical jury’s still out. “Every five years they discover this problem,” Rabbi Dovid Cohen told the Jewish Star, adding that one rabbi considered “writing a teshuva (answer) explaining why salmon is kosher but did not, out of concern that it be used after his death to find justifications to prohibit the fish.” Rabbi Charim Golberg claims that in addition to lox, the other fish on Chevra Mehadrun’s blacklist (hake, flounder, sol, halibut, sea bass, red perch, scrod, pollock, cod and butter fish) should all be considered kosher. “It’s nothing to carp about,” he said.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • shinbet

    religious bias aside, take a look at this video, they are pulling real worms out of the thing...

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIuV1rRosI4

    Watch at the 2 minute mark,

    Enjoy your dinner..

  • really!?!?

    is this the same group who claimed a few years ago that tap water isn't kosher unless you buy their filtration system that costs $1,000s?

  • DG

    "It’s nothing to carp about”, yeah, Rabbi Cohen moonlights at the Improv...

  • Brian

    How about spelling my name correctly lady?

    Looks like Jewish Star "scooped" all the news agencies who are always a dollar short and (apparently a week and a half) late!

  • JenChungsBaby

    It's nothing to carp about.

  • Rocknrope

    Um, because nobody cares?

  • gawzmta

    So no anisakis for the Ashkenazis?

    (Nobody made this joke yet?)

  • CR

    Hey Sabrina (and Gothamist) in general: How about one story about something related to keeping Kosher or Judaism in general that doesn't mention guilt, or say "oy vey" or something equally stereotypical (and downright stupid). Leave that for the fine journalists over at the NYTimes who just can't stop no matter how they try.

  • farleft

    How about one story where Gothamist commenters stop telling Gothamist staff what post, how to spell, and how they should do their jobs? That would be much better than your pleas for semitic leniency.

  • Eric

    Oh man I am so in the mood for Russ and Daughters right now.

  • Pålægpåtoppenafsmørrebrød

    I want some Absolute Bagels, maybe get some bagels by the dozen and figure out how to cure salmon without smelling like brine.

  • JenChungsBaby

    Let them not eat. More for the rest of us.

  • hotstepper

    eating fish for breakfast is icky.

  • CR

    Let me guess - you have a masters degree in something useless.

  • hotstepper

    yes. impregnating your mother.

  • theboneranger



    in the sixth grade someone told me tuna canneries allow up to 100 rat hairs per can.

    i happen to have some smoked salmon in the fridge for lunch - - THANKS guys!



  • Politburo

    One thing you never want to do is lookup all the allowable limits in the FDA regs...

  • BDS=(Boycott.Divest.Sanction)

    its 2010 can we please start acting like adults and stop pretending religion is no different that superstition.



  • CR

    Got a better way to form a community?

  • BDS=(Boycott.Divest.Sanction)

    you can't think of any other way to make a community?

    thats the best you can come up with?

    out of date dietary codes and an imaginary diety?

    Come on. non-existence is hard to accept, but we should face facts and stop propagadting fairy tales.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com