Quantcast

Proposed Ban on Blue Fin Tuna Faces Defiant Japan

102910tuna.jpg
Photo of tuna at Tsukiji Market in Tokyo courtesy Tien Mao.

Atlantic and Mediterranean bluefin have been pushed to the brink of extinction in the past half century, with stocks declining by more than 60 percent in the last decade alone. Today the Times editorial board praised President Obama for endorsing a ban on international bluefin trade, and urged the administration to "use all of its influence to get the European Union and others to follow." Two-thirds of the members must support the ban for it to pass this month, but Japan, where bluefin is "the crown jewel of sushi," is fighting back. Fisheries minister Masahiko Yamada has vowed to "lodge reservations," and many in Japan think say this is just the latest instance of "Japan-bashing."

Takashi Saito, a Japanese bluefin wholesaler, tells the Washington Post, "I feel that what happened with Okinawa and with Toyota is being extended to the tuna issue as well. It is just Japan-bashing. There is no choice for the Japanese government. We Japanese eat tuna." At least until they're extinct! Here in New York, a study last year found that many sushi restaurants are selling bluefin tuna, but calling it something else.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Amanda Harletsch

    western consumerist values is driven in deed by market demands, The problem with this little paradigm is that is not sustainable, or even questions it ethical foundation.

    Of course 95% of humanity would not even understand the concepts I'm talking about, tehrefore humanity will cease to exist thanks to it's own stupidity.

    It is not about tuna, it is about intelligence.

  • Amanda Harletsch

    Have to say, that in a globalized era, this values apply to the rest of the world. Adam Smith def couldn't see into the future to see how his theorems will drive greed to the point of implosion.

  • NannyState

    I hear Charlie the Tuna is prowling the black market for nuclear bomb components.

  • ozik

    The problem won't stop once the bluefin are extinct, it'll just move onto the next big/easy/tasty fish. That Mistubishi is hoarding the fish against future scarcity is a distinct acknowledgement of the problem.

    Eating something to extinction is short sighted and stupid. And if the West stops harvesting the fish, the Japanese will just collect more of it cheaper.

    That's sort of the problem with any sort of conservation nowadays: If I cut my consumption of something it just leaves more of it for assholes.

  • Snoopy

    What is Charlie the tuna's take on this situation?

  • ABSORB

    I'm surprised a company hasn't figured out how to farm raise Bluefin tuna yet given how expensive it is

  • Spirit of 76

    They're impossible to farm because they're fast, far-ranging fish. They get big because they eat a lot of other fish (hence the warnings about mercury content because as predators, they accumulate toxins from their prey) and because they get a lot of exercise swimming in large swaths of ocean chasing down that prey. You'd have a hard time growing enough smaller fish to feed bluefin in captivity, never mind the enormous fish pens you'd have to use to give them enough room to move around in but keep them from escaping.

  • Shinobi Shaw

    They already did that and it was one of the factors for a World War!

    Japan loves fish and their diet mainly consist of Seafood, their economy also depends on this.

  • Spongeworthy

    Go rent "The Cove" and everything will become clear.

  • HypocraticOath

    Didnt they say in The Cove that the organization offered to pay them the same amount they were earning from fishing not to fish- and they declined? What would we say if people began eating lions?

    We are all buying korean products now anyway...

  • Spirit of 76

    No, we're not. We're all buying Chinese products. Korea is so 1990s.

  • Amanda Harletsch

    perhaps too intellectually stimulating for most people.

    BTW: there is more than one documentary that talks about this issue but still obscure for most people.

    There are FREE movies that totally relevant, but they are oh so boring.

    http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x8zljd_the-future-of-food-the-future-of-fo_shortfilms

  • Snoopy

    Do you realize if those nips did this 75 years ago and they all died of starvation there would never have been a Pearl Harbor?

  • Hahah it is funny 'cause it is racist. Good one!

  • LesDiggityDoo

    Japan should just start occupying their neighbors for useful resources and see how that goes...

  • LesDiggityDoo

    along with cannibalization..

  • ANGRYGOD11

    Japan's population is falling. More people die than are born and immigration is not a realistic option. Maybe Japan wants to drag some other species down with them. Or maybe it's just that tasty.

  • Think2wice

    Don't you know that as a divine race they have a divine right to divinely glean the oceans of all edible life.

  • Think2wice

    Amen.

  • schadenfreudian mensch

    Immigration is not a realistic option only because they're too xenophobic.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com