Wow, so many angry people commenting on this web site. Come on, lighten up. It's a cupcake place! And a pretty darn tasty one at that. Go order one or two and you'll be singing a different tune.

Cupcake Cafe infinitely better.

Shouldn't they be across the river, scouting out a sweet spot in Xanadu?

How about getting rid of the West Village one too? On the basis that the lines block the sidewalk and the cupcakes are half the size and twice the price they used to be?

God I hate sidewalk cafes. It's theft of public space, nothing more. Can I build out from my apartment onto the sidewalk, please?

if magnolia goes down, so does the quality of the neighborhood. by a little.

uh, no

i said, "buy a little" damn it!

Shitty, overpriced cupcakes. I liked the Japanese restaurant that used be there.

the size of the Magnolia storefront is bad enough, then you have all the fat tourists standing around like elephants outside the door

People still go to Magnolia?! Their cupcakes blow.