Quantcast

Is the Chatty Cabby Crackdown Going Too Far?

On January 29th, TLC agents began enforcing strict new laws and penalties for cab drivers who use hand held electronic devices and cell phones—even hands-free! Since the crackdown began, the city has ticketed 704 taxi drivers, with the first offense carrying a hefty $200 fine. But has the ticket blitz gone too far?

Cabbie Mohamad Diallo, 36, says his hack brother was ticketed for talking on his phone as he waited in line at a taxi stand. There was no passenger in the cab, and the two men were talking about their brother-in-law's death. Diallo tells the Daily News, "I don't think it's fair. He wasn't even driving." Another veteran driver vows to keep defying the law, but only because he needs to get updates from his wife about their autistic teenage son. "I have to keep talking to my wife," the driver said. "My kid comes first."

The TLC remains committed to the heigtened enforcement because it forces drivers to focus on the road. A second offense triggers a 30-day suspension, and a third violation within 15 months results in the loss of his license. But Bhairavi Desai, executive director of the New York Taxi Workers Alliance, insists cabbies are being unfairly targeted, and cites one study that found cabbies are less crash-prone than other drivers in the city. "They are professional drivers," Desai tells the News. Sure, but does that mean they're impervious to distraction while chatting on the phone?

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • MEDICNYC

    I am waiting for the study that shows an increase or decrease in yellow taxi accidents after this "crackdown" went into effect.

  • brooklynette

    You guys clearly don't remember how bad it was before the invention of cell phones--those cabbies would talk your damn ear off all the way home! Are you married? Have any kids? What do you do for work? I particularly remember one who kept asking me if I were Jewish. And the loud music blasting out of the rear speakers! I say talk to your friends as much as you want, just keep your eyes on the road.

  • justthinkin

    The cell phones are bad enough, but when they pull out the prayer mats, I'm outta there.

  • ianmac47

    Maybe cab drivers will just follow the lead set out by teenage drivers across the country and start text messaging instead of talking on the phone; texting is easier to conceal, even if it is more distracting.

  • Snoopy

    What ever happened to the old time cigar chawing cabbie who would tell you the time he had Marilyn Monroe and John Kennedy in the back seat doing it while they drove through Central Park?

    Ah the good old days.

    On the other hand thank God for cell phones.

  • Stephenson Billings

    Maybe if they spoke in English this wouldn't be so much of a problem.

  • whitecastlerock

    Focus on the road, bathe more than once a month, and deal with the rules associated with your job. If you need to focus on your autistic child, then don't drive a cab...

  • trady

    Exactly! I can't imagine what type of all-day updates this man's wife is giving him about their child. Ridiculous.

  • Alex

    There shouldn't be a ban at all as long as they're using a hands free device.

  • lucy van pelt

    The hands free device was just so your cabbie could have one hand on the wheel and one hand giving everybody the finger

  • NannyState

    I don't know if I'd want my cabbie to have free hands.

  • trady

    You'd think hands-free would be fine, except it's still not good enough. I've been in cabs where the cabbie was so focused on talking, he missed where I wanted to be dropped off. The problem is they can't do two things at once. A bluetooth keeps your hands on the wheel, sure, but you're still trying to focus on a conversation AND pay attention to the road and the customer.

  • jaycjay

    Every traffic safety study done in the past decade or show disagrees with you.

  • jaycjay

    his hack brother was ticketed for talking on his phone as he waited in line at a taxi stand

    Well, if his brother told a newspaper reporter that the guy was ticketed while he was parked, it must be true. The only place people will lie about traffic violations is traffic court.



    "If they're going to keep on doing this, I have to get another job," one cabbie lamented yesterday.

    Get another job, or maybe... stop talking on the phone while driving.



    "I just got a call and I can't do nothing with it," he said. "I just can't answer. It's terrible."

    Terrible! The worst thing to ever have happened through civilization's history! The humanity!

  • theevilone

    I assume you never take personal calls during your workday?

  • Ishtar

    Some people actually let their phones go to voicemail when they are in the middle of a task at work that requires their attention. You wouldn't stand for a cashier at the grocery store taking a call on her cell in the middle helping you, would you?

  • jaycjay

    Exactly. If I'm doing something at work that requires my attention -- the equivalent of driving, like writing a Gothamist comment for example -- I won't pick up an incoming call. Or I'll do the equivalent of pulling over the curb, and save typing the rest of that comment til the phone call is over.

  • jaycjay

    I do it all the time. It's not against the rules. If it were, I'd be faced with that same choice: get another job, or just stop talking on the cell phone.

  • Ishtar

    Do some cell phones come without voicemail or something?

  • Ishtar

    I'd rather the cabbies talk on their phones than to me.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com