Quantcast

Voting To Become More Like High School Exams

2010_1_standardizedtest.jpg After fifty years of service, the city's lever voting machines will be replaced with "SAT-style ovals," according to the Times. When the Board of Elections chooses the city's new voting machines on Tuesday, and it's likely the group will select Scantron-style fill-in-the-blank test forms, which will be in place for the September primary.

Though they're iconic, the current Shoup 3.2 mechanical voting machines can break down, and there's no paper trail left behind in case they act up. That's why officials are leaning towards a standardized-test-style voting process, which they say won't just provide better record keeping, but will also shorten the occasionally lengthy lines at the polls (so long as the Board of Elections keeps enough sharpened #2 pencils on hand). The new procedure would go something like this: Upon signing in, voters will take their ballots to one of several voting stations, "which are like raised desks, with dividers to offer privacy." After making their choices, voters will go to a touch-screen computer, which will show them how to scan their ballots. After being scanned, the paper ballots will fall into locked boxes beneath the machines where they can be checked against the digital results.

New York City will be one of the last municipalities in the country to update its voting protocol — perhaps because some voters are so attached to the old machines. "Most New Yorkers are nostalgic about lever machines. I know I am," said Lawrence D. Norden, director of the Voter Technology Assessment Project at the Brennan Center for Justice at the NYU School of Law. "Ask a New Yorker about those machines and they will tell you that there is something reassuring about pulling the lever and hearing the choices register on the machine."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Amanda

    Meh, I thought that I was done with Scantrons when I finished school. I guess I was wrong :\

  • jimmycracks

    it should be like a witness lineup:

    candidates in a room facing a one way mirror and the voter pointing to the guy they will vote for

    :3

  • NannyState

    And publicly hang the losers as H.L. Mencken suggested.

  • Snoopy

    They should do that in pro sports. Everyone on the team that comes in last will be eliminated permanently. It will add to a better gene pool in sports.

  • angry_pickle

    Democracies are not suitable for the uneducated. Look at Africa.

  • longacre

    Or Florida.

  • Snoopy

    Will they be offering a Quick Pick option?

  • hotstepper

    super duper. can we have our voter-approved mayoral term limits back now?

  • nicemarmot

    Why don't they just use a touchscreen that prints a voting receipt? If the votes turn out right, then you stick that receipt in the machine for the final stage of registering your vote.

  • JacqueMehoff

    agreed, ATM style.

    this sounds terrible.

  • whitecastlerock

    fill in the sheet then scan the paper? that won't cause too much confusion

  • grizzzly

    It'd be nice if the scanning machine gave the voter a chance to review their selections as interpreted by the machine to ensure accuracy.

  • Malcolm Tucker

    Given the average voter in this city probably didn't even graduate high school, this is a brilliant idea.

  • imadick

    you're better than everyone else too? great! welcome to the club!

  • farleft

    I'm buying stock in #2 pencils.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com