Quantcast

New Study Says New Yorkers Are Miserable!

The Center for Disease Control, of all people, says that New Yorkers are the unhappiest people in the entire country... with New Jersey, Connecticut, Michigan and Indiana rounding out the Top 5. On the other side of the spectrum, Hawaii, Louisiana, Colorado, Florida and Tennessee are filled with the happiest folks. All in all 1.3 million people were surveyed over the course of four years, and the least miserable were those residing in states that do well in quality-of-life studies.

The survey focused on the question, "How satisfied are you with your life?" However, one psychologist opined, "How do you measure happiness? It might be the things they're looking at are not the things that make New Yorkers happy."

Another expert suggested that long commutes, congestion and high prices are making us sad. To prove them wrong, 1010Wins did their own street survey and found plenty of smiling people! Except one sad sack who blamed being a Mets fan for part of his woes.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • 240Bravo

    New Yorkers are like Marines, they aint happy unless they are complaining.

  • asg749d

    ...You don't need a study to realize the New Yorkers are in fact miserable...just ride a subway car, or a bus, or go into a bank and wait in line for more than 30seconds...

  • NannyState

    ...or read this blog :)

  • gawkthis

    "1010Wins did their own street survey and found plenty of smiling people!"



    1010 should have interviewed Mr Clyde Bruckman; when asked about this survey he replied,



    "I'm not smiling. I'm wincing."



    (Mr Bruckman's outlook has probably improved since dying)



    "This X-Files moment has been brought to you by 1010WINS..."

  • Think2wice

    God that was a great episode with Peter Boyle.

  • Guest

    wait, wait, wait. being a baseball team fan has anything to do with happiness? gratification, maybe, but happiness i don't know.



    ... i mean, it's really sad.

  • sowhtifithppnsitwll

    Hawaii.. Don Ho,hula girls and beautiful beaches.

    Louisiana.. Great hospitality and food.

    Colorodo.. Sun sets colors open space and clean air.

    Florida.. I'm retired. LOL

    Tennessee..Ain't no place where I'd rather be. (does it for me)



    NEW YORK...It starts with quality of life. I walk out my door in Sheepshead Bay Brooklyn and I have to avoid a dozen plastic bags of dog poop on my way to the subway.There is graffiti all over buildings.The subway station is being renovated, the trains are filthy and I paid too much fare.



    It makes it a lot easier to focus on the negative from that point on.

  • NannyState

    Not only that but let's face it, you look like shit too.

  • sowhtifithppnsitwll

    I never had anything against you before. But you just must be a piece of work with a mouth the way you spew shit.

    If you wonder where your run of bad luck comes from, it came from me.

  • NannyState

    Yeesh, wotta grouch! I was just being nice.

  • sowhtifithppnsitwll

    If that's the best you can do. OK. LOL

  • NannyState

    God, if I was happy, I'd have to throw myself off a building.

  • ennuipoet

    Being born in Tennessee I feel qualified to state: I'm quite sure that being miserable in NYC is still infinitely better than being happy in Tennessee.

  • waysideflower

    I completely agree. I grew up in Nashville, but I've been living here for about four years now. I can't think of anything that would make me want to go back to Tennessee. Even a visit to my family for less than a week is almost more than I can stand.

  • Bike Rider

    maybe people in those hicklands are happier because we're busy working our asses off to subsidize their states while they smoke meth and fuck without contraception.



    google red state socialism.. ugh

  • zodak

    i'm happy being miserable.

  • Tommy

    It's New York State, not New York City, so putting "New Yorkers" in the headline is disingenuous. There are lots of places outside of NYC in NY State that would make me miserable too.



    In terms of New Yorkers, we may be miserable, but we would be more miserable somewhere else. Can you imagine having to live in Hoboken or on Long Island? Faced with those options, I'm sure most New Yorkers perk up.

  • nynew

    my husband and I have this discussion every time we discuss housing. Friends from "back home" buy large homes for what a studio or 1br apt would cost on Staten Island. my husband's response is, "that's because no one wants to live there." It's not so much about IQ. It's education. People there (MS, specifically) are more concerned with comfort, slow life, enjoying family, low career aspirations (not that they don't have any, it's just different than in other areas we've live in). Sure you have some MDs and lawyers... but we're talking industry. biotech, computers... unless it's military related, it's not there and industry doesn't want to move there b/c for the most part, the people educated for those careers would rather live in CA and the NE. Ignorance is bliss... sure... friends who have visited me here and in Chicagoland area were amazed at the parks and all that the cities have to offer. (trust me, the parks here are incredible compared to the towns my hubby and I grew up in, the schools here are SO far ahead... so for better educated society, I don't mind paying the higher taxes) Do you get that in New Orleans? Hell no. I don't consider Bourbon St and the Quarter to equal in comparison to the cultural diversity you'll find in NYC.

    So are people happy there? yeah. My parents were happy with next to nothin' and not traveling. Are people happy here? I think the majority of people I've met here are happy... have they met their goals in life by age 35? most no... but I think that's a driving force to keep a city going in the right direction. Striving for more (and I'm not talking iPhones, not objects... acheivements).

  • handsomedevil

    I admit it. I'm fucking miserable. HELP ME FOR CHRISSAKE I CAN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE! HEEEEEELP!

  • Duffy

    It's interesting that the ranking of happiness by state is inversely proportional to the IQ averages by state.



    Ignorance is bliss.

  • schizofriendly

    Thinking too much makes you blue. We think too much here.

  • Think2wice

    So, these are the results of quantifying gross domestic happiness during a recession? Seriously, happiness in a recession!?

  • Billiamsburg

    people from those hick states just say they're happy cuz being sad if fer homos.

  • Trilby16

    It's not that NYers are actually miserable. We're not. We just love to complain! It's our birthright!

  • bittycakes

    Agreed. I *love* to complain!!!!! (also I do believe happiness comes from within)

  • bittycakes

    Oh, and that being said, I'm super happy!

  • hotstepper

    i've always thought that alienation from nature is a big problem here. it drives people to materialism and conspicuous consumption which provides a false sense of happiness.

  • JenChungsBaby

    I agree. Another reason is the stratification of rich and poor. Studies have shown that the happiest workplaces are those where everyone makes the same pay, even if it's not a lot. And workers are less happy when they know that they're getting paid less than the person in the next office, even if they're getting paid a lot overall. Same thing here in NY.

  • NannyState

    Fucking Claude Levi-Strauss over here...

  • Shinobi Shaw

    Good point! The more man is away from nature the more innately miserable he will feel.

  • felixthecat2

    Dexter Season 4 Finale made me sad.

  • owlbethere

    Dexter lost control.

  • seven

    How can you be happy if you wake up every morning having to face the grim realization that you live in fucking Tennessee?

  • hunter.blatherer

    Because you just know the Rapture is always moments away, and zombie Jesus is gonna come swoop you away. This pick-up will be unmanned!! (but it will still have its Truck Nutz)

  • TNcountryboy

    I dunno... guess I'm just so tickled 'cause I wake up knowin' that mis'rable yankee assholes like you aint livin' round here. yeeehaaaw!

  • hotstepper

    memphis is pretty cool, though i don't know if i could live there.

  • valeriob

    All they need is a jug for drinkin' and a jug for blowin'.

    HOOT, hoot, HOOT, hoot...

  • TNcountryboy

    Hey val, I jus finished my jug 'a shine n I'd like ta hoot-hoot cha a luv tune. Thang is I'ma needin som'er ta put tis cork. Won'cha bend over n I'll see if I can't finda good spot fer it.

  • hunter.blatherer

    You'll be even happier when you find out "val" is male. Just remember to keep it a secret.

  • Gwinny

    hilarious!

  • Amanda Harletsch

    what a surprise, I would never think that when riding the subway (specially in winter), walking on the street...

    Next study should be about hygiene compared to other cities.

    I just love spiting men!

  • Boogie Down

    Could be worse. I saw a guy pissing on a platform around dinnertime last month. So classy.

  • hunter.blatherer

    Spitting and pissing in public is a birthright of all male New Yorkers. Are you trying to make us miserable?

  • Amanda Harletsch

    trying to make spiters miserable? I bet they are already in very reputable relationships! what descent woman would be like to hang out with a spiter?!

  • hunter.blatherer

    "Reputable relationships"? Since when was anyone happy in one of those?

  • Amanda Harletsch

    says Tiger!

  • Shinobi Shaw

    Let me be honest here, I am pretty happy with Career (although with the economy these days this may not last that long either....).



    Spiritualy? Fantastic.



    But this City can get pretty lonely at times, people just don't communicate as much.



    One of the most densely populated cities in the world and yet you can still feel lonely.



    BTW it's not lonely in the matter of actual people, but I mean in terms of connecting.

  • felixthecat2

    I'm still sad about Quinn and Bloomberg' reelection. Also about the poor carriage horses. However, I have family and girlfriend who make me feel better.

  • thefacts

    Unfortunately, family and girlfriend belong to the human species, which you repeatedly state is miserable.



    My condolences for having a miserable family and girlfriend.

  • valeriob

    It's like a Tri-State tri-fecta for the most miserable!

  • valeriob
  • ides_of_march

    Watching a big chunk of your paycheck get eaten up in taxes for politicians to flush down the toilet will do that to people.

  • Dead Himmler

    Money does not equal happiness. It comes from the inside and has nothing to do with external factors.

  • FrankMartin

    Tax dollars being wasted isn't just about money. It's about seeing politicians not respect your effort and time and the resulting income. Poor leadership is certainly depressing.



    As for your cliché, money doesn't buy happiness, but it's the down payment.

  • TrippinJoJo

    "money doesn't buy happiness, but it's the down payment."



    Well said

  • Robert

    While your statement is true having money makes a big change in your attitude in life. Knowing that you have enough money to cover your bills and keep your loved ones comfortable will have a huge impact in your outlook in life.



    Having money lets you focus on the better things in life without having to worry about the next phone bill or credit card bill.



    This of course applies to the average person and not the white collar folks whose problems arise from having too much money :)



    Just my 2 cents. Merry Christmas everyone!!

  • nycviabos

    They're not happy, they just don't know any better.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com