Porn Star and Stripper Fight Prostitution Charges

112209moore.jpg
Alexia Moore
In July 2008, the Vice Enforcement Squad raided Big Daddy Lou's Hot Lap Dance Club on West 38th Street, which was ranked as the best of all strip clubs in the world by AskMen.com. Prosecutors say it was so beloved because the club offered much more than erotic dancing to its upscale clientele, including on-site cocaine sales, and private rooms with beds for $250 an hour (plus whatever customers gave "dancers" behind closed doors). During the raid, police arrested some dancers, including porn star Alexia Moore, on alleged prostitution charges, as well as staff members and club owner Louis Posner, a lawyer who started a voter reform advocacy group after the 2000 election.

Moore, whose real name is Cassandra Malandri, and topless dancer Falynn Rodriguez, rejected a plea deal that would result in no jail, no probation, no community service, and no criminal record—provided they admitted to prostitution. It's uncommon for a prostitution charge to go to trial; the women insist they aren't prostitutes, and say prosecutors are aggressively pursuing them so they can convict Posner and his wife of running a brothel. (Before being shut down, the club was also sued by an investment broker who was injured during a lapdance when a stripper hit him in the eye with the heel of her shoe.)

An undercover officer says the two women agreed to have a threesome with him for $5,000, off-site and at a later date. The strippers say they played along with the proposal but never took it seriously, and when they were arrested a month later, the ménage à trois hadn't happened. Rodriguez's lawyer tells the Post, "They thought it was a joke! I mean, $5,000." Judging by their photo in today's Post, 5K does seem sort of laughable.

Email This Entry


Comments (22) [rss]

800 flowers tops. And no im kidding so dont track my IP.

goddamn puritans. vice is nice.

In porn, everyone's a "star."

judging by their photo in today's Post, 5K does seem sort of laughable.. Perhaps the cop looked worse.

Victimless crime. Glad Bloomberg's police force is carrying on the tradition set by his predecessor's to showboat and waste taxpayer dollars chasing non-criminals.

The only response a judge should have to a case like this is to roll his eyes and tell the cops and prosecutors to "get a life".

if they filmed it, it wasn't prostitution, just an amateur porn film & that's legal!

Exactly! Moral of this story: Bring a video camera if you're going to hire a prostitute.

Yawn. If you want to deal with prostitution, arrest johns & pimps. & then help the prostitutes into other avenues of employment. Duh.

You mean employment that's as lucrative? Good luck.

Undercover cops go to strip joins. Taxpayers money well spent.

A bunch of cops step into a strip club. No one thought that this might just be the next round of entertainment for the bachelor party at table 10?

The IRS should get involved for tax fraud and evasion immediately. Put them behind bars. No wonder the Country is in trouble when people like this can make tremendous income and not pay any taxes on their prostitution!

The NYPD Vice Enforcement Unit has falsely arrested over 40 gay men in adult book stores on trumped up prostitution charges. See Campaign to Stop the False Arrests. We can now add topless dancers to the list of innocent victims of NYC law enforcement's moral crusade against adult entertainment. Despite the allegations of "on site cocaine sales," Court records reveal that there is not a single drug related charge charge against any of the individuals arrested at the club. We should give credit to Alexia Moore and Falynn Rodriguez for their courage in standing up and defending themselves!

No one at the Hot Lap Dance Club ever called Lou the name "Big Daddy Lou", "Big Lou" or "Daddy." He was simply "Lou." No one ever called the club "Big Daddy Lou's Hot Lap Dance Club." It was simply referred to as the "Hot Lap Dance Club," "Hot Lap Dance" or "HLD."

There were never any "on-site sales of cocaine" at HLD. The club had a strict "no tolerance" policy towards drugs. There was not a single charge for narcotics or drugs in any of the criminal complaints filed against any of the owners, staff or dancers who worked at HLD.

The statement that prosecutors are seeking to "convict Posner and his wife of running a brothel" is inaccurate. Posner's wife never worked at HLD. Vice police falsely arrested her late at night at her home in her pajamas on "promoting prostitution" charges. Bail was set at $150,000 and she spent 6 days in jail at Reikers. The grand jury failed to indict her on the promoting prostitution charges and the charges had to be dropped. HLD was a gentlemen's club, not a brothel. Louis Posner pleaded "not guilty" to the promoting prostitution charges.

The comment "plus whatever customers gave "dancers" behind closed doors" is inaccurate and misleading. Many of the dancers who worked at HLD, including Cassandra Malandri and Falynn Rodriguez, had worked at the top gentlemen's clubs in Manhattan and throughout the United States. None of the HLD dancers worked as prostitutes or escorts. Like any other gentlemen's club, dancers received a set amount of money for their time in a private room. Tips to the dancers were not expected or required. There were frequent emails and staff meetings prohibiting and warning dancers at HLD against prostitution.

The statement that HLD "ranked as the best of all strip clubs in the world by AskMen.com" is correct. HLD ranked as the number one gentlemen's club in the world in the askmen.com article "Top Ten Gentlemen's Club." Larry Flint's Hustler Club in New York ranked No. 3 and Spearmint Rhino in Las Vegas ranked no. 5. The statement that HLD (or any of the other top rated clubs) was "so beloved because the club offered much more than erotic dancing" is false. HLD was popular because it had beautiful dancers, a comfortable ambience, an "upscale clientele", well orchestrated live erotic performances, and a gourmet catered buffet.

The statement that HLD had "private rooms with beds" is misleading. All of the rooms at HLD, including any private rooms, had chairs and sofas for lap dancing. Lounge beds at HLD were part of the ultra-hip ambience, similar to top clubs like B.E.D. in South Beach, Miami. The overwhelming majority of customers paid $20 for a lap dance in the open lap dance rooms at HLD.

This is a case of "selective prosecution" as law enforcement went after Louis Posner and his wife because Posner was a "lawyer who started a voter reform advocacy group after the 2000 election." The police raid in July 2008 was just before the campaign for the Presidential election and conservative Republican pundits mocked Posner, a liberal activist attorney. Prosecutors went after Cassandra Malandri, and her partner Falynn Rodriguez because Alexia Moore is a "porn star." Alexia Moore only does lesbian porn and her performances as an adult actor are constitutionally protected free expression.

Prosecutors are not just seeking to "convict Posner and his wife." Prosecutors want to forfeit over $550,000 seized from the Posners and HLD. Since there are no victims of this alleged crime, there would be no restitution payments. Any money forfeited would go to New York City, and most of it to the NYC police department. The unfair seizure and forfeiture laws provide law enforcement with a perverse financial incentive to go after entrepreneurial businessmen, rather than real criminals. See Forfeiture Endangers American Rights (FEAR).

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

I agree. Jake is making the Extra Extras more thick than say 3-4 bold ones.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us