Quantcast

Making The Call: A "Real Yankee"?

2009_10_arodpo.jpg
Photograph of Alex Rodriguez after his game-tying 9th inning two-run home run by Julie Jacobson
Our long nightmare is over, thanks to his dramatic two-run home run in the ninth on Friday, we can finally say that A-Rod is a “real Yankee”. And kudos to Mark Teixeira, who won the game with a home run and therefore is immediately promoted to “real Yankee” in his first Yankee postseason.

A-Rod’s success is reminiscent of Yogi Berra’s 1953 World Series performance. Berra entered that contest hitting .188 in over 100 World Series plate appearances, hardly the stuff of a “real Yankee”. Luckily, he started hitting in that postseason otherwise he never would have been called a “real Yankee”.

Tino Martinez is clearly a “real Yankee”, but he only hit .247 in the postseason, how did he qualify? Winning those four World Series titles of course. But wait, then how come Don Mattingly is a “real Yankee”? Mattingly didn’t even win a division title when he played for the team. Well Mattingly obviously makes it because of the way he played the game.

It’s too bad more of these guys can’t just be like “real Yankee” Derek Jeter who always turns it up in the postseason. Jeter a career .317/.388/.459 hitter elevates his numbers all the way up to .311/.381/.477 in the playoffs.

Hmmm…come to think of it maybe this “real Yankee” stuff is a load of crap and maybe we should just root for the players and not worry about trying to define them. Nah, where’s the fun in that?

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Toby von Meistersinger

    There haven't been real Yankees since baseball players all became mercenaries back in the 1970s. There will be no more Yogi Berras or Mickey Mantles anymore.

  • Steven

    Yep, those players actually *gasp* had another job for the off-season!!!!!!

  • faze

    False premise. You're arguing with morons.

  • Snoopy

    Did I see Reggie Jackson toss out the first ball the other night and it took a bounce to get over home plate?

    Talk about "Mr. October."

  • longacre

    What if he goes 0-for-4 a couple of times or strikes out looking in a key situation in the next round? Will he still be a "real Yankee?"

  • Dead Himmler

    It really comes down to if the Yankees win. If they do nobody will care about going 0 for 4.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com