Quantcast

State Senators Vs. Bloomberg Spat Hits Godwin's Law

2009_07_stateblo.jpg Mayor Bloomberg has been complaining about the State Senate's refusal to vote on the issue of mayoral control of the public school system—and the State Senate Democrats have been complaining about Bloomberg right back. And while the debate is not an Internet forum, we're going to say their dispute has officially hit Godwin's Law.

On his Friday radio show, Bloomberg brought up Neville Chamberlain and appeasement negotiations while discussing mayoral control of schools—prompting Senator Carl Kruger (D-Brooklyn) to say, "It's a sad comment. It's a comment that says to people like myself and to so many hundreds of thousands of millions of people who lost family in the holocaust. Even to raise the name of Hitler, in and of itself, should have a public rebuke and is worthy of apology. We're not Hitler. We're legislators."

Yesterday, Bloomberg was asked about the comments. According to PolitickerNY, NY1's Rita Nissan asked, "Your comments about Chamberlain on Friday--they’re upset by that and they feel they are owed an apology. They feel that you compared them to Nazis." (Keep in mind, the Senators called Bloomberg a dictator, a yenta and a plantation owner on Sunday.) Bloomberg responded, "I certainly did. What part of that did they not understand? This is ridiculous." Bloomberg's spokesman later said, "The Mayor couldn’t hear Rita’s question clearly, and neither could Andrew Brent, who was standing right by her."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • cxb

    Godwin's law is moronic.



    EX: it says that, if a politician uses most of Hitler's techniques, you cannot compare him to Hitler!



    Yikes!

  • NannyState

    Get your historical analogies straight, guys. The legislators = Weimar Republic, Bloomberg = Mussolini.

  • Spirit of 76

    I don't think so. So far, the subways still don't run on time.

  • NannyState

    Ha!

  • AvenueHebrew

    "We're not Hitler. We're legislators."



    You're not Hitler, but you're not legislators either. That would entail you accomplishing some form of legislation. You're a bunch of lazy cowards who sat around bickering for a full month, without doing a lick of work. If I did that, I'd be fired in a week. But then again, my paycheck doesn't come from taxpayers' money.

  • Kevin Walsh

    "The Mayor couldn’t hear Rita’s question clearly, and neither could Andrew Brent, who was standing right by her."



    That's because he cut off her question once it became apparent what she was asking. Bloomie has a habit of doing that.



    www.forgotten-ny.com

  • MT

    Am I the only one thinking "two men enter, one man leaves?" How about a little Thunderdome action to settle this. I'd bet on Bloomberg.

  • yakatori

    The NY1 reporter was Rita Nissan not Hassan.

  • Thank you. It's really one of those mornings.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com