Quantcast

Gassy Mastiff 1, Soledad O'Brien 0

2009_05_neamas.jpg A Chelsea co-op's attempt to evict a family over its "gassy" Neapolitan Mastiff has been thrown out by a judge. In January, the Post detailed the plight of the Lyons family, who were shunned and hated by their neighbors—including CNN anchor Soledad O'Brien— because their mastiff Ugo is smelly. Though the West 26th building allows pets, the co-op board (with board secretary O'Brien) became fed up and moved to evict the Lyonses, who tried to address the issue by grooming him three times a month and spraying him with deodorizer. Now the Post reveals that Ugo can stay because the Lyonses "were not properly served in the suit." The Lyonses' lawyer said, "The board is trying to evict a family, and it can't even serve the initial papers correctly. Maybe the board should be put on a leash." Since news of Ugo's plight attracted many supporters, O'Brien has suffered a bit of opposition; she resigned from the co-op board in February, explaining, "After discussions with neighbors and others, [my husband] and I have become increasingly concerned about my personal safety." The Post also has a chart comparing O'Brien's and Ugo's characteristics.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • cncrocket

    anyone who chooses to own a dog that big in a city this crowded is an asshole. i dont even want to share the fucking sidewalk with your oozing goddamned monster. that ugly fucker probably smelled like a swamp. fuck all of you large dog owners. you're all presumptuous jerks. i dont think your dog is cute. now get your motherfucking leash out of everyone's way and move to the suburbs.

  • sexisicilian

    Some people should get a life, don't shower for a week & let us see how you smell ...

  • felixthecat2

    Some people should get a heart and stop attacking innocent beings for their smell. I am sure Soledad stinks as bad as her appearance on CNN. Have you been on a crowded train, the BO is horrible, does it mean that we should ban most of the people from the subway system?

  • Global Wombat

    Gas, eh? Sounds like the dog has a poor diet, which can be easily fixed.

  • pissflaps

    gastiff

  • dadoc

    Obviously some genetically purebred monstrosity that gets walked a few times a day by a hired walker and never really gets a chance to enjoy life. Was it a rescue pup? Feel bad for the pup, not his fault. Owners had a choice about putting him in this position. But understand them not wanting to give up their home or their pup. But people count too. If he really is such a stinky mess, the owners need to find a better compromise.

    Maybe inconvenient & expensive for them, but a good vet nutritionist & more personal grooming could make him a good friend to his neighbors, and not just the object of snarking by lawyers & bloggers.

  • felixthecat2

    Soledad appearance on CNN STINKS, can I sue her? Fugly bitch better not appear in front of me ever! What kind of bitch picks on a dog?

  • Tower18

    And here's your proof about why she resigned from the board.

  • felixthecat2

    Perhaps fugly talentless Soledad and michael Vick should both hook up and disappear.

  • felixthecat2

    This is proof? Don't quite your day job because you stink as a prosecutor.

  • Karen

    I meant, fart, not fat. sorry.

  • Karen

    My neighbor's Boston Terrier is the gassiest mammal alive-which is why I don't go to thier home anymore. This dog is so stinky-which they think is hilarious-that he literaly chases people away. Imagine a fat coming out of a dog the size of Ugo. Isn't there a doggy Beano around?

  • angry_pickle

    The fact that O'Brien feared for her own safety shows how fanatical some animal lovers are.

  • jaycjay

    "The fact that O'Brien feared for her own safety shows how fanatical some animal lovers are."



    It certainly does not prove anything like that at all, any more than a fear of werewolves proves that they are an actual threat. Her fear of a a threat does not prove the existence of a threat.

  • angry_pickle

    Werewolves don't exist. Fanatical animal lovers do.

  • Pull My Finger

    Screw that worthless bitch. Ha ha ha ha you lost.

  • Gustastic

    It's not like most apt-buildings are NOT dog-friendly. Quit your effing whining and move the hell out if you don't like living with dogs.



    God, I hate rich people.

  • JacqueMehoff

    what's the proper way to serve the summons?

    would certified mail and regular mail suffice?

    or is that only for poor people like me who can't afford legal representation?

  • NannyState

    They have to physically touch the paperwork, you can't just mail it in. Oftentimes, a process server will just drop the summons and complaint at a person's feet if they act evasively. Also, if someone at the domicile accepts papers for the defendant, they're good to go. Signing a document of acceptance just gets the server paid without the hassle of going through lawyers.



    In any event, Soledad O'Brien is right to fear for her safety. There's a lot of crazed animal lovers out there and they'd love to go after a self-obsessed witchy bitch like her.

  • Kojak

    Going by my vast legal experience from watching Law & Order and the West Wing, I believe a official has to physically give the recipient the summons, after which they must sign a legal document stating that they have indeed received it.

  • Spirit of 76

    I am not a lawyer or a process server, but I don't think they have to sign for it. They can, but it's not mandatory. Otherwise you'd never be able to serve most people because they would just refuse to sign. Process servers have to be licensed, which means they basically have to legally swear that they delivered the summons to somebody resembling the description and answering to the name. That is enough for the law. If a process server lies and didn't deliver to the person he's supposed to, then he loses his license and/or gets sued. I'm guessing the board opted for "nail and mail," just attaching the papers to the door of the apartment. That's not acceptable unless the party to be served can't be found or is avoiding being served. It may be a short-lived victory for the dog owner. If the board wants, they can always start over. There's no double jeopardy in civil matters.

  • Kojak

    How come most co-op boards are so petty & batshit crazy? They seem to have issues with even the most slightest of nuisances.



    I'm glad the Mastiff one. Continue to fart at will.

  • TKaisen

    Because nobodies let any little bit of power go directly to their brains.



    Co-op boards are just the city's version of homeowner's associations.

  • ANGRYGOD11

    Only the richest co-ops act like this. Other boards don't have the resources to waste on petty battles.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com