Quantcast

Hiram's Abuse Tape Too Graphic to Have Potential Jurors See

2009_01_hiramm.jpg A judge has refused to release the video that allegedly shows State Senator Hiram Monserrate yanking girlfriend Karla Giraldo "viciously and violently" around his Queens home. Monserrate will stand trial for assaulting Giraldo with a broken glass, an incident that required her to get twenty stitches on her face. His lawyer said of the video, "We won't even get a chance. It's adding fuel to the fire. It's totally inflammatory." The request to release the video was made by the Daily News, but the judge thinks that the powerful images would taint potential jurors. He said, "The defendant will not get a fair trial. It has the great potential for prejudice. A picture is indeed worth a thousand words...it causes the blood to boil." He also told Moserrate's lawyer, "You and your client have to make your peace with this exhibit. You'll have to cope with it...It's inevitable that it's going to come out."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • pao pao

    The video came from the survillance camera inside the buildings hallway. I have seen it. It didnt show what happened inside the apartment of course.

  • pete

    Where did the video come from? he planed to wack her then wack off to the video?

  • Mr Mel

    Macho Jerk.

  • BigRed

    I can't believe this piece of crap is still representing the state in the state senate.

  • schadenfreudian mensch

    Like the entire bunch now in office are any better. They're all cut from the same cloth. Scum among scum.

  • nicemarmot

    Hahaha, I didn't realize there was a video! However will he be acquitted of the crime he committed if his lawyer can't suppress the evidence?!

  • SP

    Uh. Isn't that the whole point of that stuff called "evidence?"

  • jaycjay

    Right... but this decision is that it won't be released to the press before the trial. It can still be introduced as evidence during the trial.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com