Con Ed Criticized For Gas Leak That Caused Fatal Explosion

2009_04_qnsgaslk.jpg The family of the woman who was killed when their house in Floral Park Queens exploded, apparently from a gas leak, visited the site of their leveled house. Dindial Boodram, whose wife Ghanwatti died, told the Daily News, "I want answers, I need answers" about how Con Ed handled reports for a leak—utility workers had been on the scene for 90 minutes and never evacuated residents in spite of high gas levels from a street manhole.

Con Ed spokesman Michael Clendenin explained to the NY Post that the gas levels were not dangerous at the home of the people who called about the smell of gas, "There was no protocol...Which house would you evacuate first?" The News says that an indoor reading of 10% triggers a house evacuation; the reading under a nearby manhole was 80% (it should be zero in normal situations).

The Post reports, "The worker called in an emergency at 4:15 p.m. and continued to take readings, but no one was evacuated. Additional crews pulled up 35 minutes later, just as Boodram's house burst into flames." City Councilman Eric Gioia, a frequent critic of Con Ed, said, "Of course, you should evacuate this street. It's common sense. They have to understand that they're rolling the dice with people's lives." Back in 2007, a Queens grandmother died from her burns in a gas leak; both Con Ed and the FDNY could not find the cause of the gas smell in the neighborhood.

According to the NY Times, Con Ed "found a small hole in a two-inch gas main in front the house that appeared to have been the source of a leak" as well as a "damaged electrical cable near that hole." However, Con Ed is "still investigating what had caused the hole and what had touched off the explosion." And one of Boodram's young sons, 10-year-old Ryan, said to the Times, "Before she died, she had once left me a letter so she said I could always remember her, but it was in the house when it exploded."

Email This Entry


Comments (4) [rss]

user-pic

My condolences to the family.

"the reading under a nearby manhole was 80%"?
I bet Con Ed will evacuate next time.

The street was still cordoned off yesterday with Police and Fire trucks going back and forth most of the day.

Keyspan recently replaced my old gas meter with a remote reading model. Two workers showed up, and one of them was clearly in training. After they replaced the meter, the smell of gas was still pretty strong, and they suggested I open a window. Two hours later, it was still fairly strong, and I called Keyspan to have someone recheck the previous employees' work.

When the next guy arrived, he was clearly freaking out; upon inspection, he discovered they hadn't connected the new meter properly. I described their appearance, and he rolled his eyes as if he had had problems with these two before, which scared the shit out of me. He repaired the leak, and everything was fine.

I do wonder if the outcome would have been different if I had decided to leave my place or take a nap immediately after the appointment (or maybe just an elderly person who might not know something was wrong). Ugh.

That quote from her son breaks my heart.

"There was no protocol...Which house would you evacuate first?"
How many people have to die before they come up with a freaking protocol? Clearly Con Ed workers have no authority to order an evacuation and are not trained in emergency protocols -- this seems to be the domain of FDNY. So how about Con Ed sits down with the FDNY to educate Con Ed workers about calling 911 in case of a gas leak? Really, does it take a genius to figure this out?? I guess something has to happen in Manhattan before someone takes action.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Christmas tree locations addition one on corner of lewis and macon in 11233. Also, i bought mine on
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us