Ch-ch-ch-changes: New York in 1961 and 2009

Not too long ago we took a look at one Harlem storefront as it changed throughout the decades, starting out a cocktail lounge and currently vacant after a brief stint as a Sleepy's. Now Paul Sahner over at NYC Grid has a new photo project up where he compares New York spots in 1961 to their 2009 counterparts. He tells us, "I recently came across a handful of photos my grandfather shots while in NY in 1961. I decided to go out and attempt to re-shot his original photos in 2009."

Email This Entry


Comments (20) [rss]

If only there was a technology that allowed you to switch photos without reloading the page.....

user-pic

I see whities that need to be skinned of their fur.

I love projects like this.

Q

user-pic

Here's one I did of the now condemned Windermere apartment building on the corner of 9th Avenue at 57th Street: http://www.flickr.com/photos/edstern/49477881

Men wore hats and ladies wore gloves. Why?...♪Traditioooon, tradition♪

Ha ha ha! People used to wear clothing!

user-pic

No doubt about it. The 60's were a lot more photogenic.

Pic #7 is the saddest of them all. No more "bishop's crook" lampost, no pre-war building on the corner, and no more 71st Regiment Armory.

The funny thing is: In my nondescript section of Brooklyn they're replacing some of the "War of The Worlds" lampposts with "bishop's crook"s. (It also got carpet-bombed with bike racks, but that's another story.)

Considering 1961 was the Space Age, I feel like the fur-clad people back then would be completely disappointed with how similar everything looks almost half a century later.

Obviously there have significant technological and social changes since then, but based on photos alone it looks like the only differences are fewer hats and different garbage cans.

First they'll desperately fumble for a Camel cigarette when they hear we have a Negro president. Then when they've chillaxed they'll be disappointed at the lack of flying cars and Moon bases.

Hark back to the sidewalks of a different New York; a New York where middle-aged people outnumbered people in their 20's...

yeah that's what is most noticeable to me

its been a change for the worse imo

People in their 20s used to look middle-aged.

And people back then did not hold objects up to their faces while smiling in blissful vapidity and ignoring their surroundings. Weird!

Yeah they did. They were called cigarettes.

i was just at 5th Avenue and 50th Street today and i think those construction barricades are still there.

ba-dump, bump.

Biggest difference I noticed, aside from styles, is that the streets in 1961 look less cluttered. Fewer traffic signs, advertisements, kiosks, etc. Plus, the streets generally don't seem to have bright lane markers, and the traffic lights are not hanging over the intersections, so they blend in more.

I have no opinion as to which way is better or worse, I just think it's worth noting.

I am amazed at how filthy the facades of Rockefeller Center were in 1961.

Paul Sahner has way too much time on his hands.
Anyway, thanks.
BTW, there is a cell phone in that '61 photo on Fifth Ave.
Very creepy.

user-pic

Traffic is going both ways on 5th in the first pic. What's a "public shelter"? Fallout shelter?

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

nice inflammatory way to lead into the bike story.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us