Quantcast

Can Local Teams Survive the Sports Illustrated Jinx?

2009_04_sicover.jpg Given the bad luck of the Mets' past two September collapses, Amazin' fans may have preferred to slide under the radar with all the new season's attention focused on the Shack Burgers arriving at Citi Field. But then Sports Illustrated has to show up and blow up their spot by making the team their preseason pick to win this year's Wold Series.

The problem with that of course is many people's belief in the "Sports Illustrated jinx" that accompanies many of the magazine's high praises for players and teams getting ready for a season. Mets GM Omar Minaya said he was caught off-guard by the pick, but doesn't believe in the "cover business." The team's manager Jerry Manuel laughed it off saying, "My kids and dogs and all the other folks, they picked me, too."

The magazine is putting a lot of stock in the off-season acquisitions of stoppers Francisco Rodriguez and JJ Putz. SI says, "Here's all you need to know about how the East was decided last year: The Mets lost seven times after taking a lead into the ninth, the first-place Phillies not once."

The weekly sports mag didn't predict another Subway Series, but did pick the Yankees to come up with the most wins in the American League this season. They think that the big guns brought in this off-season have put the Bombers at "their most October-ready roster since 2003."

The Daily News says that since SI has new Yankee ace CC Sabathia on the cover, "Perhaps it's not a full-scale jinx" for the Mets. The Post gets a laugh out of highlighting the year SI picked the Indians and the team ended the season with a 61-101 record. And jinx or not, the high bar set by SI is more than the News sees for the local ballclubs. In their extensive preview today, head baseball scribe Bill Madden predicted third place finishes in each of their respective divisions, which would make for another quiet October in town.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • whitecastlerock

    Who reads Sports Illustrated?

  • Dead Himmler

    This might be BS but the Madden curse is 100% real.

  • Kevin Walsh

    SI picked the Red Sox in 2001 or 2002; they won in 2004

    www.forgotten-ny.com

  • jaycjay

    The whole "cover jinx" thing is ridiculous. It's a magazine that's been printed weekly for decades, and a handful of times a person or team that's been featured on the cover has had something negative happen afterward. The thousands who went on as expected or even developed more spectacularly than expected after being on the cover... don't count.

  • FrankMartin



    I agree in general. But the mental games publicity and expectation create is real pressure that can crush. So no voodoo jinx, but high hopes from millions can make for stress, stress saps performance. I know they are big time and should be able to deal, but throwing a ball well on the field is one stress, the NY media or national media is a totally, dare I say it, different game.

  • longacre

    I don't expect the Mets or Yanks to win anyway, so I won't blame SI when they do.

  • Wza

    dammit..

  • fakenewyorker

    putz is a very inauspicious name for a mets relief pitcher

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com