Midweek Special: NYC Restaurant Review Roundup

031109tendowning2.jpg
10 Downing (Ryan Charles)
This week Frank Bruni at the Times bestows two precious stars on Greenwich Village restaurant 10 Downing. It's a big deal for chef Jason Neroni, who, as Bruni observes right at the top, has had his troubles. But that was then, this is now: "I seldom had the sense that Mr. Neroni was showing off, which he’s been known to do. What was strongest about the best dishes wasn’t some fanciful conceit or adornment, but rather the quality and preparation of the centerpiece ingredient." Still, bring your hearing aid, for the "din can be excruciating."

The New Yorker's Mike Peed, however, has a mixed opinion about the food, and finds the atmosphere suitable for Al Qaeda recruitment: "10 Downing has quickly attracted a glossy clientele—nightly throngs of big bags, skinny jeans, and suspicious looks up and down. Whitney Port’s 'The City' has filmed there. It’s reservation hell... So many guests choose to endure 10 Downing’s sizable wait times that the restaurant’s sliver of a bar area often becomes a kind of holding paddock."

Robert Sietsema at the Village Voice keeps it real at Thakali Kitchen in Jackson Heights, which specializes in cuisine from Nepal's northern border: "I paid a visit with the Organ Meat Society in tow. The membership proclaimed bhutuwa ($5.50)—a spice-rubbed appetizer of goat liver, stomach, and intestine—delectable, and also loved pangram fry, a chicken-gizzard sauté. Sadly, the stir-fried lungs, called phokso, were unavailable." His colleague Sarah DiGregorio reviews midtown's La Fonda del Sol (photos) and dissents from the Daily News's assessment that the dining room experience beats the "lively" bar: "The main courses served in the dining room are well-executed, but something about them feels impersonal... The optimal experience at La Fonda del Sol is a tableful of tapas in the bar area. The smaller dishes range from $4 to $12, and many are perfect—playful, but never overly complicated."

Steve Cuozzo at the Post, always a fun read, has a lengthy monograph about the best grilled cheese sandwiches in town, entitled "Cheesy Does It": "In its most insipid form, grilled cheese is essentially baby food made solid... The tension between crisp top and bottom and gooey insides must hark back to a mysterious, post-natal dream memory, if not to the womb. But we can all do with some babying these days. I spent the past two weeks wallowing in a blur of culinary infantilism." Can diapers go on the expense account?

Meanwhile, the Daily News's Danyelle Freeman is white whining about Butcher Bay, the new East Village seafood "shack" in the former Seymour Burton Space: "Now Seymour Burton is Butcher Bay, a wanna-be Pearl Oyster Bar. Adam Cohn, one of the original owners, remains. The burger doesn't. Big mistake. The sign on the front door says, 'Cash Only.' It should also say, 'No Beer on Tap.' Butcher Bay is the kind of place that should have beer on tap. It should also have a full bar. It doesn't. No dessert either." Ugh. And Jay Cheshes at Time Out opines on super-hyped pizza place Co., which is run by Sullivan Street Bakery pro Jim Lahey: "Lahey’s crust is so good, in fact, it needs no toppings."

Email This Entry


Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

It's the same media that NEVER mentioned Muslims' hatred of Israel as a possible motive for 9/11.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us