Quantcast

Midweek Special: NYC Restaurant Review Roundup

021809diningshang.jpg
Shang (Hugh Merwin)
This week the Times's Frank Bruni piles on Shang, a restaurant in the Thompson LES Hotel helmed by the acclaimed, formerly Toronto-based chef Susur Lee, whose first mistake is making Bruni exercise: "The staircase was the first befuddlement and miscalculation I encountered — and a clue that the evening and restaurant might not be all I’d hope for. It’s a long, drab, foreboding rise of steps from the sidewalk to the host station, an entrance less inviting than aerobic. I’ve gone on runs that didn’t leave me as winded." As for the menu, some dishes are "intensely pleasurable," but overall it's "inconsistent and uneventful. The magic that Mr. Lee reputedly made in Toronto hasn’t followed him here."

Robert Sietsema at the Village Voice has a thorough accounting of five El Salvadoran pupusa joints in downtown Jamaica, for the next time you're in that neighborhood. Meanwhile, the New Yorker's Lauren Collins visits Txikito (pronounced "chee-kee-toe"), the small plates Basque restaurant in Chelsea. Collins is pleased, but cautions everyone to order carefully: "At these portions and prices—it’s at least six plates to a full stomach—a lackluster dish feels like a squandered opportunity."

Steve Cuozzo at the Post has a hot tip on a free food deal at Eighty One, the pricey modern-American restaurant in the Excelsior Hotel on West 81st Street. The first 150 diners who e-mail Eighty One this morning will be eligible to try the new two course "eco(nomy)-menu" FOR FREE on Friday night. Cuozzo has all the details on the new value menu, normally priced at $30.81, but you'll want to take advantage of their desperation right now by e-mailing free@81nyc.com.

NY Mag's Adam Platt slams L'Artusi, the newish Italian restaurant (photos) from the owners of insanely popular Dell'anima, awarding just one out of five stars: "Dinner at L’Artusi grinds slowly off a cliff. The hunk of skate I ordered was overwhelmed with fatty chunks of pork, the cold octopus was cut in meager, cat-foodlike shreds, and an inviting-sounding combination of tuna and frizzled artichokes cost $24 and turned out to be yet another indifferent premade crudo, cut in matchbook- size squares." Also, it's "incredibly loud."

And Danyelle Freeman at the Daily News thinks Bar Breton (photos), a cute little brasserie run by Chef Cyril Renaud (the soon-to-close Fleur de Sel), should change its name to Brunch Breton, because "the best dishes on the dinner menu are items you'd order for breakfast... We all love the idea of eating brunch at home. Bar Breton is so homey that the only thing missing is your bedroom right next door."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com