[Our liveblog from City Hall is below, under the poll]
Folks who smelled the sticky sweet smell yesterday, your cries were heard: City officials are holding a press conference at 11 a.m. to discuss the origins of the mysterious maple syrup smell... dunh dunh DUNH.
The smell has confused us as well as captured our imagination. Conspiracy theories multiplied: "It's a factory in NJ," "It's the smell of a de-icer," "Diners are trying to boost business for breakfast items." Past smellings include October 2005, March 2006, November 2006, November 2007, May 2008, January 5, 2009 and last week—not to mention yesterday in the Gramercy/Madison Square Park/ Midtown area. Plus there was a November 2007 cameo on 30 Rock.
We're headed to City Hall now and will file reports. If only we had a groundhog assistant.
At City Hall: Reporters are cracking jokes about this week—given that the Mayor was bitten by a groundhog and all—and how this special press conference was scheduled. Fun fact: City Hall security didn't even know about this last minute press conference!
There is an easel, which means a map or smell-graph (Updatehere's the map). OEM Commissioner Joe Bruno is on the scene.
Preview: It's from NEW JERSEY.
Mayor Bloomberg is here. He's happy about the news that NYC high school students taking AP exams are doing well.
Bloomberg, who has not put on a Sherlock Holmes cap, says that NYC, NY and NJ agencies have been working together to solve the maple syrup smell mystery (he says "maple sugar"). He emphasizes it's not a health hazard.
The Mayor is detailing how the OEM put together the data about the ester (aka the smell reaction from the organic compound) from the past few years. He listed the clues:
1) Most complaints came from UWS and Morningside Heights
2) Winds were moving from West to East
3) Winds at the time were also blowing at a specific speed--fast enough to move smells across the river but not fast enough to disperse the smell.
4) OEM compiled list of smelly factories (okay, odor-producing factories)
The smell was tracked to a NJ company called Frutarom, which processes fenugreek seeds for food additives. It does not appear that the company is violating any rules or laws.
Mayor Bloomberg: "It's just one of the many aromas we're going to have to live with. I can think of a few things worse than maple syrup." He considers the case CLOSED and thinks the hero is 311, due to all the calls to the system querying the smell. On to the map!
Questions: The Mayor isn't sure if Frutarom is the only company producing this smell. He likes maple syrup on his French toast. He says the cost of the investigation is negligible—it's part of what the city does.
When asked how the city knew the smell isn't dangerous, the Mayor pointed out that there were no reports at hospitals. Bloomberg said the city has 60,000 data points daily and a health-issue was noted, the city would have put it together. Another reporter asked if this would further degrade New Jersey's image; Mayor Bloomberg, ever the diplomat, pointed out there are lovely parts of the Garden State, adding that there are parts of Willets Point are really polluted, too (self-slam?).
We just asked the Mayor if there was any thought of a maple syrup smell warning system—alerts when Frutarom processed the fenugreek seeds. He said no, so the next time we smell it we'll have to assume it's either from Frutarom or we're going crazy.
Live Maps image of Frutarom Factory
CityRoom reports there was no answer at Frutarom's offices. The Mayor does not believe he'll think about the smell again, even when he's enjoying French toast or pancakes. Also: Bloomberg has never smelled the mysterious scent.
The mayor is now fielding questions about Wall Street pay, high earners leaving the state, his 2009 campaign spending, capping executive pay, etc.
i'm going to miss the "mystery" behind the syrup smell. it caused quite a stir whenever it came around and i enjoyed the frenzied speculations of where it emanated from. now we'll just get tepid responses of "there goes that factory again" when the aroma returns.
basilhoff
I read today, with great relief and joy, that after many years of searching, the Great Manhattan Mystery Maple Emanation has been solved. I'm glad to see Bloomberg took time from saving the economic melt down of the Big Apple to address this issue personally. I'm sure all NYers are sleeping better this evening knowing the luxurious smell was not the wafting presence of Al Qaeda hosting pancake breakfasts in Jersey City.
Winds are currently from the NNW, which matches what the map above suggests. The origin is therefore probably in NJ -- perhaps Cliffside Park or Palisades Park, by the look of it.
REPLY | JANUARY 5, 2009 11:51 PM [ REPORT THIS ]
snessnyc
Is Frutarom located in Maplewood, NJ?
Outter Burrougher
frutarom is traded on London and Tel Aviv stock exchanges, if anyone is interested
MikeMahogany
I recently figured this out myself as I was watching Six Feet Under again. During one of Nate's death sequences his dad is eating pancakes with syrup. Later, it turns out Lisa is taking fenugreek.
mrguy
my question is this- the maple syrup smell has gotten a lot of press in the 3 years it's been around. how come no fruiterom worker ever came forward and said "hmm, you know, our factory does this process that causes an overpowering maple syrup smell. maybe i should call a newspaper that might be interested in this fact."
Also, did anybody check to see if fuiterom was processing fenugreek seeds this way before the first appearance of the smell in 2005? if they were, how come we never smelled it before then?
rdsizzle
I agree, something is fishy. The "Syrup" story might be a coverup to something much bigger.
valeriob
I can finally sleep at night!!
BongoBoy
So the company is from Israel.
It's a Zionist plot, I tell you! Hamas doesn't like the syrupy smell.
But then again, I have my pancakes with maple syrup and any sorts of products of the cloven hoof variety, washed down with a glass of milk.
tingo
Having grown up in Jersey, I can remember much worse smells than this. In fact, some of those smells crossed the line from smells into toxic burning fumes. The entire state's northeastern corridor should be sued for the chemicals the unfortunate public is exposed to everyday because of corrupt politician's coddling factories.
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.
Want Gothamist's suggestions on what shows to check out, where to eat, what to buy, where to go for a quick trip? We'll be bringing you some exclusive tips and ideas via email every day! And don't worry—you'll still get a list of our top stories.
Sign up for Gothamist Daily, which will deliver useful tips—plus Gothamist's most popular stories—to your inbox at 11 a.m. This way, you'll be able to plan your week or month as well as catch up on Gothamist if you've stepped away.