Quantcast

Midweek Special: NYC Restaurant Review Roundup

012109jd.jpg
The John Dory (Katie Sokoler)
This week in the Village Voice, Robert Sietsema has his turn with The John Dory (photos), the new seafood place from the owners of The Spotted Pig. He concurs that "the menu is sometimes shockingly expensive. On our first visit, a half-dozen oysters set us back $24." But some items are worth it, like the cod milt (fish sperm, $16), "a dish that defines just how far the menu will go to deliver novel seafood sensations. While this may conjure up images of ejaculating fish and hapless under-chefs running after them with paper cups, the semen comes in a sac that fries up like sweetbreads. For aficionados of weird food, it's delicious." And Sarah DiGregorio loves Bushwick's Tortilleria Mexicana Los Hermanos, where "the tortillas are wonderful: thick, slightly chewy, and fragrant."

Frank Bruni revisits Daniel for the Times after its facelift, and lets the restaurant keep its status as one of only five places in town deemed worthy of all four stars by the paper of record: "Daniel...is the most universal member of this exalted clan, to the extent that 'universal' can be applied to any restaurant charging $105 for three courses. That’s a lot of money, and not just in lean times. But you get a lot for it. In fact there are moments during a meal at Daniel when you may well wonder why it isn’t more expensive." (Ah, to have an expense account!) In the Times's $25 and Under column, Dave Cook recommends three good, affordable restaurants influenced by South American cuisine.

Steve Cuozzo at the Post
grabs Jeffrey Chodorow's new "organically obsessed" steakhouse Center Cut (photos) and shakes it like Johnny Fontane: "The house needs Don Corleone to slap it silly and say: 'You can act like a steakhouse.' Center Cut undercuts itself like it's paid by the blooper." But it's not all bad: "On my most recent visit, for the first time, wine by the glass wasn't sour." And Danyelle Freeman at the Daily News loves those $13 cocktails at Macao Trading Co (photos)., the Portuguese/Chinese restaurant in Tribeca from the owners of Employees Only. The food, not so much: "Instead of a fusion of Chinese and Portuguese food, there's an uneasy negotiation between the two cuisines." But the sticky rice is good!

And Kate Julian at The New Yorker has mixed feelings about Dirt Candy, that sleek little vegetarian place on East 9th Street: "Many of [chef Amanda Cohen's] dishes are so earnest in their embrace of a single ingredient that you find yourself stopping to really think about that vegetable, as if for the first time. This is true of the portobello mousse, a dense, comforting cube topped with a pile of grilled mushroom slices. But if the candy-colored carrot risotto reminds you just how sweet and rich carrots can be, it can be exhausting for the same reason."

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • mangusta

    Why would some loser open their mouths on this subject when they clearly have no fucking clue? A simple google search would answer gingi's question, but the sad fucktard felt the urge to pose that question in this section. What a pathetic, impotent attempt at appearing knowledgeable. The fact that Le B was the omitted restaurant speaks volumes.

  • thegingi

    What's the fifth 4-star restaurant? There's Jean-Georges, Masa, Per Se, Daniel, and ____? Am I missing something, or is this a typo?

  • John Del Signore

    Le Bernardin

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com