Quantcast

NY Times Commentary Takes On Cagey Commenters

2009_01_babeland.jpg This weekend a Times reporter gets his hands dirty (but keeps his fingers unsmudged) while diving into the cutthroat world of commenting on New York neighborhood blogs. They discover that the city's "fabled brashness" often leads to "raucous New York-style debate." The writer then falls prey to something that a lot of us have been guilty of on more than one occasion—following insane comment threads. After introducing us to a Brownstoner post where commenters had a familiar battle over parents in Park Slope, the story ends with (Spoiler Alert) a get-together of Brownstoner regulars that was "bearing a notable absence of ill will" where "virtual friends didn’t look like what they had expected." The whole thing leaves you with so much of a virtually warm feeling that you almost begin to imagine a world where a couple who met as fellow Gawker commenters could end up betrothed—oh wait.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Dirk

    Once again, the NY Times is waaaaaayyyy behind when it comes to their lifestyle articles.

    Wow! Comments get out of hand on blogs! Stop the presses!

  • Nyctini11

    I think to outsiders us New Yorkers assertiveness is viewed as abrassive, oh well, if i wanna get walked all over, bite my tongue constantly, etc etc, i'll move. For now, i like it straight up, thanks my fellow NY'ers!

  • dr zippy

    More parochial, dishonest nonsense from the Times. The idea that New Yorkers are more argumentative than any other city is ridiculous. Just look at the other -ist sites to see that the claim is utter nonsense.

  • BongoBoy

    Does the New York Times city section only know one Brooklyn neighborhood?

  • Steven

    Only the rich sections.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com