Residents and business owners who have been complaining about the new Grand Street bike lane now have a video that they say demonstrates the traffic mess caused by the lane, which provides a dedicated space for cyclists separated from traffic by a row of parked cars. Sent to us by the Soho Alliance, the video depicts a truck driver turning from West Broadway onto Grand Street and mistaking the parked cars for idling traffic.
After realizing his mistake, the driver has a dickens of a time backing up, and at the 50 second mark an SUV driver says the hell with it (as only SUV drivers can) and simply drives down the bike lane—which might seem slightly comical until one recalls the death of 22-year-old Eric Ng in 2006. Ng was killed by a driver who mistakenly drove onto the bike path by the West Side Highway. Sean Sweeney, the director of the SoHo Alliance, calls the Grand Street bike lane "an unmitigated disaster" that's increased congestion, noise pollution, and even prevented emergency vehicles from making turns. (In the video, another driver yells, "All that honking for nothing!")
Wiley Norvell at Transportation Alternatives counters that "New York City has 6,000 miles of streets, most of which look the same as they did in 1950. We only have a handful of these newly-designed 'complete streets' installed, which means there’s going to be a learning curve for everybody. But as more and more of the City comes into the 21st Century, the net result will be safer streets for everyone."
In South Williamsburg, residents and business owners have been chafing from the new Kent Street bike Lane. So on Wednesday morning, a group of bike-riding clowns will cycle along Kent to "defend" the controversial lane. According to a press release from Times Up!, the clowns will distribute information in English and Hebrew Yiddish "to educate bike lane opponents that removing bike lanes only encourages more people to drive,which further clogs our city's streets and taxes our country's oil resources." [UPDATE: Times Up! tells us they've changed the hand-outs so that they are now in English and Yiddish.]
Yesterday the Post reported that NYC has more bike lanes than any city in America, and the Bloomerg administration plans to install four times as many to accommodate a surge in cycling, which increased at least 35 percent between 2007 and 2008. Bike traffic on the Manhattan Bridge has risen from 546 to 2,232 riders per day in the past year, and on the Williamsburg Bridge that figure has jumped from 1,117 to 3,001. Norvell would like to see that Williamsburg Bridge number double; his group is pushing for a separated lane on Delancey Street to encourage more cyclists to take the bridge.
Snoopy is also a moron. Cyclists have been saying that they've needed their own lane for a long time, and they're only going to get more like this.
robingee
This just in: Snoopy's a jerk. Oh, we knew that.
Billiamsburg
That poor SUV driver inconvenienced for 48 seconds while a truck navigated a turn! Grr. The nerve of that truck. In the largest city in North America no one has ANY right to inconvenience the SUV driver! The world stops and starts at the SUV drivers fucking convince!
Snoopy
When the cyclists start delivering a load of 100 sheets of 4' x 10' x 5/8" sheet rock curbside in New York, then they can say "I need my own lane."
I DO NOT BRAKE FOR CYCLISTS!
IvoryJive
I could show you video of that exact same thing happening at about 500 other intersections in Manhattan on any given day. Just sayin.
For a long time I lived above Bleecker at West Broadway. Sometime around the early nineties, tour buses headed for Soho started coming down Bleecker Street and making a right turn onto LaGuardia Place. They would get stuck there virtually every light cycle on weekend afternoons. Eventually, the DOT pushed back the stop bar on the northbound lane of LaGuardia place, so cars were waiting further back from the intersection, giving the buses enough room to turn. Problem solved.
I'm not a certified traffic P.E., but it seems pretty obvious to me that this entire situation could be avoided if that one parking space with the red S.U.V was removed. Then the truck could make the turn. No need to remove the entire protected bicycle facility. That's throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
I'm not even going to tackle the idea that maybe we shouldn't be driving giant trucks around small downtown streets. That video still shows 1 huge black pick-up truck, 1 red SUV truck, 1 enormous 50 or 60-foot delivery truck, and the two dark SUV trucks waiting to make the turn. I don't think the rare and meager infrastructure provided for the most efficient and sustainable mode of transportation (cycling) is the problem here.
I am amazed that Sean Sweeney is complaining about traffic noise and congestion, and yet has his sights set on bicycle lanes rather than all these trucks driving through the neighborhood. I mean, really - how much noise does a bicycle make?
bodo
Would it really be that difficult to make that last spot on the block a no parking zone w/ a barrier if necessary?
Looks like even that idiot driving the rental truck could have turned onto the block were it not for that one parking space.
JacqueMehoff
Is grand street a SUV parking Lot,
between this vid and the other picture, you'd think it's exclusively SUV owners who use this road.
jimbobklyn
one issue that is never addressed is the driving test. i don't remember ever seeing a "how to navigate a bike lane" or "how to pass a cyclist"
until it cycling becomes a part of the driving landscape, people will see you as a kid on a bike.
just sayin' change the written test.
RatherBeBiking
I bet he'd love a bike lane on his block. I hope they put one on yours too.
SP
lol@ "thefacts"
spnder
"No, Mr. Norvell, the learning curve never is achieved because there are always new drivers entering Grand Street, who must begin to learn."
That's the worst attempt at logic I've read in a while. And I'd fathom a guess that Mr. Norvell doesn't drive, so like most of us, would welcome bike lanes on our blocks.
thefacts
The spokesman for Transportation Alternatives has the temerity to tell people: "there’s going to be a learning curve for everybody."
No, Mr. Norvell, the learning curve never is achieved because there are always new drivers entering Grand Street, who must begin to learn.
Since, there will always be new drivers entering Grand, so there will always be honking, chaos, confusion and danger.
Those who suffer are not you or your ilk, Mr. Norvell. The suffering is borne by the residents and businesses along Grand Street, who are the tortured guinea pigs in your and DOT's little social experiment.
You want a bike lane, Norvell? Fine, put it on your block, and then you and your family can start talking about 'learning curves'.
SP
That intersection has always been hell, long before the bike lane was put in. West broadway and grand street has a weird bit of one way street below the intersection, so all southbound traffic on west broadway must turn left onto grand. It's always a clusterfuck of cars forced to turn left across the northbound lane. As said in a previous comment, this video proves nothing. If anything, it only shows how bad those small streets are for traffic, most of them should probably be closed to car traffic entirely.
bsalamon
too bad most of the hassidim speak yiddish and not hebrew
virtually the entire increase in New Yorkers’ means of transportation during those robust years occurred in mass transit, with a surge in subway, bus and commuter rail riders.
The Times article failed to account for folks choosing to bicycle commute. The bicycle lanes are working.
WorksInDUMBO
That SUV driver should be ticketed. So should all the freakin SUV drivers who park in the bike lanes ALL.THE.TIME! (So sick of these jerkoffs who have some kind of sense of entitlement because they drive a HUGE-ASSED vehicle that was never intended for city driving/parking.)(and don't even get me started on the SUVs double-parking on Court Street in Brooklyn!)
Spirit of 76
I still see idiots who go the wrong way down one-way streets. How many decades have those streets been around? Let's ban one-way streets!
JMH
Every time I think NYC residents are among the smartest people in the USA, I go and read the comments to a Post article and I realize how stupid some of us are.
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.
Want Gothamist's suggestions on what shows to check out, where to eat, what to buy, where to go for a quick trip? We'll be bringing you some exclusive tips and ideas via email every day! And don't worry—you'll still get a list of our top stories.
Sign up for Gothamist Daily, which will deliver useful tips—plus Gothamist's most popular stories—to your inbox at 11 a.m. This way, you'll be able to plan your week or month as well as catch up on Gothamist if you've stepped away.