Milk Cast Spills: Penn Calls Prop 8 "Manslaughter"

112008milk.jpgJames Franco as real-life gay rights activist Scott Smith, Sean Penn as Harvey Milk. Photo: Phil Bray/Focus Features.

Gus Van Sant’s new film Milk tells the story of Harvey Milk, who in 1977 became the first openly gay man to be elected to a major public office in the United States, only to be assassinated within his first year of serving on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. At turns tragic and exhilarating, the film chronicles the last eight years of Milk’s life (played by Sean Penn), when he worked on campaigns for public office and the protection of gay employees.

Besides Penn, the stellar cast also includes Josh Brolin, James Franco, Alison Pill, and Emile Hirsch. That group joined Gus Van Sant at a press conference yesterday, during which Franco revealed that he wanted to be a part of the film so badly that he would have “played the pool boy” just to be in it. But, thankfully, he plays Milk’s lover, giving the world a steamy Sean Penn and James Franco make out scene! $11 well spent!

2008_11_vansant.jpgAnother tidbit: Van Sant (pictured) said they looked at hours of archival footage for developing the characters and maintaining historical accuracy. (In the film, you'll see snippets of "home movies" from The Hormel Gay and Lesbian Center's archive in San Francisco.) Van Sant also takes pride in using the same Director of Photography (Harris Savides) that Madonna refuses to do any work without: "I thought you know, she must be pretty discerning. I had the Madonna effect. I get to use Madonna’s DP." (And her ex-husband, too.)

Of course, it's impossible to overlook the fact that Milk, which opens Wednesday, is being released on the heels of the Prop 8 passage in California, the same state where Milk helped mobilize the gay community to demand their civil rights. Speaking about Prop 8, Penn said, "It's only an issue because of ignorance in the first place. We don't have any excuse for being ignorant of the law...or ignorant of human history... In fact any support of Prop 8 would be minimally manslaughter. Because human history tells us that teenage boys are going to hang themselves out of a reach for an identity that they can't get.... And if this movie is a part of an engine to help reveal that, that's going to make us all happy and proud."

Email This Entry


Comments (17) [rss]

'In fact any support of Prop 8 would be minimally manslaughter."

Please. Enough with the drama queen hysterics. Now the Stalinist gay lobby wants to classify anyone who doesn't agree with them politically guilty of manslaughter? These people are deranged.

Why is Gus Van Sant using Madonna's name to hype Harris Savides? It's not like this is their first (or second, or third) time working together, and dude shot Elephant and Gerry! Those are way more impressive than any Madonna video.

fun Harris Savides fact: he shot and directed Hanson's MMMBop video. So maybe Milk will have some sweet parking lot rollerblading sequences.

i'm a big supporter of the whole "let the gays get hitched issue" but come the fuck on, this is a BIT of a stretch....

and ides, what in the fuck dude, "stalinist gay lobby" are you on crack?

If Sean Penn feels so strongly about it maybe he should have gotten off his ass and pushed the movie to theaters 6 weeks earlier. It damn well could have made a difference.

seems like someone needs ticket sales

Marriage is for churches, civic unions are for the state. Hetero state marriage if defined by an interpretation of a religious document like the Bible is unconstitutional. It's not the business of the state to interpret the friggin' Bible, or any religious document.

I'm for equal civic unions for all. You wanna be married, go to a church. But it shouldn't be legal unless you have a civic union first. My mother is not married in the eyes of her church because she only had a state marriage, and not a religious marriage in her church. That says it all for me. Poor woman, living in sin for the last 47 years. Not the state's fault, though.

Well then, I guess you won't be getting hitched anytime soon, eh HUGO MEGO?

user-pic

People know what you are talking about when you say you are married. We don't need to create various types of civil unions. Two people, forming a contract, taking on dependencies and liabilities for one another.

And HUGO MEGO is a total gay porn name.


Penn's statement isnt a stretch, its the truth. And if that were YOUR son or brother, you would feel different.

Prop 8 is inherently ignorant.

Saw "Milk" last night - really an amazing film. It's a bit of a tear-jerker.

I've been reading Gothamist for many years. I had no idea there was such a collection of raging homophobes who also read this blog. I'm not really comfortable with knowing that there is such hate behind the words written in many of the comments above.

Perhaps it is time to move on. Thanks Gothamist for years of interesting NYC articles. I'm sorry that your readership is filled with people who stir up negative emotions in others. It's really quite a shame. It may not be fair to judge a publication on its readership but the comments above are not being moderated and at times it feels like this is a soapbox for hatred.

Not really something I want to be part of.

I'm a strong opponent of Proposition 8, and I look forward to seeing the courts overturn it. That being said, I think Penn's hyperbole is a bit over the top.

It's sad to me that this movie has become about Prop 8 only, instead of human rights, generally. I realize the importance of the gay marriage issue and don't want that trivialized, but what about all the other Harvey Milks: Matthew Shepards, Duanna Simpsons, Teish Taylors... etc. Is not fighting for the right to not be killed kinda important too?

I realize the political environment of today has resulted in this sort of focus on one goal... but sheesh...

In the times of Harvey Milk, gay people were being murdered for being gay, now... well crap... nothing has changed.

MILK is nothing but another HETEROPHOBE movie propagated by people who hate the straight lifestyle, because they fail at their natural biological task. That is why they promote gaydom and the act homosizing others.

Stop the lies and come over to truth.

The real hero in the gay activist movement and group is Harry Hay. Why not tell his story? He was homosized as a boy, then went on to start the national gay liberation movement under the premise that man/boy relationships need to be expanded and promoted. He became a principal member and founder of NAMBLA. Until his death he and other members were principal and keynote speakers for the LGBT. He spoke openly about promoting pedophilia and supported marriage between same-sex and men and boys. Prop 8 received millions of dollars in donations from his likes. However, the leaders of the No on 8 anti-family movement want to redefine family to include a mom and her same-sex friend, a man and his boy lover, and a man and his multiple wives. Which is why No on 8 received millions of dollar also from members of polygamist sects and groups in Utah.

It is ashame that these people and activist have so much hate for straights, gays, and themselves that in 1973 homosexual practicing psychiatrist, without factual basis lobbied to remove the DSM 111 code from homosexual activity depriving millions of gays of treatment and forcing them to self medicate with drugs and alcohol.

get the facts that move your movement from www.nambla.org

LOVE IS TRUTH, NOT LIES YOU LIVE BY.
GIVE TRUTH A CHANCE.


Harvey Milks: Matthew Shepards, Duanna Simpsons, Teish Taylors... etc. AND OF COURSE THE MAIN MAN HARRY HAY, THE FOUNDER OF THE GAY LIBERATION MOVEMENT AND NAMBLA, A SELF-PROCLAIMED PEDOPHILE WHO WAS RAPED AS A BOY BY A MAN NAD WAS DECEIVED INTO THINKING IT NORMAL.

By StinaLES And if that were YOUR son or brother, you would feel different.

Since, you asked, it will never be my son or daughter, and I can also say that my son or daughter will never be a pedophile or rapist.If you can not say that, how sad fo ryou as a human being.

But, for you parents who missed the man raping such as Harry hay as a boy, or the thousands of homosexual pedophile priests who raped boys, that a certain percentage grew up to become gay.

Why is it that drug and alcohol addiction runs rampant within the homosexual practicing group? Because, the gay activist have shut the door in the face of those who wish to seek a cure.

Consider this statement, " I was born this way, do you think that I would chose to be this way if I had a choice." Answer- Consider that alcoholics, drug addicts, nicotine addicts and sex addicts have choices but they made a choice to led them to be that way. Just because choices are hard does not mean that they are not choices.

Abstinance is a choice among heterosexual and homosexual sexual practicing people, but how many take that road and rather prefer the road of sexual gratification.

TRUTH IS LOVE.
GIVE TRUTH A CHANCE.
MAKE MOM AND DAD YOUR HERO AND FOLLOW THE PATH OF THE X AND Y CHROMOSOMES.

Your evangelical newspapers don't report about youth ministers getting off to little girls just about "Harvey Hay".

http://www.kiiitv.com/home/13840352.html
http://www.vvdailypress.com/news/points_10183___article.html/victorville_city.html
http://www.news.com.au/couriermail/story/0,27574,24803074-3102,00.html
http://www.gazette.com/opinion/moore_45052___article.html/girl_deal.html
etc
etc
etc

Your truth is not the whole truth is it? Better to point the finger at those that are different than the man/woman in the mirror.

"Take a look at yourself and you might look at others differently" - that's the way the gospel song goes isn't it?

Evangelical newspapers? Last time I checked they were left wing bigots that hate the church. People like Lisa Miller of Times Magazine.

To be fair, I get my information straight from LGBT, NAMBLA, and publicatin about Harvey Milks and Harry Hay.

Harry Hay is the founder of the modern gay rights movement, a pedipohile, and supporter of NAMBLA.

But, the church, yes. 95% of the Catholic priest child molesters were homosexual.

When I look at myself, I know that as a "Human" I like you are targeted for sin by SATAN. I have freed myself, by accepting Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior. By looking at myself, I know that you are in need of Jesus as your savior to fight sin, one being homosexuality (the defiled unnatural use of the body: perversion of what the body was created for)

Thank you, for allowing me to look inside. Did it help?
Jesus is 'The Way", "The Truth", and "The Life". All other path is lost, a lie, and the road to death. It I don't tell you, how will you know.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

The NYS Unemployment website is down, and the phone number has a permanent busy signal.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS