Last week's Republican National Convention sparked passionate debate over the qualifications and treatment of Sarah Palin as well as John McCain's poaching the message of "change" from the Democrats the week prior. Possibly lost in the shuffle was the relatively small amount of airplay given to the 9/11 attacks, especially when compared to how central a theme they were throughout the previous RNC held here in New York. Even Rudy Giuliani didn't spend a great deal of his speaking time hearkening back to 9/11 in comparison with his usual rhetoric.
However, on the final night of the convention (themed "Peace"), Republicans did show a video billed as a "Tribute to 9/11" that aired during the 8:00 hour. The video begins by linking the Iran Hostage Crisis to the 9/11 attacks and then launches into a great deal of graphic imagery from the day of the attacks before its narrator tells us, "This is a war that America will win. We will have a president who knows how."
The video was aired live by CNN and MSNBC. (Ironically, Fox News did not broadcast it live because they were playing Bill O'Reilly's interview with Barack Obama.) Shortly thereafter on MSNBC, a somber Keith Olbermann apologized "as somebody who lost a few friends there" for airing such a graphic video and said that, "It is a subject of great pain for many of us still and it was probably not appropriate to be shown." Those remarks appear to have gotten Olbermann removed from the anchor chair for the rest of MSNBC's election coverage.
Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.
"Drilling for oil in the USA doesn't mean it is OUR oil... it goes to oil companies in the world market and we have to buy it like everyone else."
So now you want it for free?
Get a clue: the more oil there is in the market THE CHEAPER IT BECOMES.
robingee
Hello? I don't think Bin Laden is RIGHT. I am telling you that there are reasons WHY he led this attack, not just because they hate our freedom and lifestyles. But that's the simplistic explanation we GET.
Iraq: read about the Downing Street Memo.
Drilling for oil in the USA doesn't mean it is OUR oil... it goes to oil companies in the world market and we have to buy it like everyone else.
jpeditor
"The reasons that 9/11 happened were due to us having a military presence in the Middle East."
Really? The Saudis, kuwaitis etc INVITED us there - as much as couldn't give two sh*ts for the arab world, you want us to take BIN LADENS perfernces over the Arab govts.
"Bush wants us to believe it was because the militant Islamics "hate our freedom." It's more complex than that, and that is what Democrats want to explain; "
"explain" the fact that islam has been at war with the Judeo-Christian world for 13 centuries.
"But why Iraq? "
Because EVERYONE in BOTH parties thought Sadaam was a danger:
"Why not Saudi Arabia, since most of the hijackers were from there?"
Because the green left won't let us drill for our own oil (hint, petroleum is used to make the computer you use and to deliver the food you eat, not just for the evil SUVs...).
ma bell
nice i found what you are referring to. his ratings beat him for a one week period in june for the first time ever. the catch? o'reilly was on vacation and wasn't hosting his show that week. big time win for olbermann!
i never said billy boy was correct. in fact i think he's an idiot 3/4 of the time. but i think olbermann is an idiot 9/10 of the time.
robingee
ma bell - that was May 08, and in June Olbermann topped Bill-o;
But even if Bill-o has more ratings it doesn't make him correct. The things he says are quite insane and easily disproved with facts. How can he be consistently wrong yet have so many viewers? It's a sad statement on our citizens. I am proud of the people who see and seek out the truth.
Robingee -- it is evident that most voters are too dumb to follow the complex reasoning you present.
robingee
"MSNBC and Barack Hussein Obama all think we got what we deserved on 9/11."
That's not true.
The reasons that 9/11 happened were due to us having a military presence in the Middle East. Bush wants us to believe it was because the militant Islamics "hate our freedom." It's more complex than that, and that is what Democrats want to explain; not just say "hate our freedom" - but explain all of the reasons and how we can resolve the problems. We went into Afghanistan, which is what we should have done. But why Iraq? Why not Saudi Arabia, since most of the hijackers were from there?
robingee
yeah you keep trying too, buddy
jpeditor
MSNBC and Barack Hussein Obama all think we got what we deserved on 9/11.
The rest of us voting for McCain / Palin don't.
NannyState
Think of those guys at the top of NBC with their black S.U.V.s and hunting lodges in Jackson Hole. They are part of that conservative cabal that controls Big Media and while they toyed with the idea of an upstart ratings grabber like Olberman breathing new life into a cable outlet that has underperformed for so long that everyone has wondered when GE's "Number One or Number Two in its category or it's dropped" policy would kick in, these bastards have fallen back to the predictable NBC habit of eating their young. At least McCain is happier.
ma bell
yes i apologize. i meant demoted. again, you don't get demoted unless the powers feel that you don't get the ratings...which he doesn't. you must have another read on this, cause nielson says o'reilly trounces olbermann...no competition.
His show is still on and has higher ratings than O'Reilley.
It does? I have heard Olbermann has higher numbers in the 18 to 30 demographic but that's all. He beat O'Reilly a few times in late spring when he had certain guests on his show like Scott McClellan. Do you have a source?
chuzzlewit
i think they're on to something here with their niftily post modern blurring of the lines between states of "war" and "peace" - who needs that kind of crispness in their lives anyway? let's just acknowledge the best we can do is a hazy general state of panic and violence, and let's call it "weace".
that way we can be more specific when we invade countries and stuff like that -like "we are the americans, and we come to bring you weace!"
starrygordon
... Olbermann's "I'm sorry you had to see that" response struck me as way over-the-top and smarmy.
I was there, I witnessed the attack on the World Trade Center, and I am really sick of people trying to exploit it. Had I been in Olbermann's place I would have said exactly the same thing, with absolute sincerity.
robingee
Olbermann wasn't fired, ma bell. He will just be a correspondent at the elections now, and not an anchor. Read a little. His show is still on and has higher ratings than O'Reilley.
books
as jeffk said the real story is that they are tying 9/11 to the 1970 IRANIAN hostage crisis...so that americans will support miltary action by the US or israel against IRAN
takethecanoli
It's one thing to pay tribute to tragedy and its victims; it's another to shamelessly exploit it as nationalistic propaganda.
ma bell
what a load of crap. olbermann was fired cause nobody watched him. those with good ratings do not get fired no matter what their opinions are. o'reilly has said some pretty whacky stuff himself but since he draws a huge audience, he stays. olbermann simply was not a big enough draw.
and you bash the repubs for showing a tribute to 9/11? what? i mean seriously? what? you can't come up with something better then bashing them for showing a tribute to 9/11 and saying that it will never happen again? seriously? come on people. your grasping at straws. stick to the bush bashing. at least that makes sense.
moocow
i always wonder what the rest of the country thinks about the fact that the two places the attacks directly affected are overwhelmingly blue states. and that nyc kinda hated/hates guiliani.
Gothamist_Cynic
it was pretty sickening to watch the republicans cheer after showing 9/11 footage at the RNC.
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.
Want Gothamist's suggestions on what shows to check out, where to eat, what to buy, where to go for a quick trip? We'll be bringing you some exclusive tips and ideas via email every day! And don't worry—you'll still get a list of our top stories.
Sign up for Gothamist Daily, which will deliver useful tips—plus Gothamist's most popular stories—to your inbox at 11 a.m. This way, you'll be able to plan your week or month as well as catch up on Gothamist if you've stepped away.